Rated 4.45 out of 5 stars
I've used powders, waxes, shadow, and all kinds of pencils. I've been growing my brows out for over a year now (slow going thanks to years of overplucking) and still have major sparse areas. A few swipes with the spoolie, soft "line" just above and below brows, then fill in...spoolie quickly again to soften color, and tiny bit of wax to keep them set. I did both in less than 5 minutes, and also used the NYX "magic" pencil to highlight/clean up. Highly recommend both! Side note - I was really unsure what color to get. I'm a natural light/medium ash brunette, but I dye it much darker. I hate any orange/red tones, and taupes just kinda of look "off." I got the ash brown pencil, and it's PERFECT!
I was super excited to see this new product! Finally an affordable mechanical pencil! I purchased the color blonde and auburn. I was very disappointed with the colors. The color blonde was extremely yellow! My hair color is blonde and I usually use ABH brow wiz in taupe. And that is even a little too dark for me. But the NYX blonde looked terrible. Borderline high lighter yellow! There is no "ash blonde" or "taupe" just a scary yellow lol. As for the auburn color. It was ok. I used it in my sister. She is a red head. I had to put a darker powder over it. It is good for a light red head. The quality of the pencils are great! The colors need major improvement!
Madi from Poplar Bluff, Mo
I love how thin this pen is! It helps when i am just wanting to fill my brows in a little bit and have a more natural look.
Cynthia from North Central West Virginia
I am pleased with this brow pencil and spoolie.
I have been searching for the perfect shade of brow pencil and the Gray matched well for my platinum hair color and porcelain skin tone. I can control the intensity of the color. It blends nicely with the spoolie brush. It looks natural. I would buy again.
esther from Maryland
love it! the main eyebrow pencil ive used for 8 years
Chyna from Port Charlotte, fl
This is not bad at all!! The price point is great!!! I usually use anastasia brand this one works just as great!!
LT from CO
Ive tried so many different brow pencils, high end and cheap ones. This is by far my favorite. Wear it everyday to fill in patches. Glides on easily and stays until I remove it!
Molly from Toledo, OH
I have naturally dark red hair, but my eyebrows are more of a brown color, so I use blonde pencils. Everytime I use NYX the blonde color looks orange. Other than the color issue, the product is easy to use and stays all day. I have bought two tubes of this, and it happened both times, so I know this is not a fluke.
scarlet from fresno ca
been using this since 2021 and havent stopped using it, the best eyebrow pencil everr
Mary from Grand Rapids, MI
I bought this to replace another fluff and fill pencil I use. I think I like the bigger one better. This one is very small and takes a bit more patience and time to get all the short strokes to fill in the brows. Not bad tho. Maybe just not for me.
Bailey from Tx
My fav brow pencil
BVaz from Jasper, IN
This is my favorite affordable eyebrow pencil. It works great, it's lasting and pigmention is good as well. It applies smoothly and blends well. The spooly is not the best and you can't tell when you are almost out but everything else is pretty great. I will continue to use and do recommend.
Sun from Schaumburg,IL
Did not have black in Loreal so I landed up buying NYX and it was a good choice!
Leslie from Chicago
The color matches my natural eyebrows perfectly. I have a caramel complexion. This lasts all day. NYX has never changed it and I hope they never do!
Nya from FL
I bought at least 20 of these! Never disappoints me!!
Whit from Dallas, TX
This is THE best micro brow pencil for the best price on the market. Period. I have been repurchasing this brow pencil for more than 5 years. It's a staple in my makeup routine.
Jan from Riverside,NJ
I am a dyed auburn fair w green eyed girl. So i pick auburn way too light and red brunette snd chocolate too dark. Taupe works when im tan but i get ash brown. Dont understand but it works. Doesn't cover grey eyebrows but I dont want them too dark. I havd very sparse long eyebrows. Horrible. But I've been penciling them in for years. Outside Anastasia this brand has made them look as natural as they could look and I get compliments. So ill keep buying!
gracie h from los angeles, ca
As I recently died my hair & brows copper I struggled to find brow products that matched my hair since many brands only carry brown/black/blonde colors but nyx never disappoints !!! they have so many shades that work so perfectly and their auburn shades match so well!! So easy to use and great price point.
tJane from Michigan
I absolutely LOVE this brow pencil. Glides on effortlessly. Fills in perfecrtly. Only thing is, before I knew it, it was empty. 😩
Katherine from NJ
After searching all over for a brow pencil that isn't too warm I came across Cool Ash Brown. It is the first and only pencil I've found that matches my brows without warm tones. Finally!
JMomma2 from Midwest
I have gotten complements on my brows from this that I have never gotten before. I had trouble for years trying to do my brows right and naturally and this product is it!! I think it builds up nice if you want more drama, stays on skin for thin or bald patches and stays all day. Its also pretty eaay to get off when you want to with makeup remover but doesn't melt off in heat. Its actually a perfect product and a good price!
Ricky from Philadelphia, PA
I'm a brunette and I feel like all of the brown pencils havd a red hue. I returned the first one and bougut a different color and it still looks red. Will go back to buying the benefit brow
Megan from Medford, NJ
I have dark brown eyebrows so bought espresso because it was the darkest shade. It showed up light brown when i applied it.
CARLA from Longview, Tx
It's good for the cost of this product. Just to fill in the brows.
Lisa from Kent, WA
I felt the color was much lighter than the box showed it to be and it was difficult to apply to my brows.
Black is perfect black. It isnt too opaque and not not patchy, just right natural look. It stays on and doesnt fade unnaturally like a powder. I have bate spots that are growing in and it covers beautifully. Great for work and everyday too, not cakey or fake looking. It takes no time to apply. I like it better than abh because its way cheaper and stays on longer. This is a new fav!