Rated 4.35 out of 5 stars
I have five different colors now and love the application and staying power...However, I do not like the glittery shimmery look on my aging eyes...Please, please come out with more matte shades. Would love to have some light ones for highlighting...almost white, vanilla, cream, nude....just no sparkles...Maybe you could develop a sparkle stick to add to matte shades and your customers would always have the choice...
I agree with some other reviewers in that we older women don't want to sparkle all over and really would LOVE some chubby sticks in matte. You would attrack a completely different type customer because there are not any matte shadows like this. Please HURRY!!
Jenn from TN
Good product. Works well. Goes on smooth.
Catherine from New Orleans
Finally! An eyeshadow stick for sensitive skin and eyes that does NOT crease or fade and is waterproof! Make more colors Clinique!
Beachhippy from Virginia Beach
I have repurchased this eyeshadow stick about 3 or 4 times. It stays all day, doesn't bother my sensitive eyes, and makes me look awake. I love the no-mess aspect of this. I was using a loose eyeshadow before that was quite messy. I appreciate not having to carry a brush when I travel too.
Redwood Girl from Northern California
I love the Clinique Crayons! The lip, eyes, blush: excellent and Sustainably packaged. Perfection and easy to apply. I am 56, and lifelong Clinique fan. Apply Moisture Surge, wait. Then, smooth color(s) onto eyelids for dramatic look; like crayons, easily use! Also, the cheek blush 'Ample Apple' is a MUST!! VERY tempted to buy other shades just to experiment! Perhaps during the next wonderful offer! Lightweight. Travel friendly (why I sooo love the sample sizes: perfect!). Thank you, Clinique!
Parker from Arizona
It's always so hard to tell on a website exactly what the texture of an eyeshadow is going to be. But, I took a chance on these products because Clinique has a fairly good reputation. I bought four of these, and I looked very carefully at the color palette so that I understood, I thought, that what I was buying was a matte shadow. They aren't. They are quite, quite glimmery. Not an outright frost, but a lot more glimmer than one needs on a mature eyelid. I'm probably never going to be able to use these. To top it all off, they are quite hard. And I say this as a person who went outside in 104° weather to retrieve this box. one would think they would be melty, but I experimented with them while they were still warm to the touch from having been outside and I had to warm them up on my fingertip to apply them. I'm completely unhappy with these, I'm so sorry that I bought them. If it honestly wasn't more trouble than I wanted to go to I would return them.
Tricia from Atlanta, GA
I am a first-time user of the Chubby Stick Shadow Tint. I love it! It is so easy to apply and takes less time than applying powdered shadow. I use the color, Lots o Latte, and it works perfectly with my blue eyes. Now I want a shadow stick for a color similar to sugar cane to swipe right under my brows. Hint, hint, Clinique!
Molly from California
I really like this product. It's the right amount of creamy that I can blend it for a subtle look, but it's not oily and does not dry leaving my eyelid feeling cakey. Works great on the lower lash line as well. I just wish there were more (earthy) colors!
Lvn2laugh from Carson City, NV
I bought the Lavish Lavender — looks great in the photo and even in person. The color is just too sheer. Even multiple layers don't make it darker.
Jodi from Parker, Co
This eyeshadow is amazing! It is so easy to apply and the color looks great. It is much more simple than the regular eye shadow palettes and I will never go back! I would love to see more color options someday.
Carolyn from Ponte vedra beach fl
This was very dry from the first time i opened it. I keep trying to go back to it but just to much trouble. I would not recommend.
Kk from Bama
This shadow looks great and stays on.
Sgrina from Jacksonville, Florida
Recently I've noticed a ton of these types of products online so tried an alternate brand and Clinique. Both the shadows ended up looking fine however the alternate brand's stick was much thinner and it was much easier to apply straight to the lid itself. I would love to see these chubby sticks in a slim stick, it would be a big improvement.
Cdawg from Lancaster PA
I tried the latte color on in store with the help of an employee and liked it, but when I got it home I was surprised how difficult it was to use and get a nice looking application. I probably should return it because I think it's just old and dried out. It's nowhere near as creamy as others I've tried. Doesn't glide on. When I try to blend it it either still looks patchy or just kind of disappears. I have to apply over a base cream eyeshadow or concealer because this product alone does not cancel out the discoloration on my eyelids.
SandyL from Wyoming
I have most of the colors of the Chubby Sticks for eyes. Beautiful and creamy and easy to layer/add another dimension with different colors. I happened to put them all in a zip lock bag for storage and easy access, and have had no problems with them drying out, even after a couple years. I'm back to see if there are any more colors that I missed! Wish you had a rosy pink though, that would be perfect. And if there's a sharpener for them please let me know?
Kathleen from Gainesville, FL
I love this Chubby Eye Stick! Have read reviews that said the stick dries out and am hoping this doesn't happen to mine. At 74, I never thought I could find an eyeshadow that wouldn't crease on me but this one doesn't!
This eye tint is very easy to put on and is nice and subtle. My eyes are blue and the shade I got really goes with them. Another thing is that this tint does not crease and is very easy to wear. I love it!
LolaD from NyNy
These are excellent one and done or mix and have fun easy eye shadows. I first bought lots o latte and was so impressed I went back and buy every color! And love every one! Just so easy to apply blend and create a beautiful eye!
Cathy from Woodstock, GA
This goes on so smooth..I put this all over my eyelids and then I put on my eyeliner..Game changer..Eyeliner glides on..
Kim from Crescent Springs, KY
Love this product but like a previous reviewer, it dries out even though I put lid on after every use. I do apply it with my fingertips for smoother application. I highly recommend that the product would come in a creamer form so I could dip my finger in to apply.
Marjorie from Aurora Colorado
I am 70 yrs old. Do not wear much makeup anymore. But do like eyeshadow. Was looking for a cream type shadow. This crayon is ok. I have to apply over lid a few times to see the color. Would be nice to just swipe once and be done.
Emma from New York
These chubby sticks are so easy to use and the colors are great!
Hi from Hawaii
I chose Fuller Fudge, which looks dark online but applies as a highly wearable medium brown with a slight shimmer. When new, the product is creamy and easy to apply. However, after about six months the stick became dry, even though I was conscientious about replacing the cap tightly after each use. I still have a lot of product remaining, so I am disappointed with the short lifespan of this eyeshadow. Nevertheless, I would still recommend and repurchase it.
Kay from Texas
This was a repurchase for my daughter and yes she loves it!
Karen from Wakefield Rhode Island
Would not buy again
ShadyLady from Seattle
I have been moving away from powders as I age and tried these while searching for creamier formulas. I loved the subtle glow and dimension they added as soon as I tried one in the store. It glides on smoothly like a balm, blends easily and is so fast and simple to apply- just a swipe and a couple of taps with a finger to smooth the edges and that's it. They are very sheer, but with enough tint to add some depth and contour. The shimmer is fine enough that to me it reads more like a satin finish in most lighting. I started with the coal and lilac, and found it so effortless and pretty that I eventually bought all the other colors, which work together well and are somehow all flattering. These chubby stick eye tints fit right into my minimal makeup routine, and I love being able to add a quick sheer wash of color to my eyes without any fuss. It does fade over the course of the day (I haven't tried it with a primer), but doesn't seem to crease. These are quickly becoming a daily staple.