Rated 3.83 out of 5 stars
LA Girl is a solid drugstore brand that is good quality and the price can't be beat. This eyeliner is no different and doesn't disappear. The formula is great and stays on all day. Yhe color is opaque which I like. I dont have to go over it a few times like other more expensive brands. The pen reminds me of a Sharpie marker from the packaging to the applicator in the best way possible. It's my go to every single day when do mg makeup. I'll be buying this again, buying the brown, and recommending it to my friends.
I've been hunting for a replacement black eyeliner for a few months now, so I gave this one a try. Overall, it's a fairly mid product, in my opinion. While the black is dark and the applicator tip is well-shaped, I found that the product tended to dry out mid-swipe as I was applying it. I had to place the cap on it to pump more product out of the tip so I could finish off my eye. The packaging is alright and didn't cause any issues (as I've had some that have caused product to bleed out of the tip and create a massive, inky mess). I would say it's overall alright, though not the best if you're looking to do a cat-eye or winged liner look, as the felt tip doesn't offer a lot of precision when the product tends to dry out quickly.
Cynthia from Syracuse, NY
Easy flow, fine lines love this.
Mari from Bay Area, CA
"Stumbled upon a great find! This lives up to its description, goes on smoothly, gives my aging skin a sharp line, and is smudgeproof. It's comparable to the Rare Beauty liner, but in my opinion, much better. Honestly, beats out most high-end eyeliners I've ever bought!"
Ren from Fort Worth, TX
Lidia from Mesa, AZ
Another eyeliner that did not work for me. I'm on a hunt to find an eyeliner that is easy to apply and lasts all day and this one is not it. It does go on easily and is easy to apply, that is why I'm giving it 2 stars. But it doesn't last. Sometimes my eyes get watering and when that happens this eyeliner comes off completely. I had high hopes for this eyeliner but was once again disappointed.
Jane from Kansas City
I wanted a more affordable brown liquid liner than KVD and this was not it. I have to press really hard to get the right payoff and depth of color. Will stick to KVD.
marg from texas
the product itself was good but idk if i had a broken one but the lid would not stay on and would pop off randomly so it dried out after like 2 weeks
starpower9 from Saint Louis, MO
Easy to apply and does the job. My eyes are just sensitive and it made them burn/sting…have to return
Jackie from Indianapolis, IN
Sil from California
It really stays on! I was surprised i usually use the NYX liner but i started using this one and it really worked well. Stayed on the lid after 4 + hours in the pool. Was really surprised to see it on after those hours.
Great for wing liner
Betty from Ontario, CA
I usually use the Stila liquid eyeliner, after hearing about this liner & trying it, i no longer need to spend 24 dollars on an eyeliner! Even with the most oily eyes, it stayed in place, did not run, and is so pigmented! A must have for sure!
Fab from Rancho Cucamonga
Love it! Bought th black Artist pen, great formula! Stays on ALL day, easy removal.
Precise tip! Will definitely purchase again.