Rated 4.53 out of 5 stars
I am so happy I found this New Falsies Surreal Mascara. The best thing is that it gets a rating of a 2 on the Environmental Working Group, ewg.org website. I love using cleaner safe products. This mascara performs so well that it doesn't smudge or flake at all and washes off easily. I only use fragrance free, BHT free products and this one fits the bill. I wish all your cosmetics rated like this one!
I love push up falsies so they got me with their surreal commercials. This tube has been open two days and it's disgusting. I have a video that shows it better but I'm
not uploading it to YouTube just to be able to submit it. After inserting and removing the wand it pulls a bunch of mascara out with the wand, and I wipe the wand on the tube and almost all the mascara comes right off the wand. Application is all clumping goo just like the clumping goo in the photos. Maybe I got a bad tube ….but it's not something I'm going to waste my money on again. Very very disappointing. Maybe I'm just mad at myself for falling for fake advertising.
Ang85 from PA
In 35++ years of wearing makeup, this mascara is absolutely, positively THE BEST drugstore mascara I have ever tried. I use a primer as always, but the length is amazing! I've received so many compliments since I started wearing this mascara. Stays on, doesn't flake nor smudge. I rarely buy drug store and have several other higher end mascaras in my rotation and I'm ONLY reaching for this one daily! Highly recommend you give it a try!
kassiag1 from undisclosed
The Maybelline Falsies Surreal mascara gives great coverage and a full lash look! Smooth application and sleek packaging. The mascara lasts all day, and washed off easy. 10/10 recommendation!
buhbine7 from undisclosed
Im loving the bold design on it. The wand is amazing has so many different size bristles so helps get every lash eve. Best part no clumping action. Stay on all day.
pinkpixietx from undisclosed
This is a AWESOME 😎 drugstore mascara! I would definitely recommend this!! I absolutely recommend you try it out and see what you think, but it worked great, definitely one of my new favorites!
izzymull from undisclosed
Personally, I don't really like clumpy mascaras as I love a more natural look! Yet, the color was amazing and when i just used the mascara on the ends of my lashes I loved the look.
jennicajune from undisclosed
This mascara makes your lashes look so volumized that they look like they're extensions! It doesn't clump, and goes on nice! I liked this mascara and will buy again.
caitlinn41 from undisclosed
I switched to this mascara for everyday use and I've never had so many compliments on my lashes! People keep asking if I use some kind of serum because they look so much longer than usual but in reality it's just this mascara!!!
kelseyxsantos from undisclosed
This is 10 out of 10 amazing, my lashes looked BEAUTIFUL, it didn't clump, it didn't smudge, its water resistant, gave me defined lashes super curled and a nice volume, APPROVED ✅❤️
smalltowninfluencer from undisclosed
I am obsessed with this mascara. OBSESSED. I will be purchasing this again, recommending to everyone, and honestly would give a 10/5 if I could. I have been a loyal Stan to another mascara, but I think this one is my new staple/favorite/go to. I love the packaging, the wand, how easy it is to apply. Everything.
__l1 from undisclosed
Very good mascara, I like how it makes my eyelashes long, it lasts a long time and does not fall off. I've been using only Maybelline mascara for over 4 years now, but I really liked this one, so I'd buy it again
nwzhang from undisclosed
This product looks very natural on the eyelash and I absolutely love the mascara brush. There are never any clumps on my eyelashes and really enhances my makeup look. I only took off a star because this mascara isn't great at holding a curl on my straight eyelashes.
karenw0e8d from undisclosed
I absolutely love Maybelline Falsies Surreal Extensions Washable Meta Black mascara!!! I received this product from Maybelline and Influenster in exchange, for my honest review. This mascara was easy to apply. It did not clump during application and two coats was perfect. The color was perfect and it absolutely made my lashes look long and defined. While not quite false, they looked really good! The mascara did not flake, and I wore it from 6 o'clock in the morning all the way until bedtime at 10 PM without a single flake. It was easy to remove using micellar water. I didn't have to tug or pull on my lashes or wipe really hard to remove. I have very sensitive eyes and this product did not make my eyes itch or burn or irritate them in any way. This was a great mascara from application to removal and it looked great all day. I would definitely re-purchase!!!
stephanies221 from undisclosed
I actually liked this mascara and would have loved to make it my new go-to. It went on easily, built quickly and cleanly, and wore really well throughout the day. Unfortunately I had some sort of reaction to it and had to toss it. I do think it's a good product, just not for me.
crystalt158 from undisclosed
Incentivized-I received this product for free from Influenster and Maybelline for free in exchange for my honest review. I am impressed with this product! I chose to apply on uncurled lashes, showing the difference between coats 1 and 2. I love how dramatically different each coat is, so depending on the mood you can tone it down or turn it up. I do get a small bit of transfer on my lower lashes, but I dont mind. After about 5 hours, and really looking, I could see very small specs of fallout. It also stays put and does not run. Maybelline is not a brand I normally reach for, but this one I will absolutely buy!
jbt2 from undisclosed
I received this Maybelline Falsies Surreal Mascara from Influenster & Maybelline for my honest review. I thought the mascara gave my lashes nice length & volume but I did notice some flaking on my face through out the day. It's a good Mascara but not the best.
taylorc376 from undisclosed
This is a good basic mascara. It did mot do anything crazy for me lengthening wise, but it did help with thickness. The formula makes for a very smooth application!
vanessas294 from undisclosed
At first, I hated it. I'm not the type that likes clumpiness. But, if you use it as a lengthener with a smoother formulated mascara, this can create a really nice look. Just like falsies. I'm going to keep practicing and find the right technique to use. I think this stuff has real potential.
fairskinnedblonde from undisclosed
Falsies is an accurate name for this mascara. I got to try the Maybelline New York the Falsies Surreal meta black mascara. This is a rich dark black full coverage mascara. It's very easy to build long false looking lashes. It stays on all day with very little fall out. I like this mascara and it will definitely be included in my routine of makeup. Definitely recommend this mascara especially because it's easy to get at your local drugstore and it's not outrageously priced.
helenaw25 from undisclosed
This mascara is good for the price. It gives you the length without clumping but you will need to curl your lashes a bit to get that lift. Alone it gives you nice length and no spider legs which I find to be a problem with cheaper mascaras! I really enjoy it for a natural day where I don't wanna put on a full face or anything heavy. It's nice!
renizzle from undisclosed
This mascara give the best falsie results that I have seen. No falsie prices or time at the lash salon make this mascara my new go to for the sexiest fullest lashes!
bodycarecollective from undisclosed
I've been using this mascara everyday for a month and I have to say I love the color. The deep black really makes your lashes pop! However, I noticed it DOESN'T last. It was under my eye within two hours. I tried multiple different mascara primers and still the same:( I really wanted to love this product especially how much it popped my lashes, but the smudging is a little bit of a dealbreaker.
emilyd308 from undisclosed
Maybelline Falsies Surreal Extensions Mascara in Meta Black claims to extend your lash reality with +36% length and surreal impact with 10X volume. I liked trying this product, provided by Influenster for my honest review, and I think that this mascara does add volume and extend my
lashes really well in just one coat. I thought the brush was effective and easy to use, even in the corners of my eyes. I did not see flaking after several hours of wear, the color stayed put and didn't end up under my bottom lashes. I recommend trying this product and will continue to use it because I enjoy how it looks.
brittc18 from undisclosed
I like the applicator. It seperates the lashs while adding volume and length. It's a nice long wearing mascara. Normally mascara irritates my eyes after a days wear but this one does not.
makeupandluxe from undisclosed
I received the Maybelline Falsies Srl Ext WSH Mascara in Meta Black free from @influenster and @mabelline in exchange for my honest review. Let me first start off by saying that I am very picky about my mascara. For a mascara to work for me it needs to be thickening, lengthening, and doesn't flake. This mascara delivers in all three of these areas. The wand is fluffy so it grabs a lot of product to deposit on my lashes. The mascara goes on thick but it's not clumpy. I am impressed with how thick and long this makes my top lashes. The meta black color gives my lashes definition without being too dark for my fair/medium complexion. I can wear it all day without any flaking! Once it goes on it stays on but can be removed easily with basic makeup remover. The only thing that I would caution is that due to the wand size it is a bit hard to maneuver on my bottom lashes. This is something that typically comes with any thickening/lengthening mascara so its a trade off that I am willing to make for longer/thicker top lashes. Overall, this mascara has quickly become one of my favorites. I highly recommend!
saamimori from undisclosed
I really like this Maybelline mascara! It is very lengthening and voluminous. It is a great drugstore mascara product. The color is the perfect black.