Rated 4.22 out of 5 stars
I love my new Milani Cosmetics - Highly Rated Lash Extensions Mascara. It definitely makes my lashes look fuller and longer. I love that it stays on my lashes and never flakes off on my face. It truly makes my lashes look extended. It easily comes off with my makeup remover wipes. I highly recommend this mascara if you are looking for a premium product that is definitely going to give you a longer, fuller lash look.
I loved the tubing mascara idea it gives my lashes great lengths however I wouldn't say it give the appearance of lash extensions. Even though I curl my lashes throughly they still end up dropping almost instantly after applying mascara. I so like how easy it is to wipe off/remove.
O from Indianapolis
This may be better for people with naturally curled eyelashes like anotehr reviewer said. It gave my lashes no curl, volume, or lift which I look for in a mascara. I wanted to like it but I'm disappointed
Sandy from Hanford, CA
The mascara is too wet, causing it to clump up and not layer well. I tried using it with another brush and it helped a little but its not worth the effort to do that every single time. Only good thing is that it doesnt smudge on hooded eyes.
Kim from Albuquerque, NM
Only mascara that doesnt run under my eyes.
kami from tulsa
I hadn't tried a tubing mascara in over 10yrs, & that one took 2 steps. I have hooded eyes, oily lids, & sometimes watery eyes. I've tried a lot of mascaras & they all either flake, smudge, run, or have wand that's too big. I don't have any of those problems with this mascara. The only problems I have are clumps, which I can work with, & the formula is pretty wet, but I have a hand fan that I use after setting spray anyway.
A from Homer
Really wanted to love it, but it's really liquidy and clumpy on me :(
Em from New York, NY
This is the first tubing mascara I've ever tried and overall I really like it! I don't have other tubing mascaras to compare it to, but I can definitely tell it's a tubing mascara upon application. It's VERY lengthening and I noticed it has significantly less clumps than non-tubing mascaras. And most off all it truly doesn't smudge or flake!! I have super oily eyelids and always get mascara transfer on my upper and lower eyelids as well as flakes on my cheeks by the end of the day (even with waterproof mascara), but this one did not transfer or flake!! I'm so impressed. The only downside is that I have very straight lashes and prefer something that has a strong curl hold. This mascara lifts my lashes but does not hold a strong curl. Something that has helped me is using a curl holding primer before applying the mascara. I also noticed it can make my lashes group together if I'm not careful about letting each coat dry properly. I recommend doing thin coats and waiting until each layer has dried if you plan on doing multiple coats. Overall I really love this mascara and I think it might be my new go-to day-to-day!
Jord from Honolulu
I bought this mascara to save money (vs. getting the Tartelette tubing mascara) and glad I tried it, but it's not for me. I have long, straight lashes. Might be great for short/natually curled lashes. This doesnt keep my shape, it results in more of a straight out lash instead of curl. The ends of your lashes are supposed to be elongated by the tubing effect, but instead they look odd. I'm good at doing my mascara and this isn't it.
Alyssa from New York
I decided to try some new mascara and I unfortunately shouldn't have wasted the money. This product made my eyelashes clump together. The formula seems very watery. Wouldn't recommend
CherryCherrie from Eden Prairie, MN
I bought this as a dupe for the Thrive Cosmetics lengthening mascara. It is literally the exact same color and highlights the same features. I thought it would be a cheaper alternative but this was like any other drugstore mascara and not a good one. If you dont have a lot of lashes to begin with it doesn't really do anything.
Adrienne from PA
It doesn't appear to lengthen or add volume as much as regular mascara. It's wet feeling, makes lashes stick together, doesn't apply as nicely as regular mascara. Tried it multiple times. Disappointing.
Amari from Honolulu, Hawaii
Yes, this will take a long time to build up if you dont do it right as its not a regular mascara. But all you have to do is wait a minute or two between coats to build up the volume!
PomchiQueen from Irvine, CA
Ive tried the expensive tubing mascaras. And some didnt even remove easily as it should. But now i will never go back! This is the best mascara!! No smudges and removes with just water. I would recommend to let it dry a bit between coats to build it up and only do up to teo coats.
ella from New Orleans
way too wet upon application, does not build well, weighs down my eyelashes getting rid of the curl, and not as lengthening as I was expecting at all.
meh from Columbus
I have fine lashes so this mascara weighed them down after they dried. also because I have fine lashes, the brush was not ideal. the nubs that are supposed to apply product and separate your lashes are too short so there is no proper distribution. my lashes all clumped together immediately. I did however like how black it was. might be the darkest color I've seen from a mascara. the formula seemed fine, it just needs a better wand.
Katie P from Stow, OH
I really wanted to love this mascara, but it's just not it. It leaves my kashes so clumpy and spidery looking, and the formula is SO wet so it doesn't really build. Once it does dry it flakes so bad. This unfortunately went in the trash.
Marci from Los Angeles, CA
Love this tubing mascara for every day use. It takes a bit of time to dry and I only do 2 layers so that it doesn't get spidery. Definitely provides more length rather than volume, so I still use a different mascara if I want a thicker look as this one isn't the best to layer.
Over50 from Pinehurst, NC
I have wanted to like this mascara and have tried it a half a dozen times. It is so wet my lashes clump together, even when I clean the brush off before applying and it takes a very long time to dry. Reading the reviews, start to wonder, if there's some kind of a manufacturing glitch or if people have different expectations for mascara. I would not recommend this product.
T from undisclosed
Great lengthening mascara and it's so easy to remove too!
Mar from Newark, NJ
I curled my lashes and put this on and literally watched thr curl fall right before my eyes. It looked like i already had mascara on all day long but it wasnt even for 30 seconds.
Emily from Charlotte, nc
this mascara is the best mascara i've ever tried . I am not a waterproof 24 hour type of mascara girl , but for me everyday quick mascara , quick clean up . it's perfect . Makes my lashes long & volumized. Would purchase 1000 again .
RM from Columbus, OH
I normally like products from Milani, but this is a no for me. The formula is way too messy/wet, and it drops any and all curl from my lashes.
Mrs. Turner from Los Angeles, CA
I've been using the Thrive Causemetics tubing mascara for years. This Milani mascara is supposed to be a solid dupe for the TC one, but I can't get on board with that. The immediate results were nothing like the TC product and by the end of the day this was flaking. I wanted to love this but i just can't.
Pinky from NC
This mascara was very wet feeling and did not give my lashes volume, instead it made them look spidery almost like sticks! After a week of using, I ended up throwing it away! Just awful!
Janet Pequin from Marshall MN
Great product. I have very sparce lashes. Makes them look fuller.
I absolutely love this mascara. I am on my third tube and I have NEVER bought the same mascara three times, especially in a row. My lashes are short but curly if that helps anyone. Easy to remove and no raccoon eyes!