Rated 4.46 out of 5 stars
this is the best felt tip liner i have ever used! i actually have tried several different brands, and almost all of them just dry out. this one has not, it's so incredibly black, and the tip comes to a very fine point so you can get the perfect wing. and since it's just such a perfect eyeliner, it's so easy to use and quick. i love. i could probably say this is holy grail status. everyone needs this.
First off: I'm a diehard stila Stay All Day Waterproof Eyeliner gal, but I'm willing to try other options that I lauded by others and I can get cheaper (because let's be honest, we're all trying to save a buck on our makeup).
I bought this eyeliner for two reasons: It was on sale (50%!) and a YouTuber I watch recommended it as one of her favorite eyeliners (as a fellow monolid, I trusted ... and I was let down ... but no spoilers yet). For an eyeliner that costs almost as much as stila eyeliner when not on sale, I expected it to at least have a fighting chance. Not so. Within 2 hours of applying, when I looked in the mirror, it had smudged all over my inner and outer corners ... how embarrassing! This doesn't happen with the stila ... ever. Not to mention, the felt tip on it is super rigid and doesn't allow for as much flex to get the perfect flick. Maybe this would be better suited for someone that is new to the eyeliner game and doesn't have a steady hand, but I found it limiting in application. And the product didn't come out as nicely when applied. I had to reapply in some areas.
Overall, very disappointing experience, and now I have two Eyeko eyeliners I won't be using again. #thumbsdown
Lacey from Nevada
This eyeliner was so dried out when i opened it the first time I couldn't even use it
Maria from Houston tx
I ordered this product and when it came in I was not able to use it because when I opened it it was so dried out
MoxiRox from St. Louis, MO
My hands are the most unsteady hands on the planet Earth. That being said, not only is application easy, it is pigmented and dries down smooth and matte. I got a sample size a while ago in an Ipsy box and now this is all I use. I have oily eyelids too.
DD from Evansville, IN
I swear by eyeko liner. This is the only liquid liner I will use and I think im on my 6th or 7 skinny liquid eyeliner. These last so long you will keep using it and using it but when you finally cave and get a new one and it glides on so smoothly you will remember why this stuff is the best.
j from Tucson
The tip dries out too quickly. I've found that I can continue to use it, if I dip the tip in water. I may try the Stila brand next time to see if it's any better.
Nioe from Newhall, California
Wasn't able to use product. Dried out.
Lisa from WA
I use this to line the base of my upper lashes (almost the waterline, but not quite) and it makes my eyes pop without giving me a heavy line of eyeliner! The black is ultra black, doesn't budge, and doesn't flake. Lasts all day and doesn't irritate my eyes.
Cal from New York
I bought this product because it had great reviews but it feels dried out when applying and it flakes a lot definitely do not recommend
Thank you eyeko! from Home
My favorite liquid eyeliner ever! Even with oily eyelids this eyeliner lasts all day on me and it's super black and smooth! Brush tip is the perfect size!
Coco from Kentucky
I got a sample of this in one of my Ipsy bags and I just ran out and let me tell you... this is by far the best eyeliner that I've ever used! It is very pigmented unlike some sheer eyeliners I've tried. I have very watery eyes and some eyeliners just start smearing all over my face when my eyes start to tear up, but this one doesn't do that. It stays ALL DAY. I highly recommend.
uknothatgurl from Chicago
easy to use! I wasnt a fan of liquid eyeliner till a friend said it was good. now, i use strictly
Lisa from Anaheim, CA
I put it on in the morning, get through my serving shift and the eyeliner is on the bottom of my corner lids. The inner corners/bottom of my lids are grey. Do not recommend if you have combination to oily skin!
captainthem from my best
the actual brush is too thick so my liner doesn't come out as precise as it normally does
Syl from Redlands, CA
I've tried high end liquid liners and drug store liners. This is my "go to". Seems to last much longer than other brands so I will pay more for it.
maolin from Black Rock City
Not sure why this is branded "skinny." I love their black magic line, which can do a very thin line perfectly. Got this in a Birchbox. No matter how careful I am, the thick applicator completely fails to lay down a straight, thin line. Won't be buying this one - I'll stick with the black magic, which is my favorite liquid liner to date.
Natta from St. Louis
First of all, I'm terrible at putting liquid eyeliner on - and I feel like with this one, it's almost impossible to mess up. Second, for some reason eyeliner always comes off my right eyelid, but this stuff stays on all day! I received a free sample size as one of my Ulta free gifts, and now that it's run out, I'm here to purchase a full size. Highly recommend!
JAJA from CA
I am always on the look out for better, but so far this is my favorite liner! I have oily lids and this does not run!!!
SJGN from Phoenix, AZ
Idk if the sample I received was dried out, but this did not glide smoothly. I liked the tip firmness, but I had to use short strokes, which made for a lot of mistakes. It doesn't smudge or flake, which is a plus.
Kass from Texas
The top is perfectly firm without being scratchy. It's not really waterproof but I line under the wing with clear lip liner and it's perfect. I'm never buying anything else ever again.
mfbspicoli from Las Vegas, NV
this is amazing and the only liquid eye liner that I will actually buy if I don't get a gel paint pot for eyeliner application. I do have a problem with oily lids though so this definitely falls and burns but with a good primer this lasts all day. two coats needed for extra thick shadow lids but once it's black it goes full black which is nice.
dynamite09 from San Diego, CA
I tried this product on and right away it didn't make a nice line because the ink runs. It runs on your eyelid. That was my only issue but that's enough for me to not use it ever again. Has lots of potential but it's messy.
Haley from Washington
Only reason I gave it two stars is because the tip made it really easy to do a wing. But I only wore it for like 3 hours and it was all over my eyes and under my eyes. Smudged everywhere. I'm glad I bought this on sale because I won't be buying it again.
Maytajune from Michigan
This liquid liner pen glides on nicely and does not skip over my 40-year-old eyelids. The liner is a bold, deep black color. It stayed on my lids all day and did not fade or travel. I wore it hiking in Arizona and it did not bleed and still looked great at the end of the day. It was easy to wash off and did not give me raccoon eyes after washing my face.
IronLizzy from Pittsburgh, PA
I was looking for an alternative to KVD tattoo liner which is my go-to. Just wanted to see what else is out there even though I love what I currently use. The reviews convinced me to give it a try. Nope. The felt tip itself is very wide so there aren't enough options for making a thinner line. The color is very bold black which I loved. The huge downside is this. Halfway through the day I caught myself in the mirror and the liner spread up my eyelid so it almost looked like I was trying to do a smokey eye and then cried a bunch. Not a good look. Then, I tried to smudge it off and the stuff that spread won't budge! I thought maybe I didn't let it dry enough so I tried again today. This time I blew my hairdryer on cold on my lids for 30 seconds and used UD setting spray. No difference. Here I am with raccoon eyes I can't fix until I get home. Pic attached shows the wing (intentional) and the smudging (not intentional). It's a real bummer and also really embarrassing. Back to KVD forever!
Nika from Boston
I got this liner in my Ipsy and I've been hugely impressed! I generally do a wing tip every day, and even if I brush the side of my eye it doesn't budge. It hasn't smeared or flaked off at all! Love it