Rated 4.41 out of 5 stars
I haven't bought a Tarte eyeshadow palette in years because they make the same palette over and over color story wise. This one definitely stands out and is beautiful. I swatched all the colors and anyone who says green doesn't have pigment or the mattes are chalky, I didn't find this to be the case. All colors have excellent payoff. The problem I found which was hard to notice given the layout and texture of some pans, many of the shades are VERY similar. ESP the golds/coppers/shimmers. They're all near identical once applied. Then I noticed that your limited to about 3/4 looks with this entire palette. That's why I took 1 star away. The green and yellow make this palette stand out. I think that's why it's eye catching. It could have used another variation of each shade. If you remove those, you almost have every other Tarte palette. Also a couple shades that were textured had sheen on top but once swatched, the sheen was gone. So essentially it becomes a matte. The sheen was just a top layer. Little deceiving. I don't regret buying this palette because it's stunning. The case is so sleek and beautiful. It's one of tarte's nicest packaging. Very upscale. But I would wait for a sale or bare in mind the limited looks. Such a beautiful palette for fall.
I wanted to love this palette, so much. The packaging is beautiful. It's sleek and classy. Fantastic mirror inside and the vanilla smell is delightful. The color story is nice although not unique. Two big issues for me with this palette is that there are far too shimmer shades. 13 out of 24 shades are shimmers. Most of them are packed with chunky glitter, which is not my style. The second issue is the amount of repetition within the palette. The shades "wild at heart", "sundown" and "heartbreaker" are incredibly similar. Absolutely no need for 3 similar shades in one palette. There's also "enamored" and "lust" which are very similar as well. "Playful" and "Charming" are colors that we really don't need both. One or the other would have sufficed.
All in all, this is not for me. I feel this palette was suppose to be a new edition of the "Unleashed" palette. That palette was perfection. Buttery, creamy metallics with no fall out. Plenty of variety. None of this was found in this palette. The only upgrade was the packaging. Such a shame.
mayLv from Las vegas,nv
I love tarte and I was very excited to buy. However I was extremely disappointed. At first to get pigment onto my brush was tuff and when I did apply and tried to blend it was very harsh. Not at all impressed. I will be returning today
That Hat Lady from Grayslake, IL
I had my eye on this palette for months! I'm glad I waited for the sale and accumulated points, because I got a great deal. The shadows are buttery and some mattes are very pigmented. The leopard texture pans are sparkly and semi-sheer. Use a small brush to avoid dusting these up. You do not need much. It's not necessary to pack these on to look good. I'm a Bright Winter in seasonal color analysis with brunette hair, olive skin and blue eyes. This palette is technically Autumn, but there's black, pine green, off-white, and burgundy to work with. This time of year I crave warm colors regardless of my Winter season. I think I can pull this off if I don't pile on too many warm colors together. Give this a try and copy the models' application for best results.
Katie from Charlotte, NC
Great eyeshadow pallet, great colors.
Cbaz from US
Why doesn't anyone else have this issue??? I've tried different primers and the shimmers leave sparkles all over my face. It's unusable. Such a waste of $$ for me. I'll add I absolutely LOVE tarte eyeshadow and have only had this issue on two products; this being one :(
belinda.g.artistry from Dallas, TX
Super happy to be adding this to my pro kit! Beautiful mattes and shimmers, Beautiful blendability and intensity
Missy from South
I really enjoy this one. I don't have Tarte except their mascara, but it's a nice palette. Lots of variety and nice shadows.
I generally get higher end shadows, and i still enjoy this.
Terri C. from Undisclosed
The colors in the picture made them look vibrant. In person it doesn't look anything like it.
Mo from Alexandria La
I returned this pallet, it would not want to stay on my makeup brushes much less my eyes. Ive always loved tarte but was not thrilled at this pallet
Rory from Pennsylvania
I've had this pallette for a few months now and I adore it, I've used all the colors just about and they hold well throughout the day. The shadow goes on easily and looks vibrant, the pallette is really well made, the mirror is nice, and it's durable. (I've dropped it twice)
Pratyusha from Undisclosed
I have a very sensitive skin and I'm in love with the formula. It doesn't feel heavy on the lids,goes on like a dream. All the colors blend well. I have a medium deep complexion and the only color that doesn't pop on me is desire but the rest are an absolute 10
It has been years since an eyeshadow palette caught my eyes. I saw a tutorial on Instagram of a beautiful Smokey eye, and once I saw it was Tarte and this beautiful shade selection, I knew I had to have it. I've received so many compliments bc of it
Joyce H. from Undisclosed
This is a beautiful pallette
Stay Lo from NY
Was in love when I saw this product, that wore off quickly. Product doesn't even show up on the lids, but there's fallout everywhere else. The colors don't blend at all. Used with primer, used without primer made no difference. Gave it to my 4 year old niece to play with.
from New Mexico
Such a great variety of colors, super pigmented!!
Elaine T. from Undisclosed
The colors in the palette look different when you put them on your eyelids. Also too many glitters.
Jessica C. from Undisclosed
So far I've used twice and I see no difference in this than my pallet I got at 5 below.. and the colors are super yellow orange
Rachel B. from Undisclosed
I absolutely love my Maneater pallet. The colors on the bllendability. I just amazing.
Jessica M. from Undisclosed
The palette is a little pricey but well worth it! The colors are amazing and go on smoothly.
Sharon M. from Undisclosed
Love this palette the colors are beautiful and stay on. I love all the maneater line including the eye liner and mascara.
Shelan from Idahoo
I love it ♥️ wonderful shades
Alexis B. from Undisclosed
Hands down my favorite palette! The colors are vibrant and beautiful! I get so many compliments with each shade! Love it
Conni L. from Undisclosed
Hands down the best pallet I've ever had
Lynn F. from Undisclosed
We absolutely love this palette combo! The colors are fabulous and sparkly...my fav!!
Andi from Woodland
I love the colors and how they blend so smoothly.
Jes O from Tinton Falls NJ
Omg I just used this palette and I'm shook. The blending was amazing. So much pigment!! It's a gorgeous palette that you should really get!! The color story and packaging makes it so luxurious especially when you swatch the sheen colors. I'm obsessed now.