Rated 4.44 out of 5 stars
I own 4ever Flame (cherry red matte), Lost Time (red wine matte), and Little Little (soft mauve matte), and Cradled (rose beige matte). Cradled is a nice Stepford-wife type of earth pinky beige. Lost Time rides the line between red and wine in the best way. Little Little is the perfect hue of pink with beige undertone. 4ever Flame is an awesome bright red matte. The formula is very matte, as its name implies and it stays in place all day for me. I prefer to outline and then fill in my lips with a lip pencil, then apply a lipstick or gloss on top. These pencils are perfect! I would love to see a wider shade range of fun colors offered, as there are a plethora of beige and neutral hues but very few brights or experimentals.
These lip liners were everything you could want in lip liner! Colors were gorgeous, they wear all day, great formula etc but when I tried to remove top of liner I would break the top off. They are very soft and break easily!😞
Malinois Wrangler from Indianapolis
I ordered "Smoked" because it said, mauve. It's BROWN. I lined my mouth then, tried to blend it into my lip. Surprised yet, horrified... blending was not an option. I looked like I took a brown sharpie to my lips and it wasn't moving. This is not a horrible thing for a lip liner!! It glides on like butter. However, make sure it is exactly the color you want because it will be a point of no return. My only complaint are the descriptions and swatches. There are two "matte caramel" colors but look totally different. I am just nervous to reorder die to the swatch descriptions being that far off.
Phh710 from Houston Texas
Cradle is the perfect color for fair besties. I recommend cradle with the Nude Stix nude 02 lip glace. So pretty.
Chelsea from New Orleans, Louisiana
I've tried so many lip liners. Chanel all the way to nyx. This lip liner is unmatched. Very creamy, pigmented and sooo long lasting!!
Ali from Oklahoma City
Love love love this lipliner! I heard good things from some beauty influencers, and they were right. The pigment is smooth and lays down beautifully!
Daria from Pittsburgh
Best lip liner I have! Even better than all the luxury ones ( I'm talking about you CT). Great staying power, soft enough for easy application, but hard enough not to be messy and the color, its PERFECTION.
Julie from Long Island, NY
This pencil is great, however, it is not mechanical so you don't have very many uses. I've used it maybe 4 times and its already gone.
Cat V from Houston
One if the best lip liners ive ever worn. It stays on all night and is so creamy and easy to apply.
Ella from henderson, nv
I never leave reviews but I'm honestly so impressed with this lip pencil. I've used so many lip liners/pencils before, some double the price of this, but this one stands out to me. It goes on so easily and nicely, but stays on so well. From the moment I put it on for the first time I knew it was gonna be my new favorite. 100% going to buying this in many colors.
HCC from SF , Ca
I am really impressed by how smooth this liner goes on! The color is bold and beautiful with staying power. Beats my MAC and Chanel lip liners hands down.
Darcy from Los Angeles, CA
Beautiful pigment and STAYS PUT! Lasts all night, even when sipping drinks. This liner is a steal!!
Marina from Orlando, FL
I've never written a review for any product but I came to not gatekeep and let everyone know how amazing this product is. My favorite is the paper romance lip liner because of the color but the quality itself is beyond me. I have a collection of 20+ lip liners within the past year and this by far the best. So creamy, so easy to apply, doesn't smudge and stays on!!!!! You can wear it fully without even putting on lipstick or gloss!
Kim from MS
I have this a 4 because it's a tad dry. Not much at all but it is something that I noticed. It stays on quite well tho. I had coffee and brushed my teeth afterwards and there was still a good bit left behind. It probably wasn't enough that anyone else would have noticed. I think that has a lot to do with the shade too. It's a perfect "my color but better" shade/tone for my lips. I'd buy again for sure.
Jessica from Florida, usa
I bought 3 colors: Cradled, midnight seduction, and paper romance. All the colors are beautiful and have great staying power! I love them all but Midnight seduction ended up being my fave!
WendyLoveapple from South Carolina
Bought this on a whim during the Spring Haul event in the Talking Backwards color. Definitely not disappointed. Rich pigment glides on full color with the very first stroke. The liner stays put through coffee, lunch and drinks with just very minor touch ups. It even works for older ladies like me (50). Price point is also reasonable for what can only be characterized as a prestige lip liner. My only complaint is it can be a little on the dry side which I think can be solved with a proper lip prep routine. Im anxious to try the lipstick.
For my fair skinned cool toned beauties that can never find that perfect cool toned lip liner. Midnight seduction. It doesn't look like it on the chart but it's a beautiful cool tone that's so hard to find in the sea of orangey browns.
Cathy g from Bergen County NJ
melxssa from california
for a matte lip liner it's soooo smooth it glides on so well and stays on for a while ! i love these liners so much def wish there was more colors
Lisa from Ohio
Phyrra from Tampa, FL
hm1124 from Phoenix, AZ
There's obviously a ton of lip liners on the market, so it's hard to impress me with one. That being said, this is a beautiful lip liner. This applied so smoothly, I think whether you're a lip liner expert or beginner this is a great product to work with. I haven't worn it alone but since it's so smooth I'd imagine I'd be comfortable enough to wear alone. I will say it's not completely transfer or smudge proof, but it is long lasting. The shade I got (Happy Endings) is a great nude, I've used it with plenty of different lipsticks and it works great with all of them. Also while this is a higher end line I appreciate that these aren't insanely expensive. If you're thinking about getting one of these, do it. They're fantastic.
Kimberly's beauty obsession from TX
I bought 2 of these on the about face website when I heard this launched. Really good lip liner. Stays on well. Everything I've tried is great.
Product Junkie from Fort Myers, FL
Where has this product been hiding?? My favorite lip pencils are Huda and they cost over twice as much as these lovely little pencils. I personally think the quality is of these matte fix lip pencils is just as good as any of the high end brands ones that I use. I bought 3 of them and will buy more.
Anthony from NA
Picked this up thinking it would just be another simple lip liner but this lip liner is amazing. Super creamy and pigmented it does not tug on your lips which is nice as well and pairs perfectly with their matte liquid lip. So glad I picked it up definitely getting more.
Sheba from kentucky
I like this shade color an the way it apply on the lips!
hfkayla from Wausau, WI
I love using these lip pencils! My favorite is Little Little. I will even use just the lip pencil with some clear gloss over it sometimes. These pair great with the lipstick as well and make the lipstick less drying on your lips.