body{margin-left:12%}Product ReviewsRated 2.71 out of 5 stars160 ReviewsMost Helpful Positive ReviewSuper goodI got the brown liner cuz I've been looking for one and it's really skinny and consistent!Most Helpful Critical ReviewExcellent design, ink issueThe component design on this eyeliner is fantastic; for me, a small handed individual, it's easier to maneuver. After creating an absolutely gorgeous sharp wing on one eyelid, the ink stopped flowing to the tip of the pen. The ink flows well from the middle but not the tip, making a sharp and precise wing quite challenging.Reviewed by 160 customersWanted to love it :(1Lauren from Barboursville, WVOnly used it once. Next day it was dry. Not sure if it was defective? I kept it with the cap on laying on its side in room temp.I tried this liner because I like the mascara.1 from FloridaThe liner tip is stiff and difficult to apply. It takes several applications for a complete coverage.don't buy this1ash from floridaThis is a very bad eyeliner I wouldnt recommend, its honestly the worst liquid liner Ive ever tried its a super light shade of black to the point where it can blend into your skin. Its also not waterproof and smudges very easily. I wont buy this again.Bought on a whim1Elle from Pittsburgh, paIt's not great.On par with a $25 competitor5 from Great Falls, MTI have been a loyal user of a $25 brand of precise eyeliner for about a decade, but this eyeliner has a pretty precise tip too! Good for us money conscious girlies.My new favorite eyeliner5Mandy from Dundee, MichiganThis is my favorite eyeliner. The line is easy to control from fine to bold without being messy. Stays on through tears, sweat, and even swimming. Highly recommend!Not Recommended1Angel from N/aThe eye liner is not waterproof as well as it is not giving the amount of pigment other yey liners provide.It doesn't work !!!1AT from HoustonIt isnt waterproof … I was super exciting to use it and an hour later I washed my face, and it came off 💔Worst eyeliner ever!!1mia from Algonquin ILi got this and was so excited and then tried it and it sucked it was grey and smudged even after it was dry the lancome one is way better!WARNING1👾 from Bloomington, INthis eyeliner is okay, i've had better. if you do not store it cap down the tip will dry out which makes it hard and inconveinant to use! in all honesty i believe you should save your money and buy an eyeliner from E.L.F instead.I liked it a lot until the tip popped off2Liana from Colcord, OKI loved how the brush made my wings really easy to apply, but after having it for a week the felt tip broke off of it. It seemed like it was a manufacturing issue.Best waterproof liner5DiDi from Joliet, ILThis is by far my favorite eyeliner. Its super easy to use and it stays where you put it for days if needed. I went camping and didn't have my makeup remover or access to showers for 3 days and this stuff still looked the same as the morning I applied itHard1teresa from Los Angeles CaliforniaVery hard to work with and not very black stained my eye black😭So happy I found this4Mar from Fort MyersSo happy I came across this enjoy using it so far it's filling in where I need help in like the colorNO TOO DRY1ASHLEY from CINCINNATII WOULD NOT BUY THIS AGAIN IT IS VERY DRY. THE 24 HOUR EYE LINER THEY HAVE IS THE BESTDisappointed :(2Bella from New Braunfels TexasFirst mistake is I thought this was a brown mascara my fault completely but I thought why not test it I say it lasts long but it's pigment could be better truly no smudge though it's not really a brownMy skincare girlies, brown liner + Vit C beware4T from Fairfax, VAAbsolutely loved the brown eyeliner so much, it looked so natural on my face, until I started incorporating Vitamin C into my skincare routine!! It oxidizes into a BRIGHT orange/red when mixed with it. Disappointed I had to change my fav liner :(I personally like it5Emma from Fairview Park, OHI know that the reviews are very mixed, but I personally like this eyeliner. I got it in brown and I think it's very natural and pretty. I actually like the thicker tip, it makes it easier for me to apply. So even though the reviews won't agree with me I like this product and would recommend.Love it!5Jo from DallasI'm surprised at all the negative reviews on this. I love this eyeliner! It's so easy to use, I didn't have any issues with drying and the packaging is so cute. I've tried a lot of different liquid liners but this is a new favorite.Dry1Allyssa from FloridaThis product seemed dried out and and the pigment was more gray than black every time I tried it. Even after shaking and leaving the tube upside down.Nice Tip, but doesn't stay put!1Jilla from IndianaTried this liner out. Good sharp lines, but after 2 hours I had black transfer lines on my creases! No thanks!i wouldn't reach for this eyeliner by the fact it wears off2mackenzie from scranton pait wears off really fast and doesn't last me longer than 30 minutesTerrible1Sarah from MII love this brand and a lot of the products, but this eyeliner is awful. The tip was dry when I bought it, it bent as I was lightly trying to create a wing, and the color was super light almost grey. It doesn't layer over eyeshadow and it does NOT glide on smoothly.Brown is more of a red/orange2Shannon from Putnam Valley, NYThe brown color is more of an orange liner. I will say I like the application and it lasts long, and also i think the orange looks cool given that I have blue eyes and wear bronzer on my eyelids, but I was looking for a brown liner.Loved the brown at first but…2Zoe from Pittsburgh, PAI got this in the brown & I loved the color when I first applied it, but after a couple hours it oxidized into a super red-brown :( if it had stayed the milk-chocolate brown it was when first applied I would keep buying it, but I really didn't like the red, rusty color it turned. It also didn't stay on super well. My hunt for a good, light brown eyeliner continues.