Rated 3.35 out of 5 stars
I like these eyeliner pencils, but they are easily not the best on the market. They aren't the best to use in the waterline because they aren't creamy enough but they are great just to line. I like the white and brown shade, the black isn't pigmented enough for me. Honestly I would recommend the Kylie eyeliners over these if you want a really creamy one. These are good, but there's definitely better! I'd give them like a 3.5/5.
I ordered the teddy bear color. First, this eyeliner is super hard to even get on / apply to the eyelid due to it being so dried out. I even tried to moisten it with water thinking I was missing something… I also checked the box, thinking maybe there were instructions since it was that hard to apply, and there weren't any. Then not only is it awful to apply, once it's on, it cracks and flakes off (I'm guessing due to being so dry). Using facial setting spray doesn't help either. So throughout the day it gets splotchy with chunks of it missing and falling into your eye balls. I really wanted to love this, but I'm shocked Ariana grande would even approve of such a terrible product.
Jordan from Fort Walton Beach
I bought the white eyeliner, when I was in the store I used the tester on my hand to see how bright it was and I was super super impressed. First day I used it I was impressed on how pigmented it looked on my eyes. Second day it was almost IMPOSSIBLE to apply. It's very flakey and dry, and pretty much is gone in 2-3 blinks. I will never reccommend and will never not buy an Urban Decay pencil again.
Katherine from NJ
Its very hard to apply. Super patchy too!
Bri from Austin TX
Bobbi from Rochester, NY
Every time ive worn this liner it has given me a stye. No other makeup has ever done that to me, I didn't get them before I wore this! Terrified to try other R.E.M. products but I want to support the brand! Dont know what to do.
Lynn from North Carolina
This terrible eyeliner 😞
Miranda from Witchita
I was excited to try this but it was a huge let down. I tried laying it over eyeshadow and it removed the eye shadow and no pigment was placed. I can get pigment on my hand but it won't go on my eyes. I could probably press harder and get it to lay down but I don't want to do that on my eye lid.
Hayden from Livonia, MI
I don't get the bad reviews. I needed an eyebrow pencil that wasn't tough on my skin and did it's job. Here it is! Amazing!
Connie from Jacksonville Florida
Stays on . Love it.
jazminelynea from undisclosed
This smooth black liner is good for anyone just starting out in doing makeup, it's easy to use and lasts for hours without smearing. It's bold and beautiful!
Carol from Webster
Didn't go on as smooth as I wanted nor have a precise tip
Dash from New York
I was in a pinch and needed a new kohl eyeliner & couldn't find my usual, so I picked up this eyeliner. What I like is tht the product is smudgeproof but doesn't stick well on the waterline like other kohl eyeliners I've used in the past.
Terrible! from Ohio
I love eyeliner but this is NOT IT! Pigment is terrible, doesn't stick to waterline, literally doesn't work at all. Terrible. Returning.
nataliej72 from undisclosed
I'm not great with this kind of eyeliner so I personally don't love it but it is super creamy and easy to put on the eye.
Jenn from El Paso, TX
Got this in white and was very pigmented on my hand when I tested it but it does not work on your waterline whatsoever! I had to press hard on my waterline to try to get it on there and it just wouldn't grasp the color.
jennkapp23 from undisclosed
I love how this product is retractable, making it super easy to sharpen if needed. When new, does not have as much pigment. Product needs to be warmed up before applying to bottom waterline if going for that look.
rachaelma5ac from undisclosed
It's been a while since I found an eyeliner that worked for me! It goes on smoothly, and last all day! I can't imagine going back to any other brand with how well this one worked for me!!
Devin from Colorado
I tested it on my hand in the store and after a minute or two of drying it was transfer proof. Cool! But once I put it on, literally less than an hour later it is only a ghost of what it once was. It's actually impressive how quickly it disappeared from my eyes. I'm really disappointed. I tried it multiple days on the outer corners and by the next time I looked in the mirror, there was just a light gray smudge left, or nothing at all. I did not touch my eyes at all.
mergimei from undisclosed
I am more of a liquid eyeliner girl so I only tried this a few times. I love how black the eyeliner is and it stayed on pretty well through the day however I wish the pencil was a little sharper and not as blunted. Otherwise it was a good pencil, I've tried a few better ones but nothing wrong with it. Also packaging is beautiful as it always is with rem beauty !
taylorg1029 from undisclosed
This liner is so creamy. Its just what I've been looking for. Ariana slayed with this. 10/10 she's definitely getting a new customer
taylor_ellis02 from undisclosed
Easy to use and the color is just right. The eye liner allows for a sharp look which is hard to perfect with other brands.
Arla Rea from Virginia
I guess you can consider it transfer proof since it doesn't want to transfer onto your eyes. I don't know what pigment y'all talking about because it's dry and it's like having draw a crayola crayon on your hand.
Karen from Wyoming, Michigan
I needed this. I have very thin eye brows and this was a blessing to me. I have used it on a daily basis and it works great for me. My eyebrows are fuller looking and enhance my looks.
M from Midwest
Such great pigment doesn't get dry and works well on waterline even if your waterline gets watery fast like mine!
MEB from U.S.
I love rem beauty and was super curious about this white eyeliner pencil. ( I also have it in teddy bear.) I LOVE THIS PENCIL!! It is so creamy and is also very pigmented! 💯 recommend! Thank you miss grande!!🏼