Rated 3.39 out of 5 stars
If you are looking for a subtle stain, this is it. I have olive skin my natural lip share is deeper and rosy so the word "nude" on lip products always makes me nervous especially if it is a bright color. The shades I choose can be make it or break it. This shade went on beautifully. It didn't change my lip's natural color, it enhanced it. Keep in mind that your existing natural lip color is IMPORTANT when it comes to choosing shades. The wrong shade will give you a disappointing experience. With that said, I think it would be more obvious for someone who has a more nude or light natural lip color, but I am a lover of subtle so I actually like it. It is great for daytime and lasted mostly through the day, although I did re-apply it a couple of times to match my desired level of tint. Also did re-apply after meals but not because I had to, only because it's a habit and having a new product I want to use it as much as possible. It comes with DUAL TIP if you want to make your line extra thin although I don't really think you will use it much since the thicker tip does a good job lining and filling. I added a little lip balm over the stain to keep my lips moisturized but when I didn't, I was fine. It just looked natural. If you normally have super dry lips, I would recommend a lip scrub once a week or twice. Then once your lips ate not peeling try this or else this will make the existing dryness look more obvious. If I could improve one thing it would be a higher pigmentation for nights out, but I couldn't imagine waking up with red-stained lips, lol.
Pro tip: Remember that this is a tint and anything you leave will stay there longer. Make sure you are coloring from the inside out and being careful when lining the lips. If you happen to color outside the line, have a wet wipe ready to remove the unwanted stain as soon as possible, or else you will stain outside the lines and it's gonna be obvious.
I am really curious as to what other shades look like on my rosy lips. I gave this 5 stars because I am familiar with lip stains and I knew what to expect when it came to tinting and moisturizing. The small things that could have been better are not a big concern for me, they are more like features in my opinion for my taste in makeup. I would have loved to try a few different shades to compare them to each other.
I wanted to love this product because the concept seems so great! Having the lip liner and stain all in one product is more convenient than carrying around 2 separate products. It's not any larger than your average lip liner pencil so sizing is also standard. There's a couple issues I experienced with it.
1. The product doesn't dispense on a regular basis. Sometimes the color comes out sometimes it doesn't. The lip liner side is more consistent, but the fill color isn't. I tried all sorts of different ways of holding it - upwards, downwards, diagonal (up and down facing), at a slant (up and down facing) to use the side of the marker tip, using the point (up and down facing). The most consistent (but still not very) grip was to hold it point facing upwards and using the side to fill in the color.
2. This is very drying on my lips. I exfoliated before each application to ensure a smooth surface. I tried applying the stain directly to my lips at first, let it sit for a few minutes, and topped with chapstick. Still dry. Next day I tried using a thin layer of aquaphor first to moisturize and let that sit for a few minutes to absorb, then applied the stain. After applying the stain my lips were dry all over again... even after topping with a lip moisturizer.
The color was really nice though. A good match for my lips while still keeping a natural blotted style to them. I like that it's subtle and brings my lips to life.
Lauren from Undisclosed
Marcia from Ohio
Love this product but dries out within a month with minimal use. I originally recommended this product to many friends and family members but after buying from other suppliers and continued having the same results with the product not lasting, I will have to find a new lip stain.
Cc from Ortonville
Had to return. Bled horribly even with lipliner. Also Dried out lips.
PATTY from INDIANA
Love that I can finally have lipstick on without having to reapply every hour. Great product. Finally
Kristi from Everett wa
It's nothing special. Its easy to use the thick side, the liner is to flimsy. Color is boring
Brandee from Napa, CA
I tried this one time and threw it out, it was like trying to color with a dying marker.
NYC Beauty Junkie from NYC
I really like this stain. I just wish the applicators were a bit thicker
Ava from Shelby TWP.
Streaks and doesn't blend well. 😞
Hana from New York
I actually really like the formula and application. It stains very well and the small tip was very nice for precision lining my less full lips. The color beige pink veers a little coral, and I had been hoping for a more neutral mauve from the picture online, which was a little disappointing.
Terry from Co
Not what it claimed to be
Julie from Georgia
It's similar to the REM Beauty one in that they're both like markers. The lip liner side is a little difficult to use, but the other side does a good job. I bought the shade Real Pink and it looks similar to the REM Beauty shade Popular when worn. I can see this marker drying out quickly, but that's a problem for all lip stains I've used before are packaged like a marker.
Full Glam Queen from Idaho
I was really wanting this to be a dupe for the R.E.M. Beauty one but with a lip liner too but it isn't quite that really. I got the shade "Real Pink" and the lip and is a pretty shade of pink (however kinda translucent and light) while the liner is a deep fuchsia. I know liners Can be darker than the lip but it's way too much darker￼ than the lip. It made me look like I'd drawn on my lipliner with a fine point sharpie and was possibly not wearing anything on my lips at all. I guess I'll just use the ends separately from each other and both as lip stains neither as liner. This has shown me that stain as liner, no matter if it's thin, looks so unnatural and odd. On the plus side this was very comfortable to wear.
Dazfa from Los Ángeles
Product runs out after one swipe. Not consistent with color. Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. It's not worth it tbh
Linda from Sacramento
The lip liner side is thin as it should be but the end with the lip color is to thin and difficult to cover the lip area.
Nancy from SC
I had such high hopes but don't waste your money. The tip dried out after one use and even if it still dispensed the product, it's such an awkward applicator.
Alliyah from Undisclosed
The stain work's wonderfully and stays put longer than I expected, as well as the liner. These can be paired with gloss or worn alone, also the color pay off is great. My only issue would be regarding the shade range. It should be a bit more diverse, especially when considering deeper skin tones.
ClassicCB from Iowa city Iowa
This is definitely being returned. Drying, splotchy and not close to the color on the ends. I love clean beauty but this is a no go for me.
Lety from Chicago
One side was dry and could barely see it on my lips. Not sure if that's what it was supposed to do but I didn't like it at all. Waste of $.
Pj from RI
Really love the shades, however the product is impossible to use perfectly. The tip does not fill and you have to use the side to dispense product. You then need a brush to get a perfect line if you can dispense enough product to get onto the brush.
I would say I didn't notice a stain, but it might be because I couldn't get enough product onto my lips.
The shades are PERFECT TOO! Felt tip doesn't work and the stain is very light, thin, and diluted.
Terri from Canton, Ga
The advertisement said "buy one get second half off"! Well that didnt happen! On top of the fact that there were lere dried out magic markers! Thumbs down BUYER BEWARE!!
koriestes from Springfield, IL
Loved it a lot
Lauren R from Houston
Love the convenience of having two color options in one tool. The colors are beautiful and it's pretty fool proof. The stains last a long time and are comfortable to wear.
Marley from los angeles
Chubbie bunnie from San Bernardino
I received an undone beauty forever lip 2-in-1 stain + liner in the color natural nude from Bzzagent in exchange for my honest review. First, I would like to say how awesome the idea was that undone came up with. But I feel like they can work on it to make it a better product. At first I had to figure out which side was the liner and which was the stain. After getting that all figured out the application of it was just horrible because of it being like a felt tip the control of it was not as easy as a lip pencil. The color was gorgeous but didn't show up very well which was dissatisfying. Over all would I buy something like this probably not. Maybe if they figured a way out to make it better I would give it another try. I don't recommended. As you could tell the color did not show up on my lips in the picture.
Kris from California
I tried this on my hand as well as my lips. It went well on my lips but I eat a lot of oily things so it did seem to fade over time which is expected. It's also a little closer to my natural lip color so maybe it was hard to tell. What I was most impressed with was that it stayed on my hand for over 24 hours. Pretty impressive since I was my hands a ton!