Rated 3.76 out of 5 stars
The blackest black. Longest lasting and stays put. Easy to apply and doesn't dry out to lessen the amount of product as happened to me with another highly regarded brand. Can be applies thin or thick.
I apply MAC Paint Pot in Soft Ochre and then make a cat eye with this somewhat thick. Also I'll put on Charlotte Tilbury Eyes to Mesmerize in taupe and then this applied thin on top with lots of mascara top and bottom.
My favorite eyeliner ever was discontinued so I bought this on the search for a new one and it is absolutely HORRIBLE. The brush is HUGE and it goes on super patchy and isn't layer-able at all. It's also more grey than black. I barely touched it shortly after it dried and it immediately rubbed completely off. do NOT buy this. a poor expensive excuse for a liner. Just get the nyx epic ink brush liner instead its cheaper and way better. so disappointed. (also I wear big winged liner every day, and have tried many things--nothing has ever been this bad)
Nala from Sterling Heights Mi
Unless you're a pro at this type of tip liner it's hard to get the exact line. I like brush tip better.
Shelby from NC
This is currently my favorite eyeliner! It doesn't tug at the eyes and the lines go on smooth.
Emily from Elk grove
Tried over 10 other brands which always smeared easily. I have hooded eyes and this is the first brand that was easy to apply, didn't irritate my eyes, and ACTUALLY stayed on. Highly recommend
Mandy308 from Kearney Nebraska
Love love love! Stays all day, writes beautifully, best liquid for dramatic looks!
JBan from NY
If you have oily eyelids I'm not sure if they would work, I love the tip of the eyeliner but I tried it twice and after it dried I just passed my finger through and just flaked off ...
Megan from Cincinnati, OH
I've used liquid eyeliner for years and the brand I used changed its formula and it started drying out and flaking. I decided to try Nars Climax liquid eyeliner because I read other product reviews. I felt it was pricy but decided to give it a try. I'm so glad I did! It applies easily and precisely, looks great, stays put yet is easy to remove at the end of the day. I highly recommend it. It's my new fav!
from Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
Better than most liquid eyeliners
Deb from LA
Came off quickly
Beegee from Ca
At first it is a little hard to work with after it exploded lol or started to leak it was much easier to use once all the ink was at the tip. Dark and stays put all day. I would buy again.
Jerry from New Jersey
this eyeliner exploded after a few weeks. this applicator is trash. pigmentation is trash. ingredients are trash. this liner is trash
Hawrsh from Dearborn
Really wanted to like this despite the bad reviews but they are all true. Initial stroke was light grey. I had to shake the pen for no joke maybe 20 minutes before getting it to become black and then even then it still looks light. I also dont like the brush. Packaging is cute tho so one star for that. Im returning.
Katie from Atlanta
It has good application but, it doesn't stay on very well. My eye watered a little and it was a mess. Not good for all day wear.
Julia from Westport
Amazing eyeliner. I wore it for hours at a wedding, sweating, dancing, and it stayed perfectly in place all night. Will forever buy this!!
Iili from North Riverside IL
eyeliner Ever I have try so many stilia kvd beauty bakery and more high end and this is the best all day eyeliner and the tip brush you can make any desing to easy to use
Crystal from Paducah, Ky
I thought this would be smudge proof, however, in the corners of my eyes it does not stay and breaks away. I will be returning this product.
Liz from New Jersey, USA
I love a winged eye, and I've used so many different kinds of liners. This one works. It stays on, has a great tip, gives great precision, it's super pigmented, and it comes off with makeup remover. I will definitely keep buying this eyeliner forever.
Jamie from Alabama
This liner is one of the easiest I've ever used. Usually felt tip liners do not create a clean line. I'm not sure what sort of tip this is but it leaves a clean line with no effort. The tip is slender or fat depending on the side of the tip you use. Get skinny and fat lines. Nice, dark black liner perfect for winging! My new go-to!
HelloMegan from NOLA
I've been on the hunt for the best liquid liner after the one I previously used was discontinued.
This one may be the worst I've ever used. The applicator is a strange shape which made it difficult to get a precise line. It's also very messy and does not go on as black as I would like. It almost looks faded.
The main reason though that I'm giving this liner one star is that it only stayed on for 2 hours before almost completely fading off.
lisa from Oklahoma
I got this and now I have no problem doing a wing. Also, you ever do a wing and say, hmm, I just need to add a little width or length to my line only to find you now have a giant dash??? Not with this. Super easy to use. It's expensive but in my opinion there is truly nothing this good...and this is coming from AA woman with deep set aging eyes.youll love it
JD from Iowa
The product is not black enough, and it doesn't layer well at all. It also comes off/smudges throughout the day so my winged eyeliner turns into looking like my emo-phase eyeliner in high school. And trust me, thats not good. Overall, I am super disappointed in this product. Normally I love NARS, but this just ain't it.
Josette from Virginia
Lola from Chicago, IL
I like this eyeliner because the brush is a great shape. But it does have a tendency to flake if left unset. You HAVE to use setting spray or powder with this product. However, it gets patchy as the setting spray dries down. So I do one coat, spray, let the spray dry, then another coat. I get a nice even color and it doesn't flake all day.
Elizabeth from Washington
I loved putting the product on and I feel that the product was a pretty nice black. However, it literally came off so easily while I was working- not cute at all.
Cp from Usa
I haven't splurged on a new liner in a long time but decided to give this one a try. I will never go back to my old liners. This one is so black, and so easy to achieve that winged liner effect. Stays on all day. I will repurchase for sure!
Onyx from NY
I've used it 3x best eyeliner I tried so far, it has to different sides one that makes the line thin and the other side a little wider. Its very black, easy to use, it didn't smudge or run down my face after falling in my pool lol.. i will Def buy again!