Rated 3.9 out of 5 stars
It's so incredibly waterproof I love it, my sister got it for me in fuchsia metal, and the color is BEAUTIFUL. Easy application, nice brush, just metallic enough, but the day I opened it, I don't know what happened, but the bottle BROKE. I'm so devastated, I don't usually like wearing eyeliner regularly but I could wear this everyday. Pls NYX if you see this can I get another? Literally best eyeliner I've ever had.
WHY WHY WHY do makeup companies discontinue great products? I've been using the Matte eyeliner for so many years and just found out that I could no longer buy it because they got rid of it. I bought this one even though the price is so much higher, and it's not even worth a few dollars. Awful awful formulation. It's pigmented but it just flakes off during the work day and it's so embarrassing. The tip won't let you create a precise wing either, it's useless. It literally doubled my getting ready time in the morning. Bring back the Matte eyeliner!!!
Bbb229 from undisclosed
I had a sweaty gross day and various activities and it stayed amazing!
Gabby from New Jersey
This is my favorite eyeliner cuz I have watery eyes and it does not come off!!! Even in the shower, you need to use makeup remover libaerally to get it off it's the best lol
Kathy from Westminster MD
I love using colored eyeliners on a beige eye shadow. The metallic color is subtle and it looks awesome. It also is a little more affordable than another make I have been buying from Ulta. As you get older and your eyelids disappear I think colored eyeliners are much more attractive than black or brown
Sassyscribbler from CT
When they say waterproof they aren't lying! This stuff (in both metallic and regular) stays on! You need a makeup remover to get it off. I love the real brush. And the color is great. (Gunmetal). It was exactly what I was looking for and the price was reasonable.
j from NYC
Such a beautiful and long lasting formula! Super pigmented and easy to apply !
from Waukesha WI
Was hard to wash off, good if you like waterproof products.
Bella from New Braunfels Texas
I love these eyeliners pigmented and literally have to SCRUB off only problem is how if you don't get enough product on the brush it leaves an ugly stroke line wish we can do something about that pigment string like always (this shade not so much)
NICKY from ROCHESTER,NY
THIS EYELINER MUCH TO GLITTERY
Unhappy EyeLiner User from Phoenix Az
Metallic liner not so much. The studio Liquid eyeliner was so much better. This eyeliner was awesome. went on easily and the extreme colors were so vibrant. i wish they would bring it back.
stephaniev190 from undisclosed
I love every eyeliner NYX puts out. this has a great pop of sparkle for you! It's so cute and fun totally would recommend.
Bri from Virginia Beach, VA
I switched these on my hand at ulta at 9am and I've washed my hands alot & worked with my hands all day, they're still there! These would be so good for oily lids! Water doesn't make them run or smudge! only makeup remover gets it off, so that is amazing!
rayray123456789 from undisclosed
DO NOT use a water based makeup remover to get this eyeliner off! i rubbed my eyelids raw and am now dealing with hypersensitivity and burning, but that's purely my fault, not the products. this eyeliner will literally stay on your face for weeks if you don't remove it and the pigments are amazing. i highly recommend checking these out, but ensure that your makeup remover is oil based so you don't make the same mistake i did!
Lulu from Matthews, NC
This liner surprised me by staying on all day and night. The con is it's very hard to remove. You must use a waterproof formula. I do wish the brush was a little slimmer.
IrinaG from Florida
Totally waterproof, absolutely gorgeous color eyeliner
IrinaG from undisclosed
Te243 from Allentown PA
The best black eyeliner i have ever tried in a very ling time. Its most definitely water proof! Does not go anywhere and the glitter just tops it off very pretty i get in all colors!!
Diana from Virginia
I mean, you will not be able to easily take it off, it's really smooth and bright, love it
Jenn from Denver
I tried the metallic brown in waterproof. It skipped and clumped.
Fia05 from Hawaii
LH from Chicago
I disregarded the other reviews that said it wouldn't come off, so let me echo them: this eyeliner will NOT wash off. I did a swatch on my hand (thankfully) and I've tried makeup remover and scrubbing with soap and water, so I'm very thankful that I haven't put it on my eyes yet.
Janae from Wyoming
I wear these to raves and clubs or bars when I know I'll be sweating a lot or even to work when I have the time it lasts all day and I use an oil based cleanser to remove but it does not budge without I love this stuff and ill be buying more absolutely.
Yasic from Providence RI
I been buying nyx for a while but my last 6 purchases have been a fail terrible quality I got the green pink and brown on this metallic shades as well as 3 of the Halloween colors the only one worth it was the red shade on the Halloween ones the yellow and purple were pretty crappy but these metallic shades were just trash total waste of my money
Turkanoise from Indiana
The consistency is like tar, its so thick and so hard to work with.
Dalis from Vacaville, CA
Why would you ruin a good thing and replace a GREAT product with this cheap version. I used to use the matte finish liquid liner and it was great, lasted all day, with no flaking. This product is thick and goopy, and flakes half way through the day, it is not worth you spending your money on this... very disappointed.