Rated 4.16 out of 5 stars
I have just tried out the ColorNurture Cream Eye Shadow in Rose Cream. Cream Pot eye shadow is my go to for any eye shadow, so I was happy to try this one out. This color is very close to my natural skin tone but is a bit lighter, so it does brighten my eyes. It would pop a little more when paired with mascara or eyeliner. I have not had an eyeshadow that is this creamy before. It melts when you touch the pot. Its very buildable. It is hard to come off at the end of the day. I had to use a make up wipe to remove it. While i was wearing it, it was light and I did not feel like I had anything on. This can definitely be used as a shimmer or highlighter. Its a natural color with shimmer, and I am intrigued on how the other colors in their line will look on me as well. I like the ease of use and quickly having a nice look.
Seems like a totally unnecessary addition "natural" or otherwise. I love the look of this product but I try very hard to purchase only fragrance free cosmetics. I never suspected this to have fragrance and was sad to find out after the fact. I will no longer be using. Would love to try it again in the future if fragrance is removed.
Balagan56 from undisclosed
I ordered one of each color and two out of the three are dry and popping out of their containers. The third one, the rose color, is on its way to drying out. Burt's bees should stick to lip products only.
Babs78 from undisclosed
Unfortunately the cream arrived from BB cracked and dry, though I would be able to use it with a lot of effort. However, the rose cream is mislabeled…it's more bronze cream and not pink, like I was looking for. I don't use it for these 2 reasons.
from Riverside County, CA
Color is "less than" what is shown online. Texture is oily. Unimpressed.
sjbarnes from undisclosed
I ordered it online and I noticed upon opening the product that it was dry and cracked looking. I didn't really think anything of it, but then I tried to use it and realized it was unusable. I was very disappointed because I really wanted to try it being that I loved the shade but sadly I could not.
RMO1215 from undisclosed
I found this to be very sheer and did not provide any color for my lid. If you are looking for a brow highlighter, it may work for you, however it was not what I was expecting.
Terenia from undisclosed
I love cream shadows, but most use very harsh chemicals. I was thrilled when Burt's Bee's came out w/ cream shadows. I use rose gold as my base/primer. Then I use their powdered darker shadows in my crease and outer portion of eyelid. I'm a professional makeup artist, and love these cream shadows. Use fingers for creams, then brushes for powders and you'll have fantastic results too. Also, a contact lens wearer, so great to have creams to prevent getting into eyes.
Samee from NJ
Dry & Cracked upon opening. Feels heavy on my eyelids with a little burn to my skin. Needs an expiration date in big size type so it's removed from store shelve before before dryness sets in.
hazel from seattle
Buttercream has almost no color - I have fair skin and this color barely shows up, was hoping for a bit more.
Chamile from North Carolina
This has become part of my everyday routine! The pot I received was the creamiest cream eyeshadow I've ever used. It applies evenly and smooth, it's brightening and pretty and my eyelids actually feel softer and more hydrated since using this.
Vicki from Richmond, TX
Couldn't tell I had eye shadow on :(
Evp24 from Queens, NY
Bought two of these. Used a couple of times now they're dry and cracked. I've never seen this before in a makeup. Seemed like a waste of money.
CJtwentyone from undisclosed
I was so excited to find this cream eye shadow and blush. It was so dry and cracked. I can't even get it to transfer to my finger. Very disappointed in both products.
Chuckie from Pittsburgh, Pa
I heard so many good things about this product so I thought I would try it before I tried the Thrive cosmetics. I was so disappointed your product was not creamy at all had a hard time just putting it on my eye lid. Very dry.
Hedgehog from Blountville, TN.
When you want shimmer with light application this is a go to product! Offers a lot of potential for different look's.
tiiamaria from undisclosed
The golden glow above the eyes is flattering. The cream shadow goes on smoothly and evenly.
ChicagoHeather from Chicago, IL
Product was dried up & cracked. Heard great things about the product and was so disappointed in the quality.
LunaLA from Los Angeles
Really surprised at all the great reviews for this cream shadow. The product I received is quite dry; when I try to apply it, the shadow does not smooth out, and I'm left with clumps of glitter on my eyelids. It's even a challenge just to get it out of the container. From a color perspective, the Rose Gold is more of a pale rusty orange. Overall, this just reminds me of Play-Doh.
Wheatthins from Oklahoma
Love this color and how easy it goes on. Doesn't cake on eyes. Love it!
Prys from NH
I love the color and the feel of this wish it came in other colors like green or blue
CeceM from Boston
HollyMolly from Tennessee
I was tired of the national brand creme eye shadow products that dry out after time in their containers or get flaky after a month. I decided to try this Burt Bees product because I love their lipsticks (Russet River shade especially). The eye shadow was not as color saturated as I am used to. I wish it had a little stronger pink sheen to it, but I still like it for its ease in application and its natural glowy look. I would be happy to try more shades, if they are introduced.
20Dockgirl from Lake Hartwell, GA
I was very disappointed with this product. It is NOT rose color at all. More gold color.
MichelleE from undisclosed
I probably didn't think about the word "shimmer" enough before ordering. While alone it might be too shimmery for me, I use a matte powder over it and really like the effect. It's a good daytime look. The cream is so nice to use, and there is no creasing.
Gold not Rose. from VA
It has a nice texture and we're well but is not very rose colored. It is very golden and shimmery. Not what I was looking for.
ultafan from new england
I bought only the caramel buttercream shade for under my brows and love it. I use it everytime when I use makeup and no issues. It's not too instense of a shade and looks more natural. A definite staple. I wish Ulta sold more if not all Burts Bees products. There are only a few here that every other store sells as well. Burts Bees website has so many other products for the whole family, I wish it all sold here too. Plus, ulta is always late with new Burts Bees products compared to other stores, wish they stocked sooner.