Rated 4.07 out of 5 stars
Lord knows I was looking for a bright firey shadow that would do my under eye justice. The way the Shadow pop and matte up once dry is out of this world. Only shadows with deep bright pigment looks good on all skin tones . I love the quality of the makeup the pencils last long and shine bright. The shadows are long lasting and come in a array of colors. For everyday and every mood
I wanted these to work so badly because it looked like I could quickly get color on my eyes before running out of the house. I like the colors and they apply pretty well, but they remain creamy(sticky) and feel heavy on my eye. I couldn't even wait three hours through my day with it - I went to the bathroom at school and scrubbed them off.
Mom from Michigan
I was looking for a creamier application. This was very dry and hard to blend.
Brenda from Plymouth Ohio
Goes on smooth and lasts all day
Bliss from Moundville, AL
Really disappointed with these. They go on patchy and impossible to blend. Dries out quickly and just doesn't look good.
Hny86 from Fredericksburg, VA
Tried this eyeshadow stick in Pop Off and Echoed. I love both. Once it dries, it lasts all day. Waterproof and long lasting.
Linda from Travelers Rest South Carolina
I have been using Urban Decay eyeshadow for years and thought I would try the cream pencil for the first time. It did not disappoint me. Color stays on all day and goes on smoothly.. not clumpy at all. I bought the color called pop off. Not the one at the beginning of this review. Ulta got it wrong.
Ej from Seattle
Dont buy this. It looks good and works for a few months but it does NOT keep well.
Beth from Pittsburgh PA
I have a problem with eye shadows staying more than a couple hours, even though I use Urban Decay shadow primer. I tried this because it advertised long wear. I'm pleased to say, it really lasts! I bought the shade "Digitalized" and love it!
Karissa from Boston, MA
I normally love UD products but this was a hard pass. The color was a true solid white when first applied but was yellow within a few hours. It also was difficult to blend. Wish it was more creamy instead of waxy.
Num from Austin, TX
Too much glitter- just glitter all over the place
LaVonia from Mason, Ohio
Roach is a coppery brown color but it left black specks on my upper eyelid as it settled. I do have crepey eyelids and wasn't surprised there was some creasing but was surprised how the pigment separated out and really stayed put on my eyelids. I could not get them off without using makeup remover. It happened both times I used the eyeshadow stick. Very disappointed. Returned
kimberly from Allegan, MI
I like the MAC creamy shadow a lot better. This one tugs a bit and doesn't blend that great.
Rachel from Calabasas CA
I give 4.5 out of 5.
1. Super pigmented: One or two swipes will do. I got color "Hardfall" for my medium + warm skin tone.
2. Easy to apply: Perfect for the gym or traveling. No need to pack brush or big palette.
Kathy from Jamesville, NY
Unfortunately, not crazy about the color; however, store only had a few choices. Good sale price. I would have bought more if more colors to choose from.
Yeah from WV
I am an avid collector of UD. I have hundreds of their items. When it comes to eyes the singles, reign. If u love those like me this item won't do. Sticky and cheap almost like a knock off product. I can't believe UD makes this. So many of their products are king to me. The eye singles and palettes and eye primer and set sprays for example. This item is just terrible. It's very hard to work with if you are a beginner I could imagine. Unless on sale and you can see in store I would pass.
Meme from Nj
This creases in MINUTES!! I have dry skin so my eyelids wouldn't be extra oily. My eyelids crease before I was even done with my makeup. Not good. Not worth it.
Becca Lynn from AL
I like a lot of UD products & bought two of these. I bought a white for the inner corners of my eyes, but they looked SO dry (almost immediately upon application). They set fast & do dry out more swiftly than other sticks. Don't expect them to perform the same in six months because they'll be dryer by then. I did also buy a green one, and that works okay on the under eye…if "okay" is good enough. Definitely wait until a sale if you're gonna grab one. I certainly think it's pricey for what it is.
Meme from No
The colors are nice but it is creasing on my eyelids even before makeup. I put it on my eyes with no primer as instructed and says it's supposed to be creaseproof.
Stays on all day
AMPrab from undisclosed
Easy to apply, long -lasting, slight shimmer, looks great
Sharon from Prattville alabama
Extremely easy to use. Love the shimmer and beautiful color. Will definitely buy this again in the future. Makes my mornings go by so much faster! I love the shimmer in this.. Will be recommending this product to everyone I know to try this product.
Casss from Ny
If I'd wanna black eye I'd punch myself in the face. Not pretty. Don't recommend
LauraTrevino from undisclosed
Beautiful color! Blends well. Smooth and creamy formula.
Beth from Minneapolis
It leaves glitter all over your face and in the eyes.
Channah from San Rafael, California / Kauai, Hawaii
I used the cobalt (chaos) with a touch of lime (freak) about 26 hours ago. I'm in Kauai - yesterday I swam in the ocean twice +napped + stood in the rain, slept all night, then today had a surf lesson and a shower and it still looks great! The best!
Penny from Hanceville, AL
Eyebrow doesn't go on smoothly, so disappointed.