Rated 4.11 out of 5 stars
Was looking for that perfect purple shade; not to kid-ish bright, nor too deep. I tried countless & it seems when you find the perfect shade, the performance is off. I came across this liner at Walmart, & for a great price, so my expectations wasn't high. I was super shocked that it came at to be the exact shade I wanted! Not only that, but the performance was great! Long-lasting, no smudging, glides effortlessly, easy on the waterline (I have sensitive eyes), no tugging nor irritation, and even held up in the rain! I will insert a pic of how it looked after being in the rain for 3 hours straight! I can only vouche for the purple shade, but if the other colors have the same formula, you can't go wrong. Just wish they would come out with more colors, but for now, this is my holy grail liner for a purple shade.
This eyeliner is super difficult to sharpen! I don't know if I'll purchase it again because it seems like a lot of the product will be wasted just trying to sharpen it. The eyeliner pencil is not a regular wood pencil and it's also not a twist up, so be warned. The eyeliner product is very soft. Aside from that, the color is bold upon application. The pigment fades throughout the day so I wouldn't consider this long lasting. It does not stay well on hooded eyes.
Chellybear from Tennessee
I had a severe allergic reaction to this eyeliner within a minute of applying. My eyes started to itch, got puffy, and turned bright red. Tarte easy on the eyes is a great eyeliner for sensitive eyes. Ive had no issues with it.
Khisha from Raymore, MO
Loved the product
Pat P. from Los Angeles, CA
I like the texture of the eye pencil, but it gave me a terrible allergic reaction.
Nursebabe from Spartanburg, South Carolina
Purchased the all nighter eyeliner on a whim.. love it.. will be purchasing more colors
Tootsie85 from Springfield, MO
I love the colors! Most brands have black and brown available and it is so nice to see colors to express a mood. I purchased Toast It and After Hours. I applied them and was playing with the colors and it was time to use a little more, but the twist function to push more out of the tip did not work... on either of them. I cannot get to the remainder of the product. Very disappointing. How do I get the rest of the liner out of the pencil tube? I love the depth of color, but can't get anymore of it out of the packaging. Fix the little mechanism at the bottom, to push more out of the tip.
Kristy from Indianapolis
I have three colors the blue, champagne and black. All three are super soft and pigmented, they do not transfer on me after dry down. Also they last until I take them off. I have used a bunch of both high end and drugstore eyeliners and this is very high on the list. I think they are better than urban decay's pencils. Would highly recommend.
kristy from Indianapolis
I live this eyeliner. It is smooth, creamy and highly pigmented. unbelievably, it does not transfer on my hooded eyes at all. once it dries down, it is there, on my upper eyelinds, until I take it off. Would 100% recommend.
BabyBing from Wisconsin
I got the blue color in Ulta's Black History Month box. I didn't expect much out of it, but I have to admit this completely WOWed me. It lasted all day long without fading or smudging. I also have hooded eyes, so usually eyeliner ends up rubbing on my upper lid and transferring, but I didn't have any signs of that. It looked perfect all day. I'm going to get another color I love these so much.
lin from Klamath Falls Oregon
so happy I bought this, I ordered a burger and a purple.
both are fabulous and last all day.
very creamy, soft application, about 1 minute of working time before it fully dried down.
ari from STL
All Night is a BEAUTIFUL blue. it's bold and compliments my caramel complexion well. the liner glides on flawlessly and has stayed smudge free for the last 4 hours. I have pretty sensitive eyes and I haven't had any problems so far.
jajos19 from Elk Grove, CA
I love how smooth the product glides on and the color is great. Sadly the tip broke off after my second or third use so I wouldn't buy this again. not bad tho
Rachaelann from York, Pa
Brenda from Ventura
The liner breaks. It doesn't sharpen. It breaks when sharpening and had wood splinters. Could not use at all the very first time. I returned this and would never buy again.
Sky from Denver, CO
Waste of money. Every time I sharpen it, it breaks. Scratch my eyelid with the sharp wood piece. The majority of the usage of this pencil was about 10% out of the whole thing. NEVER again!
Bárbara from Annapolis, MD
I am so impressed by this one! It's very pigmented and the tip is very soft as well. I wish they have more colors!
Jo from San Mateo
I tested this in the store and immediately added it to my cart. Used it the next day and it is one of the best eyeliners with sparkle ever. Its actually so good that my sister stole it from my makeup bag and offered to buy me a new one because she has used it everyday since.
Bellz from Saint Louis, Mo
I Was Looking For The Same Eyeliner I Always Use But This One Is Perfect. It Glides On Just Right/ It Will Now Be My #1 Go To 💙
Sh from undisclosed
Wish they had more colors. A white one would be nice, but I can think of so many other colors that I would love as well! Please make more colors
Sophie from Texas
It goes on smooth and appears to stay on
Lally from arizona
I like it because it is so smooth and dark, but it makes me tear up. Returned
Happymom from NY
First time using this brand and I am impressed. Pencil applied smoothly and easily. No dragging, no skipping, just smooth color payoff. Better than many high end pencil liners I have tried.
CKM from slc
i've used a bunch of different brands and this one is amazing. pigment is really amazing and last long. i really love this product
SeminoleNDNGal from Oklahoma
I typically do a neutral eye and like to accent with a bright color like this beautiful blue. When I do a smoky eye, I love the black pencil to tight line and use in my water line. I have used many high-end and drug store brand eyeliner pencils. This brand is one of my favorites. They are creamy and easy to apply on my mature eyelids. Wait until ya'll get old and your eyelids change along with your skin everywhere else.
Ash from Alabama
I'm obsessed with this so much! It stays very well, and glide on so silky. Highly recommend!
Mary from undisclosed
I tried this product,it met all of my expectations.i usually wear only pressed powder, lipgloss, and of course eyeliner so with that small amount of makeover it has to be the best!!!!and this eye liner fits that category.and the price is awesome!!!!