Rated 3.25 out of 5 stars
I've been wearing eyeliner for around 15 years and have tried between 20-30 different ones. I usually get a different eyeliner after I finish one because I just can't find the perfect one. When I bought this I ended up going through 5 of them because THIS is the most perfect eyeliner that has ever been created.
I see that some people are giving it bad reviews which I just can't believe but I understand that people have different skin and it just can't work on every one.
But for me it's just perfect. The formula is insane. It's so so smooth and so black. The best part is that it lasts so long. I've worn it to festivals in the summer where I am sweating like crazy, I've worn it while crying many time, heck! I even wore it to a water park and it barely moved.
Apart from all of that my favorite thing about this eyeliner is the actually brush. Like I said I've tried so many eyeliners and this is the only one that has a tip like this. It is a thin brush so it's soo precise and straight. I have found that I hate the felt applicators that most of these eyeliners use. Es Paulo y after trying this brush. It's absolute genius. This is the ONLY eyeliner that I can do a dramatic (or small) cat eye, super easily and without messing up and crying 20 times. I can actually do my eyeliner fast. Whenever I switch to a different one It takes me so long and I have to keep fixing my eyeliner for it to come out like it does with this one.
Honestly this is my #1 makeup product ever.
I do see people say theirs have dried out and I just don't understand. Maybe it's the climate they live in? Because mine last for months before they start drying and like I said I've gone through 5.
I honestly couldn't recommend it more.
I have used this eyeliner almost everyday for YEARS and it's AMAZING, howeverrrrrr I think the company must have changed its formula or something because now it is really hit or miss. I have had to return every new one I have purchased in the past half year because they are so dry. Luckily, I didn't throw away my old ones because although they've lost their "power" they still work so much better than any new one I have purchased. I did receive a free mini one two months ago in a sampler thing from Ulta with a purchase I had made and that one I haven't had any issues with! I 1000% recommend this product when it actually works, but with its hit or miss quality lately I can't say it'll be worth it for all. Sucks that it's a gamble now as to if I'll be buying a good one or a bad one. At the liners best I can sleep on it or rub my eyes and it doesn't budge, it never flakes or gets smeary/runny, and it is easy to apply. It isn't tough to take off either, just a makeup wipe swipe and it's gone. Truly, I have never found another eyeliner that matches its quality. Ugh! I just wish it were consistent.
Adubbb from Los Angeles
Used to be phenomenal, but the new formula sucks. Doesnt last, smudges, and hardly applies. Looks worse now.
I do not recommend! I don't like how it goes on! Mistake I won't buy again
from North Dakota
What happened to this formula?! I've been an avid user for years, and my last purchase was so terrible :(
Shelby from Fort Worth Texas
I've bought this in the past and was wonderful, each time I buy it the product gets worse and worse
R from Seattle
I have been using this product for a very long time, but the last two that I bough have been so bad: one dried out in about 3 weeks and the other was dry when I bought it, so I am going to return. Now, I don't know what to replace it with.
Cece from North Carolina
I got this eyeliner in a sample pack and while it works good its definitely NOT waterproof. Comes off super easy with just water.
Stevie from South Dakota
Ive never left a bad review before but this product deserves one. I was excited for this- the lady at the store sold me on it! How it was waterproof, doesnt smudge, and how it was long lasting. Nope. Nope. Nope. It definitely isnt waterproof and you cant line both eyes at once- I can barely do one eye before it dries up. It doesnt layer and doesnt go well with eye shadow. And poor control for making a linez
It isnt worth the money or the time and energy it takes to apply it.
Just please dont waste your money on this product :(
There are better eyeliners out there!
Emily from New Orleans, LA
This is one of my favorite eyeliners. Lasts all day for me. I also love that it has more of a matte finish and is more of a true black compared to other eyeliners I've tried. I know that people either love or hate this product, but it's perfect for my dry, fair skin!
Nat from California
I was a die-hard fan of KVD eyeliner. Before she sold the company, the formula was great. I used to wear it daily and buy a new one every month/2 months. The bonus was that it's vegan and didn't mess with my sensitive eyes. After she sold it, it wasn't the same. Every time I bought it after, it would be dry. I'm looking at the other reviews here and it's disappointing that it's still happening to other people. Unless they bring back the original formula, I dont think I'll ever wear KVD Eyeliner again.
Drb from Merdianville AL
I love the way this eyeliner goes on & stays. I was surprised that it only had 3 stars.
J. from Louisiana
I received this loner in a fab fit fun box and liked it enough to purchase it. This one was dry out of the box.
Brittany from Seattle, wa
Bought this and within my first use it was hard to use and was coming out hardly at all even after shaking it. Looks super faded and not at all sharp or black
Phoebe from Dallas TX
Lasted thru mutable Texas concerts in 100 plus degree weather. Would definitely recommend! 👍
Ellie from Austin, TX
Goes on easy, stays all day long, doesn't smudge
Vin from Palmdale, CA
Doesn't go on as smoothly as I was expecting.
hayley from Lafayette, LA
I like this liner but it is not for oily people. if you're super oily and rub your eyes it will come off immediately. I've seen some reviews about it not going over eyeshadow I personally have not had that problem with it
Eve from USA, OH
I purchased waterproof eyeliner and mascara. Hoping for some volume and a striking black liner. Tbh store bought ALMAY liquid liner gave me better coverage. Absolute WASTE of money. Not sure which one was worse. Still on my hunt for a DARK black liner and THICK mascara
Jewel from Buffalo, NY
I am always happy with KVD Tatoo liner. I use both the dark brown and the black. It glides on easily and is very easy to adjust or correct if needed.
It lasts for several months.
I've read the reviews that the product is dry but I haven't had that experience personally.
MiiriV from Richmond
I got a sample of this eyeliner a while ago and it was amazing. I think they changed the formula because it is garbage now. It is not waterproof and smudges everywhere. It takes forever to dry down. I have hooded eyes and it makes my eyelid stick to the hooded part u der my brow.
Chana from Phoenix
This used to be the eyeliner you needed to have in your arsenal. I'm not sure what changed, but it's trash and had increased in price significantly. I'm on the hunt for a replacement of the old formula.
Gillian from Sterling Heights mi
This product is so bad. Not only is it flying around my face as I simply just blink but it took me ages to get any product out because the brushes are bone dry.
Deborah from Rosemary Beach Florida
Love it!!!!! Trooper Black my favorite
from Elk Grove
So easy to use and lasts through tears!
Diana from Tampa, FL
I was looking forward to using this, but I wish I didn't buy it, it is not smooth, product doesn't come out. I shaked the liner and nothing came out. It's pure junk.
Bee from Odessa
I've been using this eyeliner for about four years. I occasionally try others, but they never measure up to the accuracy and non-smudge ability of this liner. I just keep buying it over and over. They usually last me about 6 to 8 months.