Rated 4.23 out of 5 stars
so i've been using this pen for 8 months probably longer and it's always been my go to especially drugstore wise. it's cheap, it goes on well, it's not too shiny, and i like the tip on this one bc it's more like a brush. they also really meant it when they said long wear, i always wipe off my makeup before i sleep, but last night my head was hurting so bad and i forgot to before i slept. woke up with my eyeliner still on, almost perfectly. just had to touch up a few parts if i wanted to keep it. not to mention i showered about a few hours before i slept with the eyeliner still on and it didn't wipe off. i love this eyeliner so much, better than stila or any other expensive eyeliner. 100% worth it for its price.
I bought it about 3 weeks ago and at first it was great! I had no problems with it drying out or having the tip become stiff (I'm sure you'll know what I mean). This eyeliner does not layer well! I wear a lot of eyeliner, and when the formula isn't dark enough, I usually fill in the shape again for good measure, no big deal. But this eyeliner kept going patchy, which was a let down. I wore it for a few hours and my wing just crumbled off. I'm not sure if its water-proof formula is to blame or not but it's quite bizarre. Hope I didn't get one that was off.
emmam829 from undisclosed
i wear eyeliner everyday and this is one of my favorites! it's so affordable and pigmented. my eyes tend to water throughout the day and my eyeliner doesn't smudge at all! it's super easy to remove and no staining. this product is perfect!
tokeaw from undisclosed
Pretty good product. Rubbed a little off my eye towards the end of the day. Great price and it wasn't difficult to remove with oil cleanser. Dried pretty quickly. I didn't test the waterproofness but it's a great product for the price.
stoopidliz3 from undisclosed
The best and only eyeliner I re- purchase every time! It dries super fast, smudge proof, waterproof, and easy to take off! It's super black and dark!
hunvera from undisclosed
This is a great long-lasting liquid eye liner at a great price point! It is highly pigmented and glides on easily. My only complaint is that it's really hard to take off.
jillianp from undisclosed
Ironic that this eyeliner is called 'Breakup-Proof' because this eyeliner has quite literally stayed on after all my tears after a breakup lol. It's super waterproof and the tip is very slim, so you get the perfect cat eye every time. I could not recommend this enough!
amyg424 from undisclosed
This has been my #1 holy grail of eyeliners!! The pigment is perfection… this pointed tip helps create that sharp sexy cat eye in one sweep. Dries within seconds so there's no smudging and easily removes with makeup remover wipes. The broken heart in the package is cute! 1000 % recommend this
Flynn from Rochester, NY
This eyeliner bled on my oily lids, I expected a bit of bleeding but this was excessive. At first the black color was rich and deep, but it faded and cracked over time. I will try one more day, but I'll probably go back to my Maybelline Tattoo Studio eyeliner.
lala from Jefferson City, MO
love the texture the smooth application the stay power 10/10
J from Champaign, IL
I have used countless liquid liners and kept hearing about this one on Instagram from various accounts, so I tried it. The first time I used it, I was in love! The second time, the affection began to fade. I store this liner horizontally but somehow the brush has almost completely dried up already. I tried storing it tip down while I did the rest of my makeup and the first eye turned out perfectly, but the brush just pulled at the second eye. I couldn't seem to shake it or pump it enough to prevent this and really struggled. The results were patchy at best and very uneven. In my opinion, the Ulta brand Felt Tip liners are much easier to apply, even if they don't have the longevity of this liner.
Candace from West Palm Beach, FL
LOVE LOVE LOVE this liner!!!! It doesn't come off during the day
jas from Lincoln, NE
i have oily eyelids and it stays on all day and thru shifts (work in a restaurant)
Monica from Los Angeles, CA
So the eyeliner works pretty good.
I finally had it on where I worked outside and mind you it wasn't even hot out. Within a few hours it cracked where I had my wing and it also faded by my tear drop. So now I'll be looking for a liner that will not crack.
Ariana from Union County NJ
I've been using this for a while. It doesn't drip when I start tearing for any reason so it's so really good and it holds.
karay16 from undisclosed
Could be better. Dries pretty fast but very precise. Hard to remove without a wipe. Good pigment and nice brush. Might have to go over work if brush dries
Remington from Houston, Texas
(Graphic photo)So to summarize I've been wearing this eyeliner for years and it literally lasts all day even through the Texas heat. This previous week I wrecked my dirt bike hit a pothole got a bloody nose started crying and this did not budge at all!!
Remi from Houston, Texas
I never review anything but this eyeliner can take a beating!! Ive been wearing it and the NYX one for a few years and I'd choose this over that one. I wrecked my dirtbike by hitting a pothole was crying, bloody nose, the whole nine yards and this eyeliner did not budge even after wearing it all day.
angelvai from undisclosed
The Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Eyeliner is a hidden gem! It glides on smoothly, and once it sets, it stays put all day. The precise application is great for achieving different looks, and the affordable price makes it a top pick for my everyday makeup routine.
NB from Utah
I dont understand why the reviews are so good this product is so dry and is to shiny. I can only do one eye before it dries out. Wish i would have returned it :( wet n wild is usually really nice but this was a total fail product.
jennyj125 from undisclosed
Overall this is a great product that I recommend. I love the precision I get with the applicator, and how quickly it dries. It gives a solid pigmentation and stays on fairly well. The applicator/brush keeps its shape nicely too. The only reason I am giving 4 stars is that it isn't entirely waterproof. I need to set it with a powder to keep it from transferring to my under-eyes at the end of the day. It's still one of the best formulas I've used over the years and amazing for the price!
Jessica from Tracy, CA
It works really well and waterproof l. I just love it. It does take practice to get that batwing look. But you'll get there eventually.
lilyk55 from undisclosed
Hands down the best eyeliner. The application is so smooth and precise and it applies very evenly for me. With certain eyeliners I feel like they're not black enough and have almost a grey hue. That's not the case for this eyeliner. It's dark and doesn't budge all day. This will always be an item I repurchase
Ginger from St. Cloud, fl
Goes on nicely but flakes off within a couple of hours and is in little specks all over my face. I have tried a few times with and without primer and moisturizer but just doesn't work for me
amberw469 from undisclosed
This is still my favorite eyeliner and has been for years. however the past 3 or 4 times i've bought one it dries out instantly after the first use and i have to rehydrate it everytime i use it. BUT the pigment and payoff when it does work!!!! is worth it!!! and it's extremely affordable and i love the brush. my only complaint is it drying out!
mistykasumi from undisclosed
So I trued this eyeliner on a whim. The eyeliner i was using before this was from KVD and it was drying out too quick. I was so sad we had to break up because KVD was my ride or die. Well move over because this wet n wild one has healed my broken heart. The black pigment really suprised me from a drug store eyeliner. Love the brush tip that give me both bold and thin lines. Love that this is water proof. Even with my oily lids this stayed on for 8 + hours without running of streaking. Still a bold black pigmented liner. When I did rub my eyes it did come off my oily lids easy. However, I usually dont touch my face during the day. So if you have oily lids and rub your eyes a lot, use primer. Over all for the price? This is very worth it and i neex to stop sleeping on drug store makeup.
melanie56 from california
This is my favorite eyeliner. the only eyeliner i'd ever use. but i'm sure they changed their formula. Before hand it would never smudge, never move, i would come out of the gym perfect fine. Now if there some sweat on my face and i wipe it, the eyeliner will smear off.