Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
I have this liner in nearly all of the shades (CopperGlow, BlackNoir, BlackCocoa, DeepPlum, SageGold, OysterGlow, BronzeBeam and BlackTulip), mostly due to the fact that I bought a set that came out a while back, and my experience is that each shade is a bit different when it comes to staying power. For reference, I have slightly oily lids and my eyes are pretty hooded. My absolute favorite that I have repurchased several times is CopperGlow. I have hazel eyes that lean gold and that color just makes them pop. I get pretty great lasting power and only occasional transfer/smudging, mostly when I'm not careful enough about making sure I don't over apply in certain areas. I have similar luck with SageGold, though it's patchier due to the heavy glitter. However, with many of the other colors, I get a lot of smudging/transfer and they don't last as long for me. If I'm just doing a basic lining of my upper eye area, they do alright, but I could never do a winged look or anything on my lower lash area unless I want raccoon eyes. I love that these are super creamy and go on like a dream (with the exception of SageGold, which is firmer) but I just can't handle the smudging on hotter days. I live in Texas, so that's pretty much every day except a few weeks scattered between December-February. So, if you do not have hooded eyes and/or oily lids, you'd probably love these. BUt, if you're like me, I would recommend something else (but do get CopperGlow!).
I went to go put this on and the whole tip broke off. I was super gentle (so gentle there was barely any color on my lid - see picture, totally not kidding) but my hand got a ton of pigment when I went to fish the broken tip out of my eyelashes BECAUSE it's so silky (yay?)
I'm glad I wasn't trying to lashine or do my waterline. Overall, not off to a great start and I can't image this thing is going to sharpen well.
If you're going to make a pencil THIS soft, make it a twist so it has some support. 😐 probably not even going to attempt to sharpen it at this point. Not stoked about the idea of trying this again. Plus it's chonky. No level of precision is possible between the size and sheer smooshiness of this thing. If it smudged nicely so you could blend it out, I'd get it, but it doesn't blend so much as... flake? Particle? Idk. Not a fan and not what I was hoping for.
But I'll give it one star for the color range and one for the overall feel. It does glide nicely and has a solid pigmentation to it... on my hand, anyway. It just also crumbles, apparantly.
Megan from US
I have tried every shade they made and the colors last throughout the day, offer great shades but I have one major complaint....when you try to sharpen them after repeated use, they are so creamy they dont hold up, melt literally trying to sharpen and cannot get a nice tip compared to when you first buy it..this is very frustrating because it doesn't last long!!!! Pixi, do you have a reason why this happens and do you have a solution because I will stop purchasing due to this problem...
Debra E. from US
I have used these eyeliners for several years. They go on smoothly, are waterproof, and stay on all day long while not smudging. The mulberry is my favorite color.
Sarah K. from undisclosed
i love the colors, but after sharpening these pencils they were too soft to apply! the tips of the pencils just break off when i try to put on my eyeliner, which just makes a big mess. i don't want to have to put them in the freezer before every single application, so i'm not sure what to do about them.
Ella from Southlake Texas
I have been looking for a good smooth drugstore eyeliner, and I came across this one and I love it so much! I have also compared it to the urban decay one and pixi is so much better. But one downside is you have to sharped it but that's not a big deal to me.
Gabi from North Carolina
It took me a while to realize it was this eyeliner giving me swollen eyes, i always wash my makeup off at night and never have any issues with other brands, wouldnt recommend!
Myoma M. from undisclosed
I bought the black cocoa and it really makes my green eyes sparkle.
Ky from Appleton, Wi
I absolutely love this, I use it on my waterline and it does not budge with my watery eyes. The only problem is that it is super hard to sharpen, and tends to just break.
Katie N. from undisclosed
When they say silky, they mean it! This glides on so smooth! The only thing that would make it perfect is to have a blender on the end to help even it out.
Kristin from Collegeville, PA
glides on smoothly, dark pigment. one of the best eyeliners I've found so far for the waterline.
Dorothy D. from undisclosed
I can't even tell you how many years I've used this brand of Eye Pen...mostly in the black colors, but finally got brave and have tried a few others. Nothing compares to these Eye Pens!
Connie D. from undisclosed
I love the color and how long it stays on but to get the pen to refill does NOT work!!! I'm so upset!! I just got one use out of it!
Rebecca P. from undisclosed
I love the Berry shade in this eyeliner. I use it in lieu of eyeshadow. It blends out softly when you first smudge it and then it sets. It will really make both blue and green eyes pop! Great shade, especially for Spring. I use it with the Very Berry Mattelast Liquid lip color and Rosey Sheer Cheek Gel.
Heather from MS
For me, this eyeliner works as advertised. I purchased the nude and it lasted all day on my waterline, was very pigmented, and glided on nicely .I do agree that it almost crosses the line of 'too soft', but just adjusting the amount of pressure you use fixes this issue easily. At first, I didn't really like how pigmented it was, but I blame this on myself for attempting to apply it like I would black eyeliner. So, for my purpose, a little goes a long way and remember to use a light hand! Not sure about sharping it yet, but if I have issues I'll certainly edit the review!
Holly T. from undisclosed
Super silky eyeliner! Kinda smudges but does stay for quite a while.
Danion M. from undisclosed
Pretty color. Was hoping for a little more impact.
Cindy from MI
I've read people's complaints that there's not much product. FYI..you need to sharpen it when the tip goes down. Its a pencil. I used a cheap pencil sharpener and it worked great.
Darcy P. from undisclosed
I absolutely love the Silky Eye Pens! I have quite a few of them, they go on smooth and the colors are great! My eyes are very sensitive and tend to get irritated by a lot of make-ups, but this one does not bother my eyes at all!
Kayla from Washington, D.C.
Bleeds on the water line but can be worked with. Love how black it is!
Victoria R. from undisclosed
This is my go to eye pencil. Silky and glides on nicely. I love the color options.
GDel from undisclosed
So easy to glude on and amazing longevity. Funny it lasted so well I actually have used the lighter color on my lips
Mia from NY
While I loved this at first, there is very little product. About 1/2 inch, lasted about a week. What you see on the tip is all there is. It goes on well and stays on, but not enough product for the money.
Meagan G. from undisclosed
These are truly one of my favorite eye pencils. All these shades are stunning.
Emma P. from undisclosed
If only I could rate this higher than 5 stars. This is the hands down best eyeliner I have ever used. It glides on. Almost never smudges. You don't need to cake it on to show. I even order it for others because I've purchased and given them out to close friends and family.
Bree from Columbus OH
I saw this product recommended in a YT, comparing it to Urban Decay's 24/7 eyeliner. I've wanted the UD eyeliner for a long time, but I can't justify their prices. So when I heard about this, I definitely wanted to try it out. Really creamy, easy to use, great color payoff. Lasts all day. Will be buying more colors.
Tina from USA
Fantastic pencil liner or whatever your choice of cosmetic use of It. Applies easy, stays dramatic presences.