Rated 4.13 out of 5 stars
I've been wanting to try the Stila shadows similar to these, but I saw these for less $. The secret to getting a great look with these is to put them on in thin layers, allowing them to dry in between, and realize that they're going to stay where you put them. I Used the gold and green colors, and I did blend edges with a small brush in a dabbing motion, but they don't like to blend in the traditional sense. The look was stunningly gorgeous, and my eyes are so sensitive to pressed metallic powder shadows that this is my new alternative.
Super excited to get these, tested them out, seemed patchy, the pigment was inconsistent. I put it on my lid and when I tried to blend with finger and brush the product just came off. Pretty disappointed
Lili from Michigan, Kalamazoo
Absolutely phenomenal! Product is so beautiful on skin!
Michelle from Pennsylvania Mount pleasant
I love how this product has a lot of glitter it doesn't really fall or get all over the face but it can fade away quickly or it can be patchy.
Elias15 from undisclosed
I have 4 of these in my collection now: flirty birdy, 24K, Ocean Eyes, and pinky swear. The glitter across the board is beautiful and always adds a nice pop to my makeup. My one complaint is the patchiness of the blue and gold shades. I feel like they could be more pigmented along with the glitter, or just be colored glitter suspended in a clear base. The pinks however are beautiful and apply wonderfully to my skin.
Lauren from Minnesota
I have disco queen and flirty birdy. So so pretty. Good dupe for glossier lidstars!!
Ash1985 from undisclosed
Glitter that actually stays put!?! Yes please! This is not too subtle or too chunky. Doesn't irritate my sensitive lids. Perfection.
blythey_w from undisclosed
I love this product so much! I've been looking to step up my makeup game with some fun, high-impact products, and this was perfect. The affordable price is perfect for my indecisiveness, and allows me to buy multiple colors! The product is high-quality and super easy to apply, with one swipe elevating the entire look. Would 100% recommend!
Mackay from TX
I've used a bunch of different shades of these and they're super pretty. Only downside is there is a decent amount of fallout/glitter ends up all over the face through the day.
Abby from Prince Frederick, MD
The consistency was perfect and it was very pigmented. My only concern was the amount of product, it did not last very long. However for its price, I think it's a great product!!
Cait15 from CA
I've purchased the color Flirty Birdy twice! I use it to add a little sparkle under my lower lash line. It lasts long and has minimal fallout. If you have sensitive eyes/skin proceed with caution! Occasionally I feel a slight burning upon application but it goes away when it dries.
Brenley from Muncie, IN
This is definitely my favorite makeup item to use for special occasions. I used it in my eyes and with my highlighter for prom :)
Kennedy094 from undisclosed
I've enjoyed using this product. The applique is effective, although I will use my own brush for finer detail. Over time, I've found I need to re-apply in layers for good coverage.
Amanda from Rapid city SD
Love the extra.dash ofsparkle when wanted
MamafuturamaTheOGAgain from undisclosed
Elf sent me this shadow free in the shade Flirty Birdy in an order several months ago and I just remembered it yesterday. I'm on my 40's with heavy eyelids and often don't bother w shadow because I have to fight to make it even on both eyes… aging is fun. Top it off w needing bifocals and it's a waste of time unless it's a special event. Anyway, I wore this over the putty primer on my lids yesterday and was so pleased. Transparent enough that I could apply liberally and with a free hand and it was a nice chunkier sparkle but not so obvious I felt awkward. I immediately jumped on the app and started adding more to cart. It lasted long enough, didn't travel, and was just enough of a fun punch to my everyday face that I cannot wait to collect more. Thank you elf!
yippee from undisclosed
when I got this as a gift, I thought that it wasn't going to be good since it was glitter (I HATE glitter), but when I used it, I fell in love with it. I will be getting this more often now!
hmmidkwha2put from undisclosed
I bought this product a month ago and it was so prettyyyy the glitter is so sparkly and for the price it's literally worth itt it blends rlly nicely & its looks the same as stila liquid highlighter glitter but alot more affordable GET IT TRUSTT😉🗣🤞
vanessao54 from undisclosed
Loved it the pigment even the glitter gave me Halloween vibes just hated how it can rub off easily but other then that totally recommend
tiffanyhanner from undisclosed
This liquid eyeshadow was so easy to use and apply. The color and texture is amazing! I definitely would recommend checking out other colors as well!￼
lauryhb815 from undisclosed
The color is beautiful, and of course the glitter too. I recommended 100%, you can make a soft makeup or glam makeup its amazing
lindsaydamodel from undisclosed
Looks amazing in the tube, but purple color didn't translate on the eyes. Patchy but understandable since this is a glitter. Had some minor glitter fallout when applied with a brush.
monikaf1 from undisclosed
This is nice product, smoothly applying on the eye lid.nice metallic color . Price is very very good￼
ashleyr0 from undisclosed
I'm not normally a purple kind of girl, but this is so much fun! I love using this to swap up my look and make it more fun.
Dry and patchy from undisclosed
Although supernova is beautiful, it drys out fast and it doesn't blend that well. I tried it on my eyelids and it was kind of patchy. But I am not a professional and the only way I got it to blend was if I pressed really hard. I love elf's products but I am kind of disappointed by this. It is very pretty on when it blends out thought and it is a stunning color.
Kara from Oregon
Applies easily and dries down quickly. However the colors are not great and it ends up a little patchy. Drying to the eyelid.
CA189 from American Canyon, California
Love these a lot. they are very easy to apply and perfectly pigmented.
K1377 from undisclosed
I bought a set of all colors. LOVED IT until they dry out leaving SO much product behind that I can't use. I'm on my 3rd Disco Queen and it keeps happening. Won't buy again