Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
Stay Put Eyeliner is very comparable to the leading eyeliner they have out on the market. I wore the Milani Stay Put Eyeliner one one eye and my go to brand of eyeliner on my other eye lid and enjoyed a day with friends that involved the summer heat and a pool fun and the stay put eyeliner had up as well as my go to brand. I would buy the Stay Put Eyeliner especially if it is the same price or cheaper than my go to brand. I wasn't aware of the Stay Put Eyeliner before participating in this program but I was aware of the Milani brand but I was skeptical of the brand as it normally was cheaper than other brands. I would definitely recommend the Stay Put Eyeliner to others. It does what it says the packaging is stylish and it is from what I remember budget friendly.
First things first, I am not an eyeliner expert. I'm still learning when it comes to these types of liners. I try to tightline with this and for some odd reason it always smudges and it is like it works its way into the outer corner of my eyes and smudges downward and transfers beneath my eyes. I have to kind of wipe it off of underneath my eyes and the outer corner. However, given all of this, I can BARELY get it off with microfiber cloth, double cleansing, micellar water...GT I don't know if I am doing something wrong or if this doesn't mix well with my eye area. Little to say, when I wear this, after a 12 hour shift I look like I've had a VERY rough night.
Millgirl from Bayview, Wisconsin
This eyeliner is the only one that I use for everyday living! Long lasing and I own several colors.
Ingrid from Linden, TN
Eyeliner is wonderful!! Doesn't smudge or run at all thru out the day!!
Drlatty from New York
This does exactly what the name says doesn't budge
Vickie Carter from Choctaw, Oklahoma
I just absolutely love the Stay Put Eyeliner! LOVE
lana from round rock,tx
my all time favorite drug stote eyeliner i use it everyday and i do have to re apply it a couole times but its easy to use and good pigment
rissa from jacksonville, FL
only eyeliner i'll ever use for my waterline. it doesnt smudge or bleed with teary eyes and stays that jet black color for hours
Emily from Ohio
The color pigment is perfect. It's durable. You can make thick or super thick lines if you'd like. It has a smudger AND sharpener built in for added convenience. The price is amazing for what you get. I'm a mom of two toddlers and it stayed on through a day that involved a birthday party, cooking, cleaning, a nap, and their bath time! Couldn't recommend this enough.
Mfcee from Ohio
Smooth eyeliner with staying power and no smudging
Dar from Buffalo NY
I tried this eyeliner because I love this brand for eyeshadow. I had been using a Marc Jacobs eyeliner which is much more expensive. But after trying this one, I've never looked back. This stays on far better than the more expensive brands, even on the water line. It's my every day go to and it's amazing!
Joan from Myrtle Beach SC
I have been using this liner for a few years now and absolutely love it . It goes on easy on your eye lid and your under eye . Stays on very well and looks fantastic. I would highly recommend this product to ladies of all ages .
JP from New Jersey
This eyeliner stays put! It doesn't smudge and is smooth to put on. It's also a twist so no sharpening needed.
Mbeth from Syracuse, NY
Great product! I researched clean products and this company came up. Tried the lipstick and loved it. Now, I love the eyeliner too. Goes on smooth and doesn't smudge.
Sunpig from florida
Slides on easy. Doesn't irritate my sensative eyes.
A very happy user from Lakewood, nj
Excellent eyeliner! Stays on for over 24 hrs! Doesn't smudge!
Jeri from Virginia
Okay, so I tried out the Start Put eyeliner because I'm black and Asian, so my eyes are hooded and I can never get my liner to stop transferring to my upper lid, even after applying lower on the lash line. This is the first liner I've had in a long time that stays bold and in place well for most of the day. I top off the application with my setting spray which probably helps to seal it, but I'm glad I found a liner that does what I need it to do. I bought 2 more for back up in black and brown!
Jo Lynn from Florida
I use a lot of Miliani Cosmetics The brow pencil is fantastic. It is so easy to put on and lasts all day. I will definitely purchase this product again.
Chrisards from Columbus, Ga
This eyeliner is long lasting and glides on with perfect pigment.
Pat from New Hampshire
Excellent coverage. Best eyeliner I've ever used.
Sky from Chicago, IL
Love this beautifully pigmented liner. Though not 100% "waterproof, it stays put really well on the waterline. The shade "Semi Sweet" is fabulous to compliment blue eyes.
kas1951 from Myrtle Beach, SC
I have tried several eyeliners for tight-lining and I prefer this one. It does get on the bottom line a little but less than others I have tried.
asap from augusta ga
easy to apply, long lasting. dont have to worry about it coming off
Meera from Texas
It was easy to glide and the color was intense.For the price it is worth it.
Alina from Waterford, MI
Applies on well. Only complaint is I wanted the espresso and I emailed them before they even shipped my order but said they couldn't do anything. Also it's a bit pricey
Valerie from undisclosed
I love the semi sweet (brown) color! I have the hardest time finding eyeliner that doesn't migrate and smudge under my eyes. This one truly stays put and also easy to remove. It's very hard to find this color in stores. Please don't discontinue!
Hibye from North Carolina
Works well although I've only used it a couple times and have little experience with eyeliner in general. Tip is not at all fine, which is ok because I wanted to use the smudger for a gradual eyeline look, not a sharply defined look. Lasted all day without smudging-my mascara migrated more lol. And I do have oily skin/lids so I was impressed by this. I look forward to the next special occasion when I'll use this eyeliner again!