Rated 3.81 out of 5 stars
I placed an order with Jane Iredale for a handful of products this past fall, including for a clear mascara that, at first, I didn't love (I'd intended on using it for a brow gel, but mine are quite coarse and unruly and to that extent, untamable). The company was kind enough to refund me, and told me I could keep the product, which, coincidentally, I gave another shot toward once penciled in, and found it created quite a nice effect. I reached back out and offered to pay, and was told to simply enjoy it. While I appreciated that generosity, I felt compelled to make a purchase, as I really love what this company stands for. Yolanda, the service agent who assisted me, was fantastic in helping me create an invoice when I inquired about a promotional product; as always, everything arrived beautifully and thoughtfully packed, and with a hand-written note. This mascara, by the way, rocks - I've used everything from L'Oreal and Lancome to Benefit and Dior Show, and despite it being a natural formula, it really wows. Even just a single coat adds impact; I'll sometimes curl and add just a smidge more toward the ends of my fringe. FWIW, I previously purchased this product from a local day spa that eventually stopped carrying makeup. Yes, Iredale products are wonderful; I've used them since 2005, when they were mostly just mineral powders. But, it's the extra-mile service that has me hooked. Thank you!
After years of using mascara, I noticed my eyelashes were getting a little thin, so I've been looking for something that is good for my eyelashes but also gives me length, fullness, doesn't clump, and doesn't smear or run down my face over the day. I also need it to last a full day on the job. Upon immediately using this mascara, I was not impressed at all; however, I decided to use the brush from my IT Hello Lashes 5-in-1 Mascara and now I really like this mascara. I use that brush to get all my lashes and then I use the brush it came with for some added length and fullness. So far, this has drastically changed the way this mascara works for me. I didn't realize the brush it comes with made that much of a difference. So, the mascara is decent. It doesn't run, it doesn't clump and it makes my lashes happy; however, the brush it comes with does not give it justice in terms of giving you length or fullness. Maybe if you use a lash primer, you can get better results. So far, using the two brush method works for me. I'm not sure I'll be purchasing this again however.
Harriettlouise from Indiana
I got this as a sample, and am now purchasing! I am normally a Tarte girl for mascara, and that is still great for a more dramatic lash. But this mascara is the perfect for errands and work. Zero clumps or flakes, just long lashes that look natural!
Vanessa H. from Undisclosed
I've used the Longest Lash mascara for over 20 years now. I have tried other natural mascaras in between. But I always come back to this one! It's the best!
Ethlyn M. from Undisclosed
I love this mascara because it doesn't leave clumps On my eyelashes like others I have used. With other brands of mascara, by the end of the day I would look like I had 2 black eyes!
Amy M. from Undisclosed
I am not as happy with this product as I was another mascara. It is difficult to see that there is any product applied to my lashes. I have to keep applying for 3 coats to even see there is any product at all. I would not recommend this product.
D from Undisclosed
I've been using Longest Lash for YEARS. It's been a reliable mascara that enhances my lashes and does not irritate my very sensitive skin. But I just received a new tube that is white (instead of the gold I'm used to) and it seems...different. It is clumpier, doesn't go on as smoothly. And it also seems to be irritating my eyes. Horror of horrors. Is this in fact a new formulation? I fear that whatever changed will no longer work for me!
SheriLee J. from Undisclosed
Not enough volume for me
Cynthia B. from Undisclosed
Goes on smooth and doesn't clump. Makes my lashes look natural. I don't like my lashes to look to heavily made up. I've been using it for several years and like it better than any other mascara I've tried.
Luisa H. from Undisclosed
Brush is good, overall mascara is fine but not better than other brands that cost far less.
Jenna from Undisclosed
I love this mascara! I use it with the PureLash Extender and Conditioner. It applies beautifully (no clumping) and it lasts all day. My eyes tend to be easily irritated, but this doesn't bother them at all. I use the BeautyPrep Face Cleanser to remove it, and that works perfectly with no irritation.
Karen M. from Undisclosed
It's easy to apply & lasts all day!
Kate L. from Undisclosed
I've been using this mascara in brown and black for years, along with the lash primer. It's the best natural dupe for YSL mascara and creates perfectly fluffy separated lashes and looks effortlessly natural. Please make a burgundy color! No clean brands are making burgundy mascara and it's incredibly flattering for all eye colors.
Vicki H. from Undisclosed
This mascara isn't as good as other Jane Irdale mascaras.
Kathi Q. from Undisclosed
Horrible. Almost a waste of time, until later in the day when I look in the mirror and have it all over under my eyes. Sending it back want my money back
Ginger T. from Undisclosed
I am very impressed with the packaging. It is designed so there is just the right amount of mascara on wand. It doesn't get gummy. Also Iredale company suggested the brown color for my age. I was unsure after always using black. But they were right making a much softer look. I will never use another brand.
Amy D. from Undisclosed
I prefer the other Jane Iredale mascara over this one.
Julie D. from Undisclosed
Doesn't clump or burn my eyes.
DEBORAH S. from Undisclosed
I have been using this mascara for several years . It stays on and is gentle to my lashes.
Kathenia S. from Undisclosed
I wasn't happy with how it applied, smeared all over my upper and lower lids. I really couldn't tell that I had any mascara on
Kimberly P. from Undisclosed
Not only is the finish beautiful, and wakes up my eyes, there is a quality I can't really describe - it just feels good using the wand - the bristles on my lashes are soothing. It feels "plush", is the best word I can think of. I have been using this product with the conditioner prior for years now, and the combination of this duo has been unmatched by any other products I have tried. Highly recommend!
Igor A. from Undisclosed
At first I liked the tube and the brush, but in fact. I had to layer the mascara four times on the upper eyelashes and I did not see any volume and length. Mascara should not be applied to the mucous membrane of the eye, otherwise small hairs get into it and irritate it, and they also crumble. It also imprints, it should not be applied to the lower eyelashes ((
Patricia C. from Undisclosed
I love the brush and the container because it doesnt get clogged up with mascara but wish it was waterproof.
McKinzie K. from Undisclosed
I have been using this mascara for years and love it! It doesn't ever clump and makes my eyelashes look really long. I keep reordering it and always hope they continue this line.
Devon E. from Undisclosed
This product does lengthen yet does not thicken .
Jennifer D. from Undisclosed
I love the way this mascara glides on. I love that there is no clumping. I also love that I can control how thick I want it to be. The only thing I dislike is that the tiny bristles on the brush come out when I'm applying the mascara.
Dawn D. from Undisclosed
I was a long time client and have switched MANY of my friends to this mascara The LAST PURCHASE , my mascara seemed clumpy But this tube Is just OLD I'm VERY DISAPPOINTED And can't seem to see my try for a third time I'm traveling in Italy and had to purchase another brand because of it made my eyes irritated