Rated 4.55 out of 5 stars
I bought the teal, green, and yellow (fresh, gotcha, and screamin) and I like them but there are some flaws. To sharpen them you have to use a pencil sharpener but the container is made of plastic so plastic flakes get into your sharpener (and possibly into the environment which is bad). I wish they were made of wood or something more sustainable. They are also a bit dry, not so bad that they tug on the lids, but I wouldn't call them creamy. I tried using the green as a lip liner (it says they can be lip liners or eyeliners) and it pulled on my lips and was kind of patchy. I didn't have a green lipstick to try over it, which might have made it better, but I definitely wouldn't be able to wear it alone. I still like them because it's hard to find fun colors from affordable brands, and they do provide a nice pop of color that I really enjoy for the summer!
I went right over to Ulta after watching a beautiful makeup tutorial by Angelica Nyqvist who used the neon eyeliner "Fresh." I thought it was a unique and gorgeous color, and perused the other colors as well. I ended up ordering all of them except the white one. Sadly, ALL of these irritated my eyes, made them watery, burning and also my eyelids were sore all day and slightly puffy after using these. I am leaving the same review on all of the ones I purchased since they all irritated my waterline and my eyelids. There is a reason why the ingredient list isn't even listed! I bet these all contain Carmine, which is a known serious allergic ingredient in a lot of cosmetics and even food. BUYER BEWARE.
And..... it doesn't even sharpen! Once you use the tip, that's all. Returning for refund!
Shaun from San Diego, CA
I tried to sharpen this eye pencil and it breaks off along with the peel. A waste of my money so I will never buy this again. If I could sharpen it or it rolled up it would be worth it but this is now useless.
Rachael from Pennsylvania
I know the colors look neon but they dont even show under black light which was the whole reason i bought it. Also they are very dry, and dont go on well. But they do stay put once on! Dont buy if toure expecting the to show up inder a blacklight.
Aquarabbit from Pennsylvania
I picked two of these up around Valentines Day and then two more in July. Every time I use them
I'm reminded of Dibs lip liners! They are great because they STAY ON and apply super smoothly snd cling to lips like ink but no major dryness. Believe me, I suffer from super dry lips. The shades are very workable- Gingerbread, Mauve, Couqutte, Maple Glaze. Definitely a staple in my makeup kit!
cienna from San bernardino Ca
my favorite lip liner ever bro i get so many compliments on this lip liner buy it right now it's amazinggggg 😆😆 i use the gingerbread shade!! it matches and compliments my skin tone soooo well, 110% recommend buy righttt nowww u won't regret it!!!
Miko from Texas
I bought this eyeliner in black and it's the worst I've ever used. It goes on easily but it crumbles all over my eye area. I've tried it twice and now sent it to the trash.
AVC from Bakersfield CA
The shade gingerbread is my favorite it goes with any lio color !
Mzsparkle77 from IL
I purchased blaze online because the swatch looks magenta purplish! There is nothing purple about it! It is bright pink! I'm looking for a Magenta lip liner and can't seem to find the right color!!!
Super easy to break..disappointed!!
yr from usa
the color was lighter than i thought it would be. maybe that is cos of my skin tone, but when i did the try on feauture, it was still darker than what it actually is. other than that it applies nice. i just thought it would be darker.
DewyBrows from Rhode Island
I bought blue & purple. Blue was beautiful. Bright. I didn't appreciate the tug and pull on my lids, I think it should glide easier. But I loved the color. Purple tip fell off as soon as I put it to my eye. Completely unusable after I'd just opened it. Waste.
Betty from Las Vegas, NV
What great pigment. Glides on nice and smooth. Great color
MakeupGEEK✨ from Santa Maria California
Applys so smooth! Never skips, applys even over foundation and powder.
jaxson from richmond va
i use in my waterline and i didnt notice a ton of fading. super pigmented (i got both greens and the black). creamy. love
Nat from columbus oh
So sad, I got 3 of these eyeliners, they are creamy but white and brown are not pigmented at all!!! I have brown skin and even after applying 10 times they wouldn't show on my skin. As expected, after those 10 times the tip of the eyeliner was gone, and that was all, you can't get more from the inside of the eyeliner. Blue was alright but in general is a waste of money!!!!!
Ctorrez from Oregon
Loved the color and how pigmented tgis is BUT (huge BUT) wheh uih go ti sharpen the whole colored pencil comes out and thenits done ans cant use it anymore. I really hope thw see all these reviews and do something about cuz it had potential
CeeCee from Denver, CO
White doesn't show up on my dark complexion, very disappointing.
Naomi from Marietta, georgia
I got the color "rosewood" and its gorgeous def recommend!
Dima from washington, DC
hear me out; i've never been a big fan of eyeliner; black eyeshadow is just so much easier to work with and do a soft line, and eyeliner always stings when i put it in my water line so i've always done other looks that don't require that. however, i've been wanting to recreate more grungy 90s smudged eyeliner looks and bought this eyeliner in black on a whim. WOW. it's the creamiest application ever, and for the first time i've tried a product that applies to my waterline without pain and actually stays there at full opacity. i didn't even know that was possible with my watery eyes! it also smudges out so well while still allowing you to effortlessly pack on pigment. i'm so excited about all the grungy looks i'll do with this little magic fella!
Vee from San Antonio Tx
Has anyone that has purchased these before know what type of sharper to use? Every time I use my eye pencil sharpener it always seems to take a chuck off. I love these colors but kinda sucks it wears down so quickly.
Raiinbowbrite87 from L.A, California ❤
I don't get the hype about these, i got the shade "lullaby", since it was out of stock when I first heard how "good" these were, I stocked up and bought 10 of these in "lullaby" as soon as they were in stock, they came & I was hopeful they lived up to their hype but sadly no they don't. I like them but not love them as I wish I did
Tess from Seattle WA
I would love to give these a higher rating, because the colors are wonderful; super pigmented, hugely bright true neon colors, but the pencils are nearly impossible to sharpen, and the crayon breaks off in the sharpener, plus the makeup gets stiff very fast and then it's difficult to use, like it's gone stale. Disappointing, but they aren't very expensive so it might just be that. Still, I love the colors. I own about four.
Michele from Spring Hill FL
3rd time buying this and will continue.
Anna from Omaha, NE
I bought this product in the shade lullaby for my bottom waterline. I like to use it as a little more natural color instead of white and I like how it's a little metallic so it's still bright. Sometimes though t seems like the color isn't really showing up depending on the angle you're looking at since it is metallic. I haven't used it as a normal eyeliner yet, but would assume you wouldn't have this problem since it would be looked at straight on. Overall, i really like this eyeliner. It glides on super easily and the other colors have are great and pigmented as well
Sunlily from Lake Kiowa, Texas
I absolutely love the shade Fresh. It is by far the most used liner in a very large collection. It sharpens easily, applies smoothly, stays put, and removes without trouble. Highly recommend especially for the price.
However, Vivid is not as good as Fresh. vivid is hard to sharpen and is too soft to apply easily. I do love the color so I work with it, but I'm trying to find a better formula
Chimmie from Los Angeles, CA
I genuinely enjoy these eyeliners, they're great for providing a pop of color to the under eyes and I have no issues applying them on
Dee from Little Rock, AR
I love bold colors for my eyes!!!! My eyes pop with these vibrant colors for my eyes.