Rated 4.25 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Stays put no running.I...
Stays put no running.I can even use on my waterline with contacts!!.Glides on and great pigmentation.Plus the price is awesome.The Brown is a nice shade.Black too.LOVE! my search is over
Most Helpful Critical Review Long lasting but difficult to apply
This is not my favorite liner but I still keep it in my makeup bag because it is long lasting and doesn't fade after wearing it all day. It is not creamy enough to easily apply to the top lid and the pigment isn't strong enough to stay on the waterline. Personally I like to use the Nyx matte liquid liner on my top lid and then I put it on the outer corner of my lower lashes and smudge it out. I think this liner works pretty well for a good smokey eye. I would say that this product is a good addition to your makeup collection but you might want to look elsewhere if you are just looking for a more versatile liner.
Reviewed by 2151 customers My new go-to
Dz from St louis
Fantastic color saturation, creamy and easy to apply, stays all day!! My new go-to!!
Bad allergic reaction
Karlaren from North Carolina
I bought 4 of these when they were on sale. I've used both the blue and teal ones without any problems. However the purple caused a severe allergic reaction with chemosis (severe conjunctivitis) of both eyes and swelling around my eyes, so severe that I had to get a steroid shot and take steroids by mouth. Not sure what ingredient is different in this pencil but now I'm afraid to try the bronze one. If you have any sensitivities, I would just avoid this brand altogether. Sometimes, you really get what you pay for. :-(
CB from Missouri
This product glides on like butter!
averyam3 from San Jose, CA
OK I am horrible at putting on eyeliner to begin with, but this was very hard to apply. It does not glide on easily or smoothly, to big of a line. I ordered two of them, and one of them came with pretty much no eyeliner in it. I was told that you just twist the top to get it to retract but nothing came out. Will not buy again.
Some Colors Good
Leah B from Delaware, OH
Gypsy Blue keeps me coming back to this retractable eyeliner. It's a beautiful, creamy, shimmery peacock blue. However, not all colors are shimmer nor are creamy. The bronze/brown color is a bit of shimmer and creamy but the purple is matte and cakey. The olive is also cakey and won't apply well. I have no idea why the same product seems to have two completely different formulas. I've bought Gypsy Blue multiple times and usually pick up another color to see if it will also be as amazing. So far, blue and brown are the only two I've rebought.
Deep Blue - pretty much a perfect blue eyeliner pencil!
Denise :) from TN - Tennessee
I have big brown eyes, so in order to make them pop, I was on the prowl for a good cruelty-free blue retractable eyeliner pencil. This stuff became my god before I ran out of it (a few weeks to a month after using it 5 days a week). It has a slight shimmer to it and is like a deep sapphire-y or cobalt blue. It glides on smoothly and does the job pretty well, and it lasts throughout the day for the most part. Would recommend! Not gonna lie though, I feel like almost $6 for this is a bit much.
Goes on smooth
Lynn from South Central Indiana
I use this on lower eye water line to brighten my eye look.
Tj from Fl
I like the green.
It last all day and waterproof
Jules from Massachusetts
Best eye liner I've ever used.
NYX can do No Wrong in(or on) my eyes👀 !!
Trisha D from SC from Charleston, SC
Looooove NYX lip and eye products!! The quality, the value! What's NOT to love!! With this eyeliner specifically, it glides without skipping and the color is rich. My eyes were irritated with long wear. Lasted through a day of physical therapy and 4 loads of laundry!!
Would not buy again.
Judy from Arcola, Illinois
I've used as eyeliner but it wears off within a couple of hours. I won't return because it was cheap but I won't buy NYX again. Disappointed.
The tube does not twist so it's a total waste of money. I've
Marilyn from NY
Tube does not twist and liner showing at top almost flat after 4 used
Love these eyeliners
DJ from Florida
This waterproof eyeliner is easy to use. Easy to wipe off upon first applying if over applying. I set it with a light power, and it stays on until the next day.
OKlippie3 from OKC
I was able to use it after I ran out of my eyeliner that was discontinued. It did its job and was cheaper
Can't get it to work...crumbles.
Eskie Lover from Wisconsin
Disappointed with retractable, but
Am loving the regular eye liners and colors by NYC.
I love it
Laura from Seattle
Simple touch to improve my eyes
Great dupe for urban decay eyeliner
Allison from Charleston WV
It's got a teensy bit of sparkle in the brown. Texture is very smooth. Price makes it a great sub for my urban decay liners. I'm going to buy more colors in this brand.
Great application & color
Rita from SW Utah
I have hazel eyes, & this Golden Olive color really brings out the gold flecks in my eyes in a subtle way. This is my go to color & looks great with casual & dressy attire it glides on easily & isn't overpowering.
Tried and true from Salt Lake City, UT
This eyeliner solves every issue I've had with other eyeliners for years. It goes on smoothly and easily. The line is thin and doesn't get too fat unless I go over it multiple times. And it actually stays put! Plus the dark brown color is juuuuust right.
Just what I was looking for!
Krisita from Minnesota
Goes on easy, stays put. Will be buying other colors too.
Good retractable liner
DrCALFON from Florida
Works as intended for under eye liner. Vibrant color. Not as thin/narrow/fine as expected despite angled tip. Does smudge/run as day wears on. Brighter blue color than wanted (looking for navy blue).
Good retractable eyeliner
DrCALFON from Florida
Works as intended for under eye liner. Vibrant, solid color. Goes on wider than expected despite pointed tip, and does smudge/run as day wears on.
Mila from Bc
Love this for the price and it's really smooth for application!
Ladyxul from Louisville KY
Easy to use long lasting
Browwizgang from IA
Reminds me of cheap Halloween makeup