Product Reviews Rated 3.93 out of 5 stars
378 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Pretty Good, but not for me... I really liked the mascara, but I already have long and full lashes. The mascara gave them a lot of length and a good amount of volume, for a mascara not labeled as a volume one. It seperated and grabbed every single one. the brush really grips and pulls each lash upward for a very nice effect. the mascara never dries out!! I've had mine for over 2 months. All in all, a definte keeper.
Most Helpful Critical Review Poor Replacement for XXL Pro Extensions Mascara I had high hopes for this mascara since it is supposed to be Maybelline's replacement for their XXL Pro Extensions mascara, but alas, I was very disappointed. the XXL mascara was perfect--not too runny or thick, didn't flake and produced ridiculously long, natural looking lashes to rival Diorshow Mascara. the Illegal lengths stuff is a far cry from that--flaky and weirdly thick, this stuff is anything but a great lengthening mascara. Maybelline, please bring back the XXL and NEVER discontinue the Full and Soft mascara!
Reviewed by 378 customers My fav mascara 5
Thaliarod from UT
Ive been using this máscara since highschool I try others but allways seem to come back to this one. I hate how I cant find it anywhere anymore
It just ok.. 3
Cort.Yerian from Ohio
Nothing to rave about here. This mascara is alright, I will not be purchasing again.
Instant lash extensions 5
Mg from Wilmington, nc
This has lash extension fibers in it. It is fantastic! I don't know why this is not more famous yet
Would definitely buy again 5
Jess from Murfreesboro, TN
Really like the slimness of the applicator. Feel like it grabs every single lash and really makes them look so much longer.
What happened to the Waterproof? 3
Glo72 from Texas
Love this mascara in the waterproof formula. I can't find it anywhere. Please bring it back!
Just ok 3
T from Oh
It's ok, but "illegal length" is stretching it - pun intended
Been a favorite since I was 11 5
Danyella from undisclosed
This is my favorite it was the first mascara I ever tried when it came out I was 11 and was using it then along with falsies black drama don't ever discontinue please. I will cry
Disappointing 2
Morge from Md
This looks nice at first but flakes so easily. I have to check my under eye at least twice during the day to clean up the black mess. I like another maybelline mascara but this was disappointing.
Pretty good 4
xxyourstrulymakeupxx from Richmond
I had high hopes for this mascara and while it definitely does add some length, it just didn't give me that long fiber effect I was looking for. It is a good mascara and I'm keeping it, just nothing that really blows me away.
So flaky :( 3
steph1347 from Nebraska
Applies and builds well, but flakes off when it dries!
Good 4
mayda from Italy
Really longer lashes, I really appreaciated the formula.It's thin ,not heavy and pasty on the lashes.If it were a little blacker and voluminous, maybe it would be even better. I would like a mascara that you don't feel on your eyelashes
Best lengthening mascara out there 5
MEATHER from Upstate NY
I have been using this mascara since it was released. It is literally the only one I love. I have tried 30 dollar mascaras and 3 dollar mascaras and none compare to this. I am not sure if this is going to be discontinued or what, but none of the stores carry it anymore and it makes me so sad. I have found nothing that even compares to it. It truly lengthens your lashes and is just amazing! Please never get rid of it. Please tell walmart to bring it back. Please!
awesome 5
skny from NY
this is probably one of the best fiber mascaras out there!
make sure you use a good lash primer and your lashes will look fabulous!!!
Best mascara 5
deb1952 from Kansas
This mascara is the best on the market and let me tell you...I have spent 40.00 on a mascara that SUCKED and every price point in between. This does not flake, if you cry it does not run...it washes off like a breeze. Makes my lashes look AmaZING! It's getting hard to find and this makes me nervous...please dont discontinue this mascara!
Worst mascara ever used! 2
Hannahc25 from Lillington, NC
I was excited to try a mascara with fibers that would lengthen my lashes. Not only did I layer it but I curled my lashes before hand and followed directions on the back of the packaging. This mascara is by far the worst mascara I've ever used. I never leave reviews but im extremely dissatisfied with my results. It clumped my lashes and made them flatten. Just made my lashes look disgusting. Didn't give more length than a normal Maybelline mascara or any other mascara I've tried. Only gets 2 stars because it's a functioning mascara... And I say that lightly. I want my money back
Best mascara ever! 5
Brooke27 from St. Augustine, FL
I have light blonde barely there lashes. This mascara makes my lashes look amazing. Dark, long, curled... and they hold all day. Doesn't smudge, yet removes easily with oil free makeup remover. Please don't ever stop making this! HG mascara!
Not what they said it would be 1
Beauty lover from Tacoma, WA
Typically I love Maybelline mascara. This one does nothing for me. After a
coat, I didn't notice much difference. After two still nothing, after three coats, it looked like one. I was excited about this mascara but would not buy it again
Made lashes look even longer did stick more a little togethe 4
Diamond Lackey from Redding ca
Use everyday
Love it! 5
Whitney from Arlington Texas
Love it! My everyday mascara and it lengthens beautifully!
Just OK 3
AM from Rochester NY
I expected this to be better as I have used fiber extension mascaras before. It is ok but I wouldn't go out of my way to purchase it again, their other mascaras work just as well if not better.
A true lengthening mascara! 5
Linda0322 from Michigan
I have used this mascara for years and truly love it! So I was worried when I saw that my local Walmart was no longer stocking it. It truly does lengthen with the fibers that other mascara lack. Please, please, please do not discontinue this product. The other "lengthening" products don't lengthen, in my opinion.
My go to mascara 5
Dawn from USA
This is my every day mascara. I use it as a primer and as a light lengthening mascara for the gym or running to the store. It lengthens unbelievably and never clumps
It's OK. 2
K from USA
This mascara is just OK. I can't say that it's awful, but I also can't say that it's great. I do notice a difference when I apply this mascara, but it is minimal. It isn't a bad product, but for $8 you can definitely find better options at the drugstore. I do like this mascara for my bottom lashes though because it doesn't transfer; however, that isn't a big enough reason for me to consider repurchasing it.
So far love it 5
Valerie from Idaho
Definitely recommend!
My favorite mascara but... 4
Sharon from Austin, TX
Such a great mascara for everyday. I liked it a lot but had to switch brands since Ulta & other stores don't carry the waterproof version. Maybelline likely wanting to make users migrate to their other new versions.
