Rated 3.84 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Good buy
Really great eyeliner, glad that I picked this up. Doesn't smudge and it's pretty long lasting, yet it's easy to remove with make up remover. The thin tip is great, and as a beginner, it's really easy to use this product. Would definitely buy this again!
Most Helpful Critical Review Favourite eyeliner no more
I've been buying this eyeliner for probably around 8 years and it has never disappointed. Today however, I went to replace my current Master Precise as it was finally running/drying out, and I was SO disappointed. I obviously jinxed it when I told my mum this was the only product I have consistently bought again and again.
The formula and actual tip of the pen have obviously changed, as it used to be a felt type tip and it is now a smaller more flexible and slippery tip. AND its absolutely terrible, my old Master Precise actually still worked better than this new formula, it was way blacker and crispier than the charcoal-grey, streaky newcomer, even if it says "Blackest Black" on the packaging. I will NEVER understand why companies change their formulas/packaging when it was perfectly fine to begin with.
Reviewed by 1503 customers pretty good!!
eemaan from Chicago, IL
I started using this product after using an eyeliner pencil and this is so much better than what I used to use. the color is very rich and the I feel like the learning curve wasn't that steep.
I love this!
EmilY from Fresno
I love eyeliner and use it every day for school, i have to reapply since it comes off easy but the tip is amazing for cateye. I can control the strokes with my shaky hands by far the best eyeliner i tried
MakeupKaween from Maryland
So, I needed a new eyeliner so I went for this. Immediately I realized it was very pigmented(yay!!) after one use though the tip is already dry. I'm storing it upside down to see if that helps.
Srin from Seattle, WA
I ran to the store to find a money friendly eyeliner and this eyeliner did the trick! I was a bit skeptical since in the past when i bought cheap eyeliner, the quality was bad. To my surprise this one doesn't smudge, has long wear, and has a grip too!!
Not for sensitive eyes
TxHockeyGal from Texas
I loved the staying power but not the heavy, allergenic feeling it caused me. Returning this one today.
Not great for hooded eyes
Officer Pauly from Des Moines, IA
Application is smooth, however, I definitely do NOT recommend if you have hooded eyes or oily skin. This stuff runs and smears, even with a setting spray.
Urban from Chicago
I'm not sure if i'm using it wrong or something but it litrally is the worst eyeliner i've ever used. It's advertised as waterproof but comes off when it comes in contact with moisture? Wouldn't recommend jt especially during summer
Def not waterproof or even resistant
Erin F from Connecticut
This is a nice black liner. I've been using it for about a week and it feels nice and looks great but it's not waterproof at all. Every time I get a new liner I draw one line on the back of my hand and wear it throughout the day so I can see how it holds up. Literally the first time I got water on the mark it came off. I love the price of this liner but it's not what it's advertised.
I will buy this product again
D.D. from Roanoke
Very easy to use and my eyeliner is a straight line.
My go-to eyeliner
HallA from Los Angeles, CA
No need to spent $$$ on brand eyeliner. It's great for those first starting out with liquid eyeliner as it's easy to use and looks amazing.
Good Liner Pen
maddy from va
I received a sample size of this product as a free gift with purchase months ago. I've worn it a few times and I like it. The brush isn't too hard and it creates a nice line. If anyone is having issues with liner pens drying out fast try keeping them cap down. There's also a way to unclog them by putting it in hot water. I've need using these tricks from Google and I haven't had a problems with any liner pen.
All time favorite since 2014
AJ from Waterford
The felt tip is amazing and super easy to work with! You can go bold or soft/natural and the clean up is effortless. Also great for graphic designs.
does what i need it to do
jai from illinois
i didnt realize it was waterproof, which i dont normally want, but besides that its a perfectly adequate black eyeliner. the little grip is a nice touch
Have tried this one 2-3 times and won't buy again
MUA Brittney from Pueblo, CO
It's great for the first swipe. Then it starts bumping and missing places like there isn't enough product coming out. Won't be trying this one again
BEST EYELINER EVER!
Meg Mo from Michigan
I have slightly hooded eyes and every eyeliner I use gets on my eyelid or starts to die after 5-10 uses and makes clean lines and black wings near impossible. I just got this eyeliner and used it on my left eye, the eye that never wants to cooperate wing wise, and was able to do a jet black flawless wing instantly. My wings have never looked so crisp and the lines are so precise, especially on the inner corners and lash line. I'll def be buying again!
Danielle from FL
I use eyeliner EVERY DAY and this eyeliner is perfect for the price and simple eyeliner look. one pen lasted me about 3 months, which is incredible for the cheapness and daily use from me! its also a good option for beginners as it is cheap and easy to remove. i will continuie using this and recommending it forever!
I like it!
Nora from Florida
I like this liquid eyeliner. It glides on smoothly and doesn't run and holds up well in the Florida humidity.
Liner does not flow consistently through brush
Sandra from Rehobith Beach, Delaware
I bought this product to be able to line my eyes in one, smooth line. Unfortunately, the brush runs out of liner in just a nano-second requiring me to stroke the liner on in bits and pieces. Not happy with it at all.
Dry and dry
Tiff from Alameda
It was good for 1 wear, no smudges and came off easily when needed. But it only lasted for 1 wear. I thought I might have forgot to close the cap so I bought another and same exact situation. I loved the formula but the way they designed the pen/cap is terrible.
Great, but not waterproof
hm1124 from Tempe, AZ
This is a great felt tip liner for creating a wing, the pigment is nice and dark and even. it's easy to use, it would especially be great for a beginner looking to practice winged liner. However if you really need a waterproof eyeliner this isn't it. I don't know why they keep saying it is cause it isn't at all. Maybelline does make great waterproof eye products but this isn't waterproof at all. Now if you don't like waterproof eyeliner this is a great option. However if you need a great waterproof eyeliner I'd recommend the lasting drama gel eyeliner instead. But overall, it is a good liner.
One of my favs!
Jess from Wisconsin
I love this product. I buy it over and over again. It's one of my favorites. It's a smooth eyeliner, goes on smooth, stays on and is long lasting. Highly recommended and makes for a great winged eyeliner! Truly one of the best on the market! Great price point!
Favorite for years
Nina from Ohio
I've been using this eyeliner for years. Every time I switch, I regret it. So easy to use and get a nice sharp point too.
Dispenses too much liquid
Dispenses too much liquid from Downey
I had been using this eyeliner for a while now but recently I noticed that it's dispensing too much liquid. Even if I hardly even press down on it. This has resulted in me just blinking, and it drips down to my lashes and onto my undereye. Which then makes me wash it all off, take off my contact lens because it goes inside my eye, and then redo it. This is horrible when getting ready before work EVERY DAY. Won't buy again.
Violet from Tempe, AZ
This eyeliner was absolutely terrible. I bought it as a gift for someone, and we both ended up trying it and thinking it was bad quality. The pen would be completely dry, then when I'd apply slightly more pressure, it'd suddenly make a big blob of eyeliner. Once the eyeliner dried, it was flaky. I definitely wouldn't recommend this product.
Joc from California
This liner is very bad. It's only pigmented for the first use, but after that it is not. It also smudges pretty bad and it just kinda melts off after 30 minutes. The tip of the liner also gets dry after the first use. 10/10 DONT recommend.