Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Unbelievable
I'd heard people raving about They're Real! I mean, who hasn't. But I didn't believe it. There was no way a mascara could create such incredible results. So when I recently bought a Beauty Score from the Benefit Kiosk in the Las Vegas airport, I was elated to see the They're Real! tube in the bottom of the box. I'm sold. Game over. I don't see myself every buying another mascara. They're Real! makes my lashes long and thick and with no flakes! Just amazing. It also helps that the wand is like perfection. The end is great for getting those thin lashes and the design certainly helps separate the lashes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Burn baby burn!
Once my 30th birthday was a few months away, I decided it was time to get proactive about my under eye care. Previously, I used whatever heavy moisturizer I used on my face. This seemed to be something that would be up my alley. I'm African-American with very sensitive and dry skin. I do not have any fine lines or wrinkles. Nor do I have any dark bags. At least, I didn't UNTIL I started using this product. But, before I list out all the horrible effects I suffered from this "potent" product, I will say that the one issue I had before starting this was that I have a toddler so I'm sleep deprived. I also am a trial attorney, so am extra sleep deprived. That's it.
The first time I used this, it burned. I wasn't sure if hey it's a "tingle" or a burn, so I decided to try it again. I told myself it must be potent! No aging here! I even told my 35 year old brother to try it, and he yelled that it burns. Whoops. In addition, I developed dark black bags under my eyes, and scaly dry patches. I thought this was supposed to moisturize!?! Obviously, I discontinued use, but after a week of using it once a day, my eyes are tender, sore, have scaly dry white patches, and black underneath. It hurts to blink!
Reviewed by 93434 customers had to just throw it away
desi from Garland, TX
I didn't even finish it. the brush got all bent, the liquid never made it to the felt tip. this was definitely over hyped.
Grease from Scranton
I wanted to love this but I get super greasy and it pulls my makeup in all different directions. I'll stick with NYX pore minimizer!!!
Really makes a difference!!
GrammyL from Columbia
I am allergic to lots of mascara so I was thrilled to be able to try the travel size to check this one out. Was looking for something like Thrive and this was recommended. Really does lengthen lashes!! Comes in 2 colors and 2 sizes. Really HAPPY with this.
Zdawg from Duluth
Dried out quickly on my eyelids and crumbled. If I teared up ever wearing it it would immediately start to run and would burn my eyes. The pen also dried out after just my fourth use
The eyeliner and young lady doing it was great!
Linda from NY
I really hope you find someone soon so I can have eyelash extensions, make up and my hair done for a wedding.
Works like actual glue!!
yarized from California
When I use this on my brows on the days I go out, my eyebrow hairs stay in place!! I love this eyebrow gel and definitely recommend it.
Mickey from Indiana
Love it but I'm not sure it's as long lasting as advertised online. Still worth it though!
Wicked raccoon eyes
Nik from Detroit
This Magnet Extreme one leaves you with huge raccoon eyes after not very long, which I found surprising cuz the regular "They're Real!" variety doesn't do that. Very disappointing. Glad I only bought a mini.
I would not buy this product again
a Typical Girly Girl from Fernandina Beach, Florida
This product did not work at all in terms of lengthening or adding to my lashes AT ALL!! SO MAD I paid so much for SO LITTLE!!
"At last..the best mascara has come along"
April from Texas
Never need an eyelash curler again!
Best Mascara I have EVER used!
MrsMojoRisin from New Jersey
Hands down best mascara!
Love this one
Tam from Rockford
I would not buy
Bun from Oak Island, NC
I need a smaller brush. My friend bought this product and found it difficult to remove.
Addie from hinesville, ga
it sat beautifully on the skin and it minimized my large pores. a little goes a long way so it should last a little while.
iz from ky
i've been using this mascara for over a year now and literally the best mascara ever. it doesn't clump and it's easy to work with. i definitely recommend getting it !!
My go to for pore minimizing
mommy of 3D from Gresham,OR
A little goes a long way
Kathey from Massachusetts
I was looking for something that wasn't a pencil and the person that help me was very friendly and knew what she was talking about.
I would purchase again
CJ from Kenosha, WI
Use it every day. It does the trick!
I love it!
CJ from Kenosha, WI
I bought it for the smudger. I ended up really liking the liner. Comes off easy with makeup remover.
Clump Crusher from CoverGirl
Lexi from Clearwater
Got this product as a sample in a box of four other Benefit mascaras. I'm a die hard Better than Sex Mascara from Too Face fan but wanted to try it. Don't recommend this mascara due too it's identical for the Clump Crusher mascara by CoverGirl.
Brow Microfilling Pen
suncakes from wa
its a no on my sparse brows
I love this eyebrow pencil!
Glamour Girl from Waterbury, CT
I was loyal to another brand for years, until I tried Benefit.
not what I had hoped for
Rockin Robin from Waterbury, CT.
I thought it was entirely overrated for the price
jcarbs from Kent, Ohio
This is by far the best brow pen. It looks completely natural. I use a spoolie to brush my eyebrows up with got2b spiking glue. Wait for it to dry and then use the pen. My eye browns literally do not move all day and look unbelievable!!!!
Favorite eyebrow product
Sid from KS
I love this product! I've been using it for about 2 years now and even though I feel like it's a bit pricey I still won't change it.