Rated 4.32 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I would 1000000% buy this again
Wow, I don't have enough great things to say about this. I found out that my boyfriend who I was going to marry cheated on me, so I cried for nearly 7 hours one day with this mascara on. To my shock, this mascara was still in place and only smudged a little bit. And when I say I cried, I mean I was in fetal position on the ground...and this mascara still held up. So y'all, go buy this thing because I will forever swear by it and if I could marry it, I would. Cause we all know it would be more faithful than my man could ever be. Solid 10/10
Most Helpful Critical Review Not at all impressed
How disappointing - I finally drop some money on a mascara and it didn't even compare to the CoverGirl LashBlast I normally use. My friend did like the look, but I like it when my eyelashes look long AND full. If you try to layer it, it just clumps up.
I even put They're Real on one eye and the CoverGirl on the other eye and asked a GUY at work which was better and he said, without a doubt, the CoverGirl eye was just as long but much more volume. So don't waste your money.
Reviewed by 10839 customers I would buy it again
medi2002 from anchorage, alaska
Love the face it gives the length to my lashes, one thing bad about it, it shows alittle bit of clumps on my lash. But all and all its a good mascara.
Girly from Las Vegas Nevada
Love it. Best mascara.
Love how it makes my lashes look so long
Kloyer from Whittier, NC
Love how it makes my lashes look so long and it's not heavy
Always a Favorite!
Gigi from Greenville, Nc
Great overall coverage.
The Best Mascara
Rachel from NJ
My go-to mascara for beautiful lashes.
It clumps my lashes together
Dani from Auburn ca
I can only say in so many words the same statement. This mascara clumps my eyelashes together so it looks like a have 10 lashes instead of spreading out and making them look thick and full.
HOLY GRAIL ALERT
SammiMakeUp from MA
SO.... I tried this mascara probably about 2-3 years ago and hated it, I thought my lashes looked spikey and spidery. I purchased it again a couple days ago to see if maybe my lashes would take to it better this time, or maybe since I'm better at applying make up it would turn out differently. I couldn't understand how I hated a mascara that had such a HUGE cult following. OMG. I don't know what happened, but it's incredible. I'm assuming it could have been my application technique, as I feel this mascara takes a little finessing to get that false lash look. My lashes look unreal AND it doesn't smudge. I was swearing by Roller Lash and Diorshow up until now.... They're Real is the only one for me
The best mascara!!
Kels from Tn
I've been using this stuff for YEARSSS it's perfect & I always get compliments on it! I have tried other mascaras & none of them even compare to this one. Its worth the price
They're Real....is for real!
Jo from FL
I purchased for a vacation trip. First, I was thinking about individual lashes, them a friend told me about They're Real, so I decided to try it. I'm so happy I did, I think my lashes now look like I paid for them. They look, think and long! They're beautiful! I'm a big fan and will continue to buy.
Not a fan
tmoe from Maryland
I have this mascara and the bang one. I dislike them both. They are so wet and clump my lashes together making them look like a hot mess. I even left them alone for months to "dry up" and it didn't get any better. I take pride in how my lashes look and this is not it. I prefer cheaper CoverGirl Clump Crusher over this.
Comparable to drugstore brand
JenJen from Florida
Meh. Not impressed. I applied they're real on one eye and my drug store brand on the other. They were basically the same but my drugstore brand is waterproof which I have to have in the Florida heat. However I didn't see any flakes or clumping.
Best mascara ever
celestinamaria from KS
My #1 mascara! Never lets me down and makes my lashes look beautiful
Nat from Chicago
I don't get it. It is so highly rated and my best friend loves it too! I got it as a gift from her and I'm not a fan. Its really "wet" and clumps my lashes completely together plus barely giving length. Some drug store mascaras are way better at adding length and are not clumpy at all. So strange that so many people love it.
Mosey from Bayshore mall
Very natural looking
Ellie from Seattle wa
I was so surprised the first time I used this, how long my lashes appeared. Goes on so quick and easy. Cons you have to rub a little bit more to remove it and miscellaneous water doesn't seem to do as good a job as Neutrogena makeup remover. Water resistant and does Not flake! Great product!
gracie from MA
i've used this for four years on and off and it is the best mascara i have ever used! it makes your lashes so long and not clumpy!
Best mascara I've ever used
Tayalli from Raleigh, NC
I love this mascara! I have received several compliments on my lashes & even some asking me if they actually were real. A little pricey but certainly well worth it. I like to apply in very layers because it can get a little clumpy. Overall the best mascara I've tried so far.
I've tried so many but I KEEP COMING BACK!!
Emmalee from Missouri
I got They're Real as a gift when I first started doing makeup and LOVED it. Then I began to experiment with other brands and was always disappointed. Whether it was clumpy or would give me coon eyes after only a few hours of wear, it never lived up to the expectations set by this product. Like a prodigal BeneBabe, I've come home!
Angel from Altamonte Springs
Beautiful and brown! Only or coat needed.
My new favorite go-to!
Erin from Michigan
I was encouraged to try this mascara because of the fact that it's one of the few "true" brown mascaras that aren't too dark. After a week of use I can honestly say I'm hooked! It gives a great amount of volume and length without clumping my lashes together. I cannot stress enough how much I love the color! My only qualm is that the product does often get rub off on my eyelid from the tips of my eyelashes, so I wish it was a bit more water resistant so this wouldn't happen. I'm an ER nurse and work 12+ hour shifts and I really put my makeup to the test daily and that is the only issue I've had with the product. Other than that it is amazing!
Carol from Pittsburgh
Clumps and makes my lashes look spidery
I love love this mascara!!!
None from Clinton Township, mi
Love this mascara
I do not recommend
Mommas from Durango, Colorado
I decided to try a new mascara and went with the benefit mascara, I totally regret it. It's really goopy and messy.
My lashes are full and have a pretty good length to them which normally makes it a breeze to apply mascara. I had the worst time and by the time I was finished, it wasn't even worth it. I looked like I just cried my eyes out, my lashes were stuck together and the mascara was running. Big no, no!
So Disappointed - Overpriced and Tacky Results
LISA from Dallas
I hate this mascara and can't believe it's so highly rated. I finally splurged on it and my lashes look horrible, sticky, spikey, not natural at all. I felt like Tammy Faye Bakker and like I was wearing cheap mascara. I want to send it back for a refund. HORRIBLE! I'm going back to my inexpensive Cover Girl Lash Blast.
Thickens lashes without fibers
Bean from North Fort Myers, Florida
Use just like any other mascara. Two coats are better than one and lashes really thicken!