Rated 4.22 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I'm here to save the day
These pencils are amazing, but I have found that the best way to use them is to pot them and apply with a brush. I found that after a while the product gets low and because they can only be sharpened so much, you tend to lose a lot of product. About a min in the microwave liquidfies it. After it cools it is just as creamy as it was in the tube and you have an entire 5mg jar full of product to use!
Most Helpful Critical Review Will not sharpen, waste of money
I have bought three of these thinking each one was defective because once the tip wore down, I was unable to sharpen it because of the heavy plastic. I even have the NYX sharpener and still won't even come close to sharpening it, I have tried everything to get them to sharpen. They are all completely unusable with 80 of the pencil still left. Although I love the milk color, I will not waste my money on even one more of these and will be looking for a similar product in a different brand.
Reviewed by 4259 customers Eye pencil
Sherry from Williamsburg VA
It's a pretty color but it creases a lot on the eyes
Nikki9123 from Texas
I LOVE these eye pencils. I've been using them for close to 5 years now and so have my mom and sister. My sister gave a couple to me a few Christmases ago and the rest is history. They go on so easily and the color/pigment is beautiful. The price is beautiful too, of course! I have tried cashmere, lavender, pure gold, milk, strawberry milk, purple velvet, cobalt and many more over the years and have yet to be disappointed by a single color. I have read that they work great as eyeliners and highlighters but I have only used as eyeshadow. Don't know why it never occurred to me to try as a liner or highlighter all this time but I'll definitely be giving it a try now! If you're on the fence about trying these- don't be! They CAN sharpen and they can last a long time if you put a little space between uses. And even if they run out, you can't beat the price, it won't cost an arm and a leg every time you need a replacement.
ALevine from WA
Perfect for a little touch of highlight on the inner corner of my eyelids. Not a fan of the color name 'Cottage Cheese'.
Formula doesn't set
Ashley from Collierville, TN
I bought iced mocha to use as a cream eyeshadow. Pros- good pigment and a pretty color that applied easily. Cons- the formula never sets so two hours into wearing it had faded and creased even though I have dry eyelids and used the Urban Decay Primer potion on my lids. And so the hunt for a cream shadow stick that's cheaper than Laura Mercier or Bobbi Brown continues!
Jax from Los Angeles
I've been using the jumbo pencils in milk and black bean for a long time now, they still work great.
Grace from NC
I absolutely love this! I am a woc and most eyeshadows aren't pigmented enough to give me the pop that I want. This is an easy fix. The only downside is that after awhile you can see where it separates, but I do have oily eyelids so that could just be me lol
I love it
Shoffy from Florida
I buy this and I love it easy to apply is perfect pigment
Smooth and cheap
Casey from Lewes, DE
Great price and the product is great! It was a win/win for me! So I got 3 of them. I mean really they have great pigment and the price is so good !! I will get them in more colors very soon because again, you can not beat the price!
Nyx Jumbo Eye Pencil is a fantastic find!
Carlee from CO
Nyx provides a professional product with great colors at a price making it possible to buy all of them! This Jumbo Eye Pencil can be a base, a liner or a highlighter. I have blue/green eyes and have purchased two colors so far, Purple Velvet (Rockies fans...this is a must!) and Cashmere (a gold). I use both as a liner, the Cashmere going from the middle of my eyes to the inside on both the upper and lower iid. Wow! Does this open my eyes up!
Sharpeners. They exist.
missage from mi
I absolutely love iced mocha, makes a beautiful base for eyeshadow and I use it on my lower lash line (not my waterline) to make my eyes brighter and it works great! I read so many reviews, where people are complaining about it being a waste of money, and there's so little product, saying the packaging is flawed and won't twist up.........They. Sharpen. Like-
Rain on me from Queens
I tried to do that lil eye thingy from Ariana Grande x Lady Gaga's Rain on me video LOL. This is not that
Mabel from Cleveland OH
Way to greasy and gets in creases.
White eye pencil
Olivia from South Carolina
The white has full pigment. Very creamy and applies very smooth. Definitely recommend
Great for eyeliner
rpauley8892 from Denver, CO
I purchased the Rust color after having owned and used two other colors. This is a really nice color to use as eyeliner, as it stays in place. I have also used it as eyeshadow, which looks nice, but it's not the easiest to blend. My main qualm is that there is so little product in there, but the actual product works really well.
Love This Colour!
Attila the Shopper from Erlanger, Kentucky
This purple is a gorgeous colour! But, these don't sharpen, and they don't twist up ; that's what I mean by they don't last long. I'm removing one star due to that. They are still a fun, inexpensive, eye crayon. They have awesome pigment, too. I use these as an eye shadow and eye liner.
A Fun Cobalt Blue Crayon!
Attila the Shopper from Erlanger, Kentucky
These are fun crayons, they come in a variety of colours, there easy to use and blend, but you can't sharpen them ,and there's not a ton of product in the pen. If you use this every day, it should last you about a month. Still fun to use, though. Just keep these things in mind.
chiko from new castle
This creamy eye liner pencil glides on effortlessly no pulling, tugging or fading. Apply it as an eyeshadow, highlighter,
Rach1029 from Ca
I got this in the rust color and it is beautiful!! Shimmery and rich color. Great for smudging under eyes and as a upper lash liner. I paired it with a gold liner on my waterline and it really made my brown eyes pop. Definitely a universally flattering shade for all eyes colors!! Goes on smooth and creamy, does not skip or tag. I've come back to look for another fun shade to try, and can't beat that price!!!
Wendy from VA -- Virginia
Smears and crumbles off under eyes throughout the day. Wouldn't buy again.
Nani from California
It's only okay. I wanted to use it for my waterline but it was kinda ugly.. didn't last long either. the subtle sparkle was cute but it really let me down :/ literal cottage cheese..
Inexpensive, fun colors
Heather O. from New Jersey
I love these eye pencils! I have been looking for this color all over, and didn't want to spend the $ on urban decay. These come in fun colors, and last nicely. They are versatile and easy to sharpen. The plastic is soft, and I haven't had any issues. Great price for a great product!
Bri from Dallas tx
Love the thickness of this pencil.
Been using for years!
GBJess from Green Bay, WI
I absolutely love this bigger eye pencil in the cottage cheese color. I have literally been using it for 6-7 years. It works so perfect for lining the inner corners of my eyes to make them pop! It is shimmery but also works as a great base in the inner corners if I want to apply a different shimmer eye shadow on top to match my look better. Otherwise this is my go to for a fresh face if I am wearing minimal makeup to help my eyes pop!
Nice water line liner!
Shelby beauty from Boston
I use this on my water line and it makes my eyes pop! Go easy though because it is super pigmented. One very light stroke on your water line and it's perfect.
Shelb from Utica, Michigan
I absolutely love these pencils, I have it in black and white as well. I use them to blend out my eyeliner for a smokey look. The white I use for a cut crease.