Product Reviews Rated 4.17 out of 5 stars
4653 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I'm here to save the day These pencils are amazing, but I have found that the best way to use them is to pot them and apply with a brush. I found that after a while the product gets low and because they can only be sharpened so much, you tend to lose a lot of product. About a min in the microwave liquidfies it. After it cools it is just as creamy as it was in the tube and you have an entire 5mg jar full of product to use!
Most Helpful Critical Review I like this pencil for... I like this pencil for the product. I have the color "Milk" and I love it as a highlight on my browbone and in the corners of my eyes. I am VERY fair and this pencil is so white I need to use a light hand.
It's also very creamy which can be good and bad - the good being that it glides onto your skin, the not so good being that it's so creamy I wouldn't recommend wearing these on the eyelid without a primer underneath if you have oily lids because it's so soft and creamy that it does crease.
Now the WORST thing: the packaging. I hate that there's plastic just under the actual product so that you can't sharpen the pencil! Some of these reviews are saying that there IS product in the shaft but why put it there unless you can get to it? NOT impressed with that at all.
So, product, good. Packaging, bad.
Reviewed by 4653 customers Absolute smudged garbage. 1
Maya from Pennsylvania
Primer, setting spray, setting powder, doesn't matter because it doesn't last more than 2 minutes before becoming a smudged, creased MESS. it's everywhere and looks horrific. GARBAGE. DONT BUY. this is the ONLY eyeliner I've ever had do this.
Perfect! 5
Sage from West Virginia
Very pigmented and so cute!
Eyeshadow Eyeliner Pencil 3
Suze from NJ
These are great but the lid always cracks and they are VERY hard to sharpen. For those reasons I'd recommend buying another brand.
Eyeshadow Eyeliner Pencil 3
Suze from NJ
These are great but the lid always cracks and they are VERY hard to sharpen. For those reasons I'd recommend buying another brand.
If I could give it 0 stars I would 1
Jess from LA
I bought two jumbo pencils, after prepping my skin within two hours the color horribly crease in my eyelids and was smudged in my lower lash line. Definitely not worth the hype.
If I could give it 0 stars I would 1
Jess from LA
I bought two jumbo pencils, after prepping my skin within two hours the color horribly crease in my eyelids and was smudged in my lower lash line. Definitely not worth the hype.
Super blendable 5
Cc from Beaufort, SC
I really like this product. I put this on the whole eyelid and even blend it into the crease with a brush. It stays slightly tacky and eyeshadows stick on top very well. The pigmentation is nice as well. My only complaint is that the top is super cheap and cracks easily if you push it on too hard.
Very creamy!!! 5
Pao from Nyc
I love using these for my waterline because it's very creamy! Love the formula !!
Very blendable 5
Kimberly from San Diego
Really nice eyeshadow! It was so smooth and easy to put on.
nice color, but does not stay 3
Lex from Palm Beach, FL
I love the color and it looks great on my eyes, but it is not the kind that will dry on and last all day. even with primers it will end up mixing with my eyeliner.
Yes I would buy again 4
Kimmy from Surprise Arizona
Be very gentle when putting in, first time I went to use it broke
This was exactly what I was looking for! 5
Ulta User from California
Exactly what I was looking for
Please Sharpen Gently! 4
Richelle from Sugar Land
I have been reading a lot of comments here about people thinking this has little product. You need a jumbo sharpener! When sharpening, you need to be careful to not sharpen it too much or it will break. But if it does, take the product onto a pallet or a pot. This way you can use a brush to apply it and not waste your $$.
a real miss 2
EBeth from KC
I got this to compare to the primer and while neither one worked for me, this was worse. clumpy, lumpy, thick, wouldn't blend.
Very Convenient 4
Kennedy from Ohio
I got shade champagne because I saw it on tiktok
It has a great formula that goes on easy nice as a highlighter and glimmer shadow
To much for to little 1
S.L from Silverdale, WA
You pay what you pay for this tiny amount of product. I was expecting you could twist it up and you can't. It's easy to use, but a total rip off. Give a girl some more NYX.
Okay for convenience 3
Aly from Amarillo texas
I use just to brighten my eyes. It does crease and comes off easily. I love the pigment and brightness effect. Also very convenient if your on the go all the time.
I would buy this product again 5
Heartlady from San Jose, CA
I wanted a change from using powder eye shadows and this seems to be the answer.
Staple 5
Kenzie from Laurel Maryland
Did you grow up in the early 2000's? If so you had these in your collection. As a 26 year old I STILL own these and always will. Great liners for so many different uses. Liners, shadow bases, highlight, whatever it may be, MILK is there to take your look to a whole new level.
MILK 5
Kelly from Maryland
This works amazing as an inner corner highlight!!!
ALL - IN - ONE 5
Kelly from Maryland
I use this on my eyes but recently I found out it makes an amazing contour stick! I use a flat rope brush to blend it in and it works amazing! I am a cool toned fair skin tone and this is amazing for me
I like it 4
CC from UnicornLand
Easy to use.
🤯🤯🤯 5
JessHopefull from Chicago
I love a great creamy black eyeliner and this NYX JUMBO Stick is just what I wanted! The fact that this eyeliner is actually sharpenable is mind blowing. That made me like the product even more... it's pretty cool.
Cheaply made 1
Cheyenne from Michigan
This broke almost immediately- I will not be buying this again.
Essential 5
prextel from az
Glides onto my waterline easily and it's pretty pigmented too. Great for that dolly eye effect.😳
