Rated 4.12 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Perfect Blend Cobalt Blue
It's hard to understand why this color was discontinued. There are hundreds, if not thousands of blacks, browns, charcoals and combinations thereof available. Blue eyeliner is tricky at best, and can easily mess up an otherwise nicely made up face. The other blues on the market, whether pencil (you sharpen), retractable pencil, liquid etc., most of which I've tried, simply miss the mark! Either by the color being very harsh, shiny and/or totally unnatural. The claims of lasting all day and staying put are false. This pencil, which allows for a very fine point if wanted, is invaluable. It does not run or smudge, even if one tends to have oily eyelids. This all speaks to why CG perfect blend pencil is exceptional, even compared to much more expensive eyeliners. However, above all else, Cobalt Blue and the color it lays down sets it above all else on the market for anyone wanting a blue eyeliner that looks appropriate. A lot of women who use other colors of eyeliners would be well served to try cobalt, to accentuate their eyes without looking harsh and unnatural. Please bring this color back.
Most Helpful Critical Review not so good
this eyeliner worked great until i had to sharpen it. when i tried to, it cracked right down the middle!!!
Reviewed by 608 customers Best eyeliner
Lucy10 from Chicago
I would give this a 5 but they discontinued cobalt blue. When I wear it I get SOOOO many compliments. They don't offer any color anymore and black and brown is boring.
the best color for my eyebrows
kl163 from winona mn
I absolutely love the color because I have grey hair, and the pencil goes on lightly and is so natural....but the sharpners they tried to sell me are breaking down the pencil!!!!
perfect eyeliner from undisclosed
ive used this for years. something is different lately. no longer smooth.
Please Bring Back Blue!
Missing Cobalt Blue from undisclosed
As a blue-eyed blonde, I have worn cobalt blue since I started wearing makeup 2 decades ago. I can only use pencil eyeliner due to an eye allergy to liquid eyeliner. Please please bring back cobalt blue!!!
Banks from Minnesota
I'm disappointed to see you discontinued the shade very black. Basic black is nothing like very black. Ugh.
BRING BACK THE MINK PLEASE!!!
jljl from Wisconsin
I've been using the Mink color for years and can't find anything comparable. Please bring it back! Us brown-eyed blondes miss it!!!
LET IT ROLL...................................
Seattles Tracey from Seattle Wash
I bought the PERFECT BLEND pencil..glad I did....The Charcoal is a softer look. It lasts and does not go on like a regular pencil, it has a softer buttery feel and a rich color. Comes in 4 colors.It is not hard to find,in all the retail stores, the only problem I have its down to the wire when I get there..maybe only 1 left..Started to buy 2 at a time..The sharpening pencil has 2 sizes on 1 pencil sharpener and does not take off half the pencil...nice and sharp and lasts.....
Bring back the blue!
Missing Blue from Missouri
Please bring back the blue - cannot find a comparable color in CoverGirl or other brands.
perfect blend eyeliner blue
Kelly Luoma from Sand Coulee, MT 59472
I really really miss the blue I have used it for years, please bringit bacl
Peni from Ocala, FL
Can this eyeliner also be used as a brow filler? I am having trouble finding a color for gray hair. Black is too harsh and brown doesn't match.. I am going to try the charcoal.
Not The Same Eyeliner
Gina56 from Tn
I have used this same Eyeliner for years. I've noticed after my last 3 purchases, it does go on the same. It pulls my eyelids, and you can forget keeping coverage on the bottom. What have you all done? I thought it would soften up after a few try's but that is not happening. Go back to your original formula please. You cannot fool a consumer.
Smoky Taupe Very Dry
samiam2020 from Dallas, TX
I bought this pencil because I wanted a more natural look for some days and not a heavy kohl look. Unfortunately, I can't get any color to line my lashes. I tried to moisten it with a little water, didn't help. I tried sharpening it, didn't help either. Can't recommend.
reliable! Pulls your eyes!
Woog from Sedalia, Mo.
Way to dry, hard to put on. You have to keep going over it about 20 times for it to finally see the line. I've bought 2 of these, never again. Totally waste of money! It pulls your eyes to hard trying to get it on. I don't recomend.
This eyeliner is so easy to apply.
Patty57 from Wisconsin
I'm just so sad they no longer carry Cobalt Blue!!! WHY???
If you are looking for...
cmhallmark from undisclosed
If you are looking for a nice, dark liner that smudges really well, this is a great liner for you! The color was perfect, application was easy and the sponge on the end to help smudge the liner when needed does the job. However, if you aren't looking for a smudged look, I wouldn't choose this liner. It will spread if touched. Overall though, not a bad product.
Smoky Taupe = Necessity!
Carla_N from Dallas TX
Taupe is a difficult shade to find in an eyeliner, and I'm not sure I could live without Smoky Taupe!
I'm brunette, NW15, green eyes, and Smoky Taupe is my go-to soft neutral liner for lower lids.Smoky Taupe is, true to its name, a soft light-medium greyish brown with the slightest hints of a yellow undertone in strong light - just enough to render it "neutral."
It works for my brows, too.
This liner is nicely pigmented, with only the tiniest suggestion of dryness, which isn't a problem on my very oily skin. Smoky Taupe goes on smoothly and wears well. It defines without looking harsh, which is ideal for those of us who are pale-skinned and over 50. I hope this is NEVER discontinued!
I love this pencil...
hortensiac1 from undisclosed
I love this pencil very easy to apply it is creamy easy to blend when I do my smoky eye very effective
Love the way it goes...
member3c6681 from undisclosed
Love the way it goes on and stays on. Smooth and not hard on my eyes..but yet lasting and beautiful.
It comes together with any kind of makeup.
xiomyb from undisclosed
Covergirl definitivamente es una de mis marcas favoritas y este producto no se queda atrs en cuestin de calidad
im not someone to wear...
seeleenaa_ from undisclosed
im not someone to wear eyeliner on a day to day basis, but i do make up looks and I need something to put on my face this is my go to ! its a bit hard to use , but if you heat it up a little bit its good to go
covergirl has the best...
shanacatherine from undisclosed
covergirl has the best eyeliners for drugstore! I have one in black and one in brown and use them daily! it's so pigmented on the water line and doesnt just rub off! it lasts for hours! I even tried to do a wing with the black shade and it glided on so smoothly! I would definitely recommend if your look to save some money but want something that's decent.
i really recommend it...
hanayoussrysaleh from undisclosed
i really recommend it it makes your skin glow and not oily at all . it moisturizes your face and makes you feel really great !
Im a sucker for a...
sydneyr20 from undisclosed
Im a sucker for a natural look and a blended brown liner can be the perfect compliment to it. I have tried many before, and this one didnt hold up for more than a month before completely drying out. I liked it at first but there are many better options out there. Try the LOral liners! They are 16hr wear and super creamy which makes application easier.
This eyeliner is a...
karis0614 from undisclosed
This eyeliner is a really good. I use the brown eyeliner because its the only one I could find but its really really good at what it has to do.
Perfect eyeliner for...
nanda81 from undisclosed
Perfect eyeliner for everyday use. Gets the job done and its super easy to blend if needed. Applies very easily.