Product Reviews Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
2063 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I wish the product... I wish the product didn't dry out so fast, but that's the only downfall. At first, you feel like it's going to last you a long time, then you find yourself with little to no mascara within two or three weeks because there's not enough product or it dried out on its own. Other than that, I love how black the mascara is and the wand. Makes your lashes look fuller.
Most Helpful Critical Review Pitiful product This has to be the worst Maybelline product I have ever bought. Usually I love all Maybelline but this is a huge disappointment. It is easy to apply and looks good on HOWEVER trying to get it off is another matter. Here are the steps I must take to get Colossal Volume mascarra off: Wash face - look like raccoon! Use make-up remover - have black flacks all over face. Use make-up remover again - most flakes gone. Switch to another make-up remover - still some residue. Use second remover a second time - mostly gone. For the next hour or so - put up with flakes falling into eyes. Good Grief! Never again.
Reviewed by 2063 customers Flake City 3
Hays from Miami, FL
I love this mascara, the wand is perfect and gives me the separation that I love while building up length and volume. However, every time I wear this it flakes so bad. I'm so disappointed because otherwise I would repurchase.
Fine 3
Eamb from Long Island NY
It works okay. My lashes looked better than Norma but constantly stick together when I use this. You get what you pay for o guess? Would not recommend for a 16 hour wear.
Formula changed :( 2
Ny from Illinois
I've used this mascara my whole life and it doesn't keep the curl anymore. I have to apply a VERY thin layer then wait for it to dry and apply more for a curl to kind of stay. It was never like that before, please bring back the old formula!!
Good lift. 3
EPH from Los Angeles, C.A.
I apply it on my lashes and a couple coats it's length is good. If I decide to apply a few more coats it ends up clumping and makes them a little stiff.
I would buy this product again. 5
AZ Grandma from Arizona
My eye lashes are thinning and the length and volume really helps
Great product for great price 5
Girl with the curld from Bakersfield, Ca
Love this mascara doesn't smudge nice brush
I LOVE this product 5
Janay from Georgia
This has been a product I have used since it came out I switch up which mascara I use but this has always been in my top 3. It makes my lashes look so full without falsies
Works great, smells horrible. 4
Me from Howell Mill
If smells don't bother you this stuff works great!
My favorite 5
Amandalynn from Missouri
I love this mascara, I use the glam brown one and it brings out my hazel eyes. Love it!
Great product 5
Arlean from San Antonio TX
Easy to apply
Best of both worlds 5
Pink from America
I use this on top of my Lancôme lash primer and it gives me the perfect amount of volume and length while separating my lashes perfectly. I highly recommend and you can't beat the price. It doesn't smudge on me either
Classic 4
Jen from Michigan
For drug store brand it does an amazing job plumping and Elongating the eye lashes. Will have to use a eyelash brush to break up the clumps. But overall makes your eyelashes look fake
Bretman sent me here! 4
Eleni from Lake Elsinore
When I saw bretman rock do a review on this mascara, I was immediately intrigued! He has reviewed this mascara and it brought great length to his lashes. Personally I have very small eyelashes and this product doubles the size haha. I do not recommend going in the pool or any water with this on as it will smudge and make black streaks on your face.
Great mascara 5
Fancyface from Houston
My stable must have mascara. Increases volume on fine lashes well
Go to everyday 5
jk from Oregon
go to mascara. Brush works well, color is good. Does flake after a few months because it drys out quick
I love this mascara 5
Amandalynn from Missouri
This is my favorite mascara, I would choose this over any one out there! I wipe off excess product on the countainer and apply to my lashes. It works so well! And it's buildable to.
This is my go to ONLY MASCARA 5
mam from Webster, TX
I love this mascara!!!!! It is reasonably priced and gives you both volume and length! Try it you will love it.
HOLY GRAIL 5
miss tiktoker from Memphis, TN
THIS MASCARA IS MY HOLY GRAIL!!! I have trieddd sooo many mascaras and a few weeks ago I came across this at target. I picked it up, and man am I so glad I did. It lengthens, darkens, and curls my eyelashes perfectly. And unlike other mascaras it comes off easily without pulling out ur lashes. LOVE AND TOTALLY RECOMMEND
Its ok 4
Ang from Indiana
I think it's nice but it doesnt stay up for long but the product does stay on all day
Buy if you want to look like a panda 1
Office panda from Pittsburgh PA
I applied before work in the morning and it seemed promising. Went on well and looked great! But when I went to the restroom mid-day, it had run so badly, I had huge dark rings under my eyes. So embarrassing bc I'm not sure how long I had been walking around like that. I came home and threw it right in the trash. Never again.
One of my favorite mascaras! 5
Audrey G from Boston, MA
One of my favorite mascaras that I've ever tried! The best thing about it is that it's impossible to clump your lashes together. You can put 10 coats of this stuff on and there's no clumping and no spider lashes. If you want the false lash effect or crazy volume, you might not like this mascara, but if you prefer the more everyday look, you'll love it. I definitely recommend curling your lashes first for the best results and to really get defined and pretty lashes.
Doesn't clump 3
Cc from USA
This mascara is okay. I wish it added a bit more volume and was more dramatic. It's great for people who like a more natural look because it's lightweight and not too dramatic.
Good 4
Carrie from Florida
Goes on well, builds up nicely and doesn't clump. doesn't run if you cry, unless it's a lot of crying . Washes off easily.
My go to 5
AL from IL
I've tried most of Maybelline's mascara and other drugstore brands and ALWAYS come back to this one. It's been my go-to for years and the brush size is perfect for a natural, full look. Other Maybelline formulas tend to cause more of my lashes to fall out than normal for whatever reason but have never experienced that issue with this one.
Absolute Fav of all time! 5
Nina from Visalia, Ca
I seem to find myself always coming back to this one. It's buildable the consistency is more on the watery side so it won't clump lashes together. Def gives length and defines.
