Product Reviews Rated 4.25 out of 5 stars
21465 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review SUPER dissapointed... SO disappointing, I was really excited about all the reviews and hearing from a few people who it worked miracles for... this product did me NO good at all...
So messy to go on.. No matter how little of mascara I left on the wand it looked as if I was a toddler playing with my moms makeup or something... I was previously using perversion & subversion by urban decay and wanted to try something different that would hopefully give me the same results but with less work.... WELL... Im back in my comfort zone using Perversion again because trying this product was a nightmare.... It was taking me 5 minutes or so to get the perfect, dramatic, long and well set lashes with perversion... With this product it took me nearly 15 minutes of touching up and brushing my lashes just to even out the spider webs to get even near presentable lashes....
Long story short this product gets a double thumbs down..
Reviewed by 21465 customers A great product! 5
Amanda from Marietta, GA
Silky and smooth! Easy to remove!
I did not like this product it clumps on your eye lashes 1
Jess from Pa
Didn't like the product at all
Average 3
Not better than sex from SC
It's an average mascara. I have had better drug store brands. Nothing special.
Awesome Mascara 5
Patty from NC
My sister gave me a travel size to try and I absolutely loved it and had to go get one for myself!
Flaky and clumpy 1
Janeane from Pocatello
Not impressed. It's black but clumps instantly then flakes once dried. There are better options for cheaper prices
Someone needs to call the Mascara police 1
R from United States
Just… awful. Mascara is wayyyyy too "wet" it's not humidity resistant, it doesn't last long, and let me tell you: CLUMP ALERT. Goes on clumpy and doesn't define and separate.
Great Mascara 5
Deborah from Dallas, Texas
I have used this product for years. Prior and during, I, like so many of us have tried many other brands, some good, but I always find my way back to this one. I think it's the unique brush that just works for my lashes!
Not great 1
Priscon from California
Transfers to my lid if i add to bottom lashes I get raccoon eyes
Terrible 1
Q kelly from Ct
Mascara is dry and not a lot come out onto lashes worst mascara ever!
great, not perfect 4
Lyz from Milwaukee, WI
I have a personal preference for very "wet" mascaras, and this one is really nice. Jet black, satisfyingly smooth application, great length and volume.... for a few hours. This mascara doesn't really cure hard and will continue to smear in any humidity. This also makes it a challenge to remove. Setting spray or finishing powder is a must. Urban Decay's Perversion is my 5-star version of this mascara.
It's eh 3
C from Indiana
This mascara is a little more on the wet side for my liking and gets very messy, also found that it bring my eyelashes down instead of staying up.
Dry 3
Mkat2017 from Montgomery, AL
I'm glad I bought the travel size to try first because it's dry and just okay for me. Wouldn't purchase again.
I've had better 2
Desiree from Hershey, PA
The coverage is so-so. It's not poor, but it's not great either. I end up having to do multiple coats to get the look I want. Perhaps because of that, it ends up flaking and smudging under my eyes. I would not buy again.
Did they change the formula or something? 2
Ann from Austin, Texas
I'm honestly kind of confused as people rant and rave about this mascara on social media...I'm starting to think they're getting paid to say good things because I'm not impressed by this mascara at all. At $30 it should at least be a little better than drugstore brands but honestly, I don't like it at all. The applicator is a weird shape, making it tough to get my inner corner lashes without getting mascara on my lid. It doesn't go on smooth at all, it feels like I have old mascara residue on my lashes despite them being squeaky clean. Doesn't hold a curl, looks clumpy, doesn't lengthen....I don't get why people like this mascara.
GOAT 5
Rusti from Muldrow ok
I love it this is my favorite mascara when I run out I have to make sure that I have a back up it's just the best I've used it straight for the past three years and going strong
Not my fav 1
Iryna from Cleveland
My lashes started to fallout like crazy after I've been using it for a while, thought it was something else but once I stopped using it and switched to my trusted bare minerals mascara the fallout stopped, maybe I was just allergic to some ingredient in the mascara.
disappointed customer 1
Laura from Cape Coral, Florida
I was disappointed in the performance of this mascara. I have used it before, but this time it did not enhance my eyelashes
Definitely would buy this again 5
Selia from Oakland
This is my daily mascara I use for going to work, socially and running errands. It is quite expensive but I love it.
NOT better than sex 1
Jupiter Kat from Seattle, WA
Worst mascara of all time? Potentially. It is indeed a shame to name the mascara better than sex. Must be terrible, terrible sex that they had in mind when creating this formula. So dry, and flakes on myself and anyone else I know who has used this. Do better Too Faced
Didn't work for me... 2
Selena from Miami,FL
I finally managed to get round to using this two nights back and seeing for myself what the hype was all about (I have 2 friends who tell me this works brilliantly for them). My lashes themselves are long, however I wouldn't mind some volume and definition. Although this went on quite well and just required one coat, it did start to both clump immediately and then flake in a matter of hours. The flaking eventually got so bad that I had to remove it all together. I thought maybe the lash serum I'm using might have interfered in some way, even though it'd been 12 hours since applying it the previous night. However, even after not applying the serum last night, I still had the same problem this morning. As much as I wanted to love this, it just isn't for me! -> My 'Ulta Beauty Top 7 must-have list' (My 7 favorite beauty products of all time, focusing mainly on my purchases at Ulta) < - < 1. Hair Loss Treatment: Divine Herbal Hair Oil < 2. Eye Cream: Clinique All about eyes < 3. Lip Gloss: Clarins Lip Comfort Oil < 4. Makeup Remover: Lancome Bi Facil < 5. Pigmentation + Anti-Aging Serum: Divine Herbal Facial Treatment Serum < 6. Eyeliner: Ulta Beauty Gel Eyeliner Pencil < 7. Moisturizer: 'Lush' – Enzymion
Didn't work for me... 2
Selena from Miami,FL
I finally managed to get round to using this two nights back and seeing for myself what the hype was all about (I have 2 friends who tell me this works brilliantly for them). My lashes themselves are long, however I wouldn't mind some volume and definition. Although this went on quite well and just required one coat, it did start to both clump immediately and then flake in a matter of hours. The flaking eventually got so bad that I had to remove it all together. I thought maybe the lash serum I'm using might have interfered in some way, even though it'd been 12 hours since applying it the previous night. However, even after not applying the serum last night, I still had the same problem this morning. As much as I wanted to love this, it just isn't for me! -> My 'Ulta Beauty Top 7 must-have list' (My 7 favorite beauty products of all time, focusing mainly on my purchases at Ulta) < - < 1. Hair Loss Treatment: Divine Herbal Hair Oil < 2. Eye Cream: Clinique All about eyes < 3. Lip Gloss: Clarins Lip Comfort Oil < 4. Makeup Remover: Lancome Bi Facil < 5. Pigmentation + Anti-Aging Serum: Divine Herbal Facial Treatment Serum < 6. Eyeliner: Ulta Beauty Gel Eyeliner Pencil < 7. Moisturizer: 'Lush' – Enzymion
Would not recommend 1
J from Chicago, IL
Disappointed by this product especially for the price point. It applies well but it doesn't stay. It'll run/smudge after only a few hours. I would rather use my Maybelline Sky High Mascara or L'oreal Telescopic.
Amazing!!! 5
Genni from Florida
Love this mascara! After completing my face makeup this is my go to after ! Completes the look!
Not for a long day 3
Karen from New Mexico
Looks great once you first put it on but wears off by the day's end. Don't even have to touch my eyes and it's displaced under my eyes. There are better mascaras out there for the price.
Barely ok 1
AB from Fort Worth Texas
This one was pricier for a barely ok mascara. I've had much better cheap drugstore mascaras honestly. Is very dry and takes a lot of work to get enough to even look like you have any mascara on. I will not be buying this kind again.