Rated 2.86 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review HG eyeliner
I have been using this eyeliner for about a year now, and I cant say enough good things abot it! Although I will say that it does take some getting used to. It has a very different applicator, and you MUST SHAKE WELL each time before you use it. I have very oily eyelids from time to time but this never smudges, or moves.And I dont even have to buy the watterproof because the regular one already has great staying power! The color is indeed bold and quite matte when I use it which I like. To remove it dont even waste your time trying to scrub it off, all you have to do is wet a q-tip and it will come right off (not sure if that works with the waterproof one or not). Overall this is an amazing product and I will continue to buy it!
Most Helpful Critical Review do not buy
i love using liquid eyeliner and I am pretty good at drawing lines, this product was awful, couldn't draw a good line, it dried out, clumped and came off about an hour after I put it on. I have only returned one make up item before and this was the second time I returned a make up item at ULTA, it was that awful.
Reviewed by 207 customers No I would not buy this again
Aa from Monroeville
I think it's a waste of my money
Sofia 💛 from Htx
I love this product sooo much! It's the only eyeliner I've ever liked. I've been using this for about 5 years now and I still buy it to this day! So easy to use, and comes off by peeling it off , so it doesn't leave ur eyes red from scrubbing it off.
Mommy all the time from Pueblo Colorado
I use this product to put A-line under my eyes. Maybelline is a great part otic because I use another type of eyeliner from them. This is just my opinion this one was a little too harsh for my taste
So easy to use, definitely buying again!
Natalie from Cincinnati, Ohio
I almost never wear make up or eyeliner, and this went on very smooth and easily. I did not have to reapply, the color was very strong.
I would buy this again
Brittany W from Washington, Mo
I used this eyeliner for a dark smokey eye. It look perfect and was very dark.
Will not buy again
DD from GREENVILLE, NC
I do not care for this product. It does not have a small tip brush at the end, rather it is a plastic rounded tip. It makes it difficult to get a even straight line. The sample product I received with my purchase is also Maybelline New York (MASTERPRECISEALLDAY Liquid Liner) and is a much better product. It has a nice pointed tip and applying is so very easy. Also, the application does last throughout the day.
This eyeliner is horrible. I do not recommend it.
Lizz from Vancouver wash
I would not buy this product
none from North Carolina
I have used a lot of eyeliners. This is the worst one. It takes several strokes to show up. Dries cakey and hard to remove.
I would buy this product again.
Alea lover of make up from Dayton, Ohio
I like to use a thin line of eyeliner on my top lid or sometimes I do a cat eye and I always add lashes.
Becca from Ontario, OH
I've been struggling to find an eyeliner that will actually stay on my eyes since my brand stopped making the one I used. This eyeliner was horrible and not worth the money I paid. I put it on and it didn't even last an hour. Pencil never works on me and I was disappointed that this liquid eyeliner was a let down.
Worst eyeliner ever
Ash from California
Worst eye liner ever. Like using a stick instead of a brush. Horrible and will never buy again. When putting on it gets on lash line and causes all your lashes to stick like glue. Also when removing it comes off like a gooey sticker.
New product try out
Justjax from Las Vegas
This looked strange when I bought it, but thought I'd give it a try. It clumps up & is difficult to control since any movement changes line from thick to thin.
I like it
Jcl from Nj
I want an eyeliner that lasts all day. I have tried Urban Decay, Smashbox and Lancôme . They don't last. Hard to believe that Maybelline and Revlon Do last-at 1/2 the cost.
I will be devastated if this is ever discontinued!
Fly Girl from Baltimore, MD
I use it every day! I'm a flight attendant and this stuff lasts all day Love this eyeliner. Perfect for a night out or casual day makeup.
I would buy this product again
Roz from Centreville, Md.
I have used this product for years . Love it! Best eye liner on the market.
I would not buy it again.
G from Point Loma
I used the eyeliner on both upper and lower lash lines. The product tugged my skin all night and I just wanted to wash it off immediately. It felt clumpy and thick.
Best eyeliner ever
Michelle from New York
I've used this eyeliner for years!! Nothing beats it
I don't really like the tip of the eyeliner
Ego from Houston, Tx
I used it once but it was too thick
Awsome eye liner
Triell from Rancho Cordova ca
It works well.
If this ever got discontinued I don't think I could survive!
Ash the Flight Attendant from Baltimore, MD
I'm a flight attendant and I need a good everyday eyeliner that will last all day and not smudge. This is my perfect solution. I'm not kidding when I say if this got discontinued I don't think I could survive. It's inexpensive, lasts all day, and has the perfect brush for me.
Kathy from Illiniois
Easily use love that
Not my favorite
Maddy Makeup from Temecula,CA
It dries quickly but a little too quick. I have to go over it at least once but since it dries quickly it peels off where I go over.
Complete waste of money!!!!
DW from Chicago, IL
I used this product to create a fabulous wing but the liner just isn't thick enough!
Yov from Denver
It's very funny and feels like I'm applying nail polish to my eye. There was even a weird white substance on the bottle...
I would definitely buy this product again!
Bethie from Gratiot, WI
I love this eyeliner! The brush makes it easy to create a thin or a thick line. The color is excellent and isn't runny. Last all day, too!