Product Reviews Rated 4.22 out of 5 stars
3364 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing!! I was looking for a long wear matte lip cream and was directed to this. The salesgirl was super helpful and told me that Patina was a shop favorite so I tried it and loved the color right away! Patina is a great neutral color, like a dusky rose. Anyway, I wore it today to my family's early Thanksgiving dinner and it lasted all day!! I drank water and beer & ate a full turkey dinner. I am truely amazed by this lip cream. It isn't drying at all and it's been on for 8 hours! I will definitely be trying other colors!
Most Helpful Critical Review Zero stars was not an option; HATED this item! We purchased this item to use for competitive cheer after explaining we needed a red matte color that would stay in place during long days of cheer competitions because the sales clerk said that it would stay in place and "won't come off without a good makeup remover." A few teammates purchased it for the same reasons. This did not end up being the case for us. It smeared all over faces, clothes and anything that even brushed across their lips. It DID however require a lot to get the color the smearing caused off. It wouldn't let me give zero stars, so 1 star it is.
Reviewed by 3364 customers They have changed the color Patina 3
Momzy from St. Louis
I was so confused when I started noticing my favorite lipstick color (Patina) I have been purchasing for years started looking terrible on me. Very purple! I then compared an old one and a new one…totally different colors. Bring back the original!!
Patina is no longer the same 3
Marta from Los Angeles
I agree with another reviewer that said the colors have changed. I'm glad someone else confirmed this- I thought I was going mad because I hadn't heard anyone say this ! I miss the old patina. The newest one is darker and more purple in tone. I can't speak to any of the other shades, but I'm very disappointed because Patina was my favorite color.
Color not as quite described 3
Erinmarie from Northern IL
I just bought this in the shade Firenze today. It's described on the site as mauve pink. It is not. I barely put any on and it it's a very opaque pinkish brown. It's a very deep color and not what I was expecting.
Literally stays on all day! Doesn't get caked up! 10 stars 5
Andrea Cash from Augusta ga
Will be buying this in every color available. Stays on all day. Literally…. Doesn't flake off
Fair 3
Enexx001 from St Paul, MN
DeVita is not "shimmering" of any kind.
Colors Changed Under Same Name 1
Kait from ATL
I'm not quite sure why they don't make this public knowledge- they changed the colors under the same color names. I tried my new Patina and compared it to my old Patina as well as doing the same thing for my favorite color Perla. The colors are completely different than they have always been and it is for the worse. The product formal feels the same but the colors have definitely changed which is frustrating when you expect the same thing for your money and it is far from different. Not liking the new colors and wish I could find the old colors.
SHADES ARE NOT CORRECT 1
Nunyabusiness from Margaritaville
The shade Baci is not a nude pink. It's purple. So disappointing…
Colors are terrible 1
KC from Madison, WI
I really wanted to like this product, it seems to wear well. But I've bought two different colors and they are both terrible. If you're going to buy this I recommend looking at colors in the store.
Love these lipsticks 5
Jbean from Minnesota
I bought this one for my mother-in-law for Mother's Day shhhh. I have bought a few for myself and use Patina Shimmer the most. It stays on most of the day as long as you wait to eat/drink for awhile (20 min ish) after you apply it. Very flattering colors also.
I would buy this again.. 5
Gina from Albuquerque nm
I love the way lipstick feel. Does not dry my lips. Wish there was more colors.
Was excited to find a dupe for my fav BH cosmetics lipstick. 3
Cait from Ohio
This formula is very light weight and long lasting. Basically identical to Jaclyn cosmetics liquid lipsticks. That being said, the shades are WAY off.I got the shades Perla and Baci. Baci is a very purple shade and quite dark. And perla is also much darker than it shows as well. I have been trying to find a dupe for my discontinued BH cosmetics liquid lip for years and I thought forsure one of them would be a perfect match but they're pretty dark. I would def recommend swatching in stores first if you're able to.
no 1
n/a from n/a
I would not buy this color again!!
best long-wearing liquid lipstick ever 5
kim from Gibraltar Michigan
I've been wearing tarte mat lipstick for a long time. They stopped supplying my color and I switched to this brand. It outperforms tarte by far. It is also a lot less drying to the lips. It also lacks in my lip liner perfectly! Honestly worth every penny.
Shade (Baci) 1
Baci from NH
Sooo disappointing! I thought it was gonna be a nude pink as described in the description. But it looked more like grey-purplish. Not what I had expected at all.
She's perfect, no notes 5
Kennedy from Texas
They aren't playing when they say stay ALL DAY!! I put in on in the morning and make it through the whole day without having to reapply!! Plus this one doesn't dry my lips out like a lot of other liquid lipsticks tend to. I got one as a gift and need to buy these in every shade now!!
I won't buy again 2
Lex from Satx
The color wasn't what it looked like. It was too purple
Sad 2
Amal from Atl, Ga
I've been west baci for years and recently I noticed the formula must have changed right??? It does not stay on long AT ALL. 😥
Stuka lipstick 5
Kimi from St. Paul mn
I only buy this brand! It stays put.
Doesn't stay at all and is super cakey. 1
McKayla from Ohio
This product is marketed as a stay-all-day type of lipgloss and it is probably one of the worst I've tried. It's super cakey even if you properly prep your lips. If it had at least stayed on a small amount of time I could've given it 2 stars even but it wiped off immediately.
Love Stila. 5
Cookie from Augusta, Georgia
Stays on all day. Even through meals.
Darker than expected and drying 2
RacecarMama28 from Orlando, FL
I liked the staying power of the lipstick so I got a few colors. They are all much darker than the bottle and my lips look like the Sahara Desert. These are going in the garbage.
WAY TOO PURPLE!! 1
Dani from Lake Havasu City
Sending back has too much purple in it.
New Stila Lip stay all day 2
SherFair from Gilbert Az
I was told it wouldn't be as drying as it is. Color is good but doesn't stay on all day and way to dry.
BRING BACK THE OLD BACI 2
Dez from California
I have purchased Baci before plenty of times. It WAS a pretty cool tone nude pink. Now it is literally a grayish PURPLE....I don't understand why they would change the color. Formula is great but I miss old Baci 😭
Love Caramello 5
BY714 from Los Angeles, CA
The BEST liquid lipstick. Caramello is my go to everyday perfect nude shade. Great staying power while being comfortable. the only liquid lipstick I will repurchase forever!
