Rated 4.27 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review White eyeliner? What was I thinking....
So I read this cosmetic blog from Pinterest that talked all about how white eyeliner was the newest most fantastic thing to ever grace the world of makeup. So I hope in my car and decide to get me some of that. First, and only, application was an epic fail. But that was on me, and not the actual product. The eyeliner was like silk going on and was very smooth. I went back and got black. My white can rot away with that contouring kit that I eye every morning like a venomous snake on my vanity.
Most Helpful Critical Review Long lasting but difficult to apply
This is not my favorite liner but I still keep it in my makeup bag because it is long lasting and doesn't fade after wearing it all day. It is not creamy enough to easily apply to the top lid and the pigment isn't strong enough to stay on the waterline. Personally I like to use the Nyx matte liquid liner on my top lid and then I put it on the outer corner of my lower lashes and smudge it out. I think this liner works pretty well for a good smokey eye. I would say that this product is a good addition to your makeup collection but you might want to look elsewhere if you are just looking for a more versatile liner.
Reviewed by 2029 customers Used for lower lid
Chelsea D from OK
I use this on my lower lid, but not on my waterline. I used Almay in the past, and I may go back. This just does not glide on easily or smoothly. I gave it 3 stars because the pigment is great.
Perfect for what I was wanting
Kristi from Springfield, Missouri
I got the white color eyeliner it's perfect for using on the lower lash line to help hide some of the redness from the rim of the eye not super pigmented so doesn't stand out a lot but it covers all the redness
I love these retractable eyeliner.
Shirley from Dekalb IL
I have NO complaints about the NYC eyeliner.
Lois from Michigan
Glides right on love it . i will buy again
Lois from Michigan
Goes on great love the color
Creamy but a little too soft
Angela from Michigan
I bought the shade Golden Olive and it's really pretty. It's definitely a true olive green with some gold shimmer. I really like it. It's very creamy and doesn't tug on my skin, but it's a liiiittle on the soft side. Kind of hard to do a sharp wing.
Great cruelty-free product!
Hummingbird44 from Lakewood, CO
I have always liked these eyeliners, as they are waterproof (my eyes water a lot), cruelty-free, & provide good color. I have both gray & bronze colors, as my eyes are brown, & I really like the retractable pencil. I use it under my eyes to accent & define, & sometimes on my upper lid.
Color does not stay in place
Cat from Sacramento, CA
Maybe it is because I have oily skin but the color ran to the bottom of my bottom lashes. I looked like a blue racoon.
Go to eyeliner!
Juli from illinois
This eyeliner is my go to on an every day basis! I've tried many eyeliners but I always come back to this one.
Rchapp02 from Rogers, AR
This was stayed on for about 10 minutes before it started to smudge. Will stick with my liquid liner for sure.
Looks great the first time!
Christine from Syracuse, NY
Color was vivid from the very beginning. Didn't have to go over lines a second time because the color was solid the first time. Stays where I put it too! Love it!
Yes will buy again
Sandy from Arkansas
Great eyeliner reasonable price waterproof a big plus...
Cheap and Does the job right!
Rebekah from Edmond, OK
I use the product to line my eyes and create a winged look. I would be careful about wearing it out at work if you get sweaty because it will smear pretty easily, especially along the creases of your eyes. Otherwise, its great.
Exactly as Expected!
Maddie from Detroit, Michigan
I just needed a brown liner so I could have a more softened look instead of my usual consistent hard black wings. The formula is exactly what i wanted, soft, moveable and pigmented. The only thing I would say about it is that its such a blunt edge that you cant really draw a wing but I knew this already when i bought it. I use a thin brow brush to graze along the tip and make a wing if i want a wing. For the price, its a great product.
Young from Richmond TX
I was able to use this pretty well. My only complaint is that the luner sometimes breaks off....that is a waste of liner.
Young from Richmond TX
This stuff smeared so much and would break off. I bought it for my bottom lid to make my eyes look wider. It smears everywhere. Sigh.
Jangee from Texas
the worst eyeliner ever. even cheap brands make better liner than this.
this liner doesn't even write. you have to go over & over the samr spot to even get color & it fades. for the price I expected more. I learned, don't judge by pricing.
I would buy this again
Abbey from Florida
I normally prefer liquid eyeliner rather than a retractable pen, but I wanted to change things up a little for my everyday look and I really like this eyeliner. It goes on nicely and I don't need to reapply it. ( I do use an eyelid primer first ) For the price, this is a really great product! I will be repurchasing.
Lupita from San Benito
I used this as eyeliner it does not stay and you have to outline a lot for it to show
Nicc418 from North Carolina
NYX delivers again! Fully recommend for waterline!
I would buy this again.
Jeanette from Odenton MD
Goes on smooth like the retractable liner.
Not the best, but still good
Mila from Aliso Viejo, CA
When I started to take my eyeliner off, it did not come off for the longest time. I read the eyeliner packaging, and it said it was waterproof. It was not advertised as waterproof at Ulta.
Stacy from MN
I currently have the bronze color and it goes on smoothly. The color payoff is great and it has a subtle shimmer to it, which was surprising since I wasn't expecting it but it's very pretty.
Love this product
Mandi from Rockford, IL
I am obsessed with this eyeliner. The formula is creamy & works immediately. It glides well over the eye & has no tugging or pulling for $5 I was skeptical about it, but it amazed me instantly. I would buy this again & again
Love this eyeliner
Sarah from Baltimore, MD
I can't believe for the price how great this eyeliner is!! It goes on so smooth and doesn't smudge!!