Rated 3.87 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Good buy
Really great eyeliner, glad that I picked this up. Doesn't smudge and it's pretty long lasting, yet it's easy to remove with make up remover. The thin tip is great, and as a beginner, it's really easy to use this product. Would definitely buy this again!
Most Helpful Critical Review Favourite eyeliner no more
I've been buying this eyeliner for probably around 8 years and it has never disappointed. Today however, I went to replace my current Master Precise as it was finally running/drying out, and I was SO disappointed. I obviously jinxed it when I told my mum this was the only product I have consistently bought again and again.
The formula and actual tip of the pen have obviously changed, as it used to be a felt type tip and it is now a smaller more flexible and slippery tip. AND its absolutely terrible, my old Master Precise actually still worked better than this new formula, it was way blacker and crispier than the charcoal-grey, streaky newcomer, even if it says "Blackest Black" on the packaging. I will NEVER understand why companies change their formulas/packaging when it was perfectly fine to begin with.
Reviewed by 1430 customers takes months to dry out. my holy grail
nicole from maine
this takes FOREVER to dry out. it lasts me so long. it is so easy to get a black winged linger with this. it is not a matte finish. it is more shiny/satin.
Love this liner
tara from NY
I've been using different expensive liners like Kat Von Dee out there that charge upwards of $20 per eyeliner for years. This is my first time using this and it's already the best one I've had. Glides on smooth, creates straight, thin lines which makes it easy to get the exact wing shape you want, and it stays on ALL DAY. No smudging, even with and oily face.
One of the best
Hannah from Rancho Cucamonga Ca
I've been using this eyeliner for about 5+ years now. It's one of my favorites
I've used this eyeliner for years
Alli from sacramento, ca
LOVE LOVE this product. I've been using this product for maybe 5 years now. It's easy to use and makes the perfect wing. Stays on till bedtime and affordable. I would recommend this liner to everyone. TIP: shake before use
Chey from Portland, Oregon
Girl, you need this. I feel like it's a dupe for the KVD. It's black, the pen doesn't run dry for months, and the line is sharp!
Super dry tip
Anavi from Orlando, Florida
Don't recommend at all. The tip is so dry you can't get precise placement, despite the thin tip. The color is alright, but you have to go over the area multiple times to get it to show. For the price of this, you could probably find a better one out there.
First time using... I am sold!!
Curlymom8 from Silver Spring, MD
First time trying this eyeliner. Ordered my mistake but I am glad with it. Mine is not dry at all and stays put the average time. I have been using the Roller Liner from Benefit and it works fine - the best one I have ever used- it doesn't stay 'til next morning but that is ok. I prefer felt tip eyeliners vr. brush because I can work perfect lines with them. I will see how long the tip keeps full of ink and I am pretty sure I will buy again. I used the Perversion liquid eyeliner from UD and it didn't work for me. This one is so unexpensive and performs just like the expensive ones. Amazing!!
Liz from Maryland
The tip is too dry and not easy to work with.
ms from Indiana
The first time I used it, it was great. Then anytime after, I couldn't get any color from the very tip. I was sometimes able to get some color from the side, but it came out uneven, or messy. Get something else, this one isnt worth it.
I use it for my brows
Bether from Joliet
The tip is super fine so I use it to feather itty bitty hairs for my brows. The brown is perfect for my dark brows, no weird red undertone.
So far so good
Traci the teacher from Longmont, colorado
I love this eyeliner. I have trouble finding eyeliner that doesn't smudge all over. This has been great.
Better than using a non branded liquid liner
Miz from New York
No mess, easy to apply and lasted the entire evening
I've tried premium brands and this is still my #1
Bri from Milwaukee, WI
Easy to create any style wing. Basically a marker. No smudging. Lasts all day.
I would buy this again!
k.bost from Maryland
It reminds me of a thin sharpie it sort of glides on your eye.
I wanted to love it
Kward from North Las Vegas
I was so excited to try this liner because of the great reviews I read. So, first off, I loved how smooth and easily it went on my lid. And I absolutley loved the finish! But after my third use, the tip dried out and no longer distributed ink. So I would have to go back with a different liner to give me that sharp crisp wing. Also, it wasn't waterproof as it stated on the packaging. It easily comes off when my eyes water or when I slightly rubbed it. I don't think I'll get this again :(
Loses Pigment Fast
Abby from Wisconsin
After opening and using a few times, the pigment began to fade overall which I think means that it's drying out. You have to go over the lines you have made to build up opacity. Although you can get great precision with this liner it's worth it to invest in something higher-quality.
Star from Brooklyn
It was dried out when I got it just bad
Save your money and invest
Mar from Fresno, California
Save your money and invest! This eyeliner is pigmented at the first couple of uses, however, it dries out quickly. The applicator then starts to apply an uneven amount of product, leaving a not so good winged liner. It is easy to use but invest on something better.
not waterproof, smears easily
ForeverHeather from West Palm Beach, FL
Honestly, I was impressed how the eyeliner went on to my eyes with precision and it has a beautiful matte finish. I bought this because it got good reviews, which I honestly don't know why it did after wearing it for like an hour. I have allergies, so waterproof makeup is my go to. This was advertised as waterproof and smudge proof once it dries. While I was driving to work, one of my eyes because slightly watery. I blinked and it came out of the corner of my eye, on the side of my wing. When I got to work and took off my sunglasses, half of my upper eye lid was black and the eyeliner was smeared. It was a disaster and it was embarrassing. So glad this happened on the way to work because I'm going to a wedding after work and I now know to go get a different eyeliner to redo my makeup before I look like a hot mess. Just really disappointed because honestly... the application was one of the best out of all the brands of liquid eyeliner pens I have tried.
Tip dries out
balloon girl from Illinois
I used this product to draw wings and liners, and loved it. But after a while of usage the tip grew dry, and no longer worked. This made it very hard to get a good pigmented fine lined wing.
Amazing product!!!! One of my favorite eyeliners ever.
Mary from East Brunswick, NJ
The application is amazing because the tip of the marker is thin enough
Its a no
mm09 from Massachusetts
Not sure how this has so many good reviews, first off i never had a problem with smudging or transfer. BUT after only a few uses it doesn't come out at the tip of the felt, it always has a small piece of hair from the felt at the end so it makes a mess of your wing and it's difficult to get right, i use a different liner to create the outline and use this one to fill. I wouldn't buy again
BEST PRICE FOR GREAT WINGS
Alex from Greensboro NC
I absolutely love this eyeliner and the price, let's be real! I've tried the Stila liquid liner and THIS is a great dupe. It's super easy to apply and it lasts all day long for me, but is easy to remove with a makeup wipe. I feel like this would be a great product for beginners or for people who enjoy doing winged liner like myself. It's great, I haven't tried anything else in years. Once you find it, you STICK WITH IT GIRL!
Works Great...at First
Joziegurrl from Seattle, WA
I loved this eye liner the first few times I used it. The pigment is dark and rich and it lasts well on the eyes and does not transfer. The brush tip is long, and the product applies evenly. But...and this is a big BUT...after using it for a week or two, nothing comes out at the tip of the brush so it's impossible to get a wing or even a nice tight line along the lash. You have to smash the side of the tip down on your lid, and it just makes a mess. I kept trying to make it work, but I have to say "goodbye" to this product. Bummer.
Quick transfer with oily skin
Marly from Iowa
Like other reviews I was trying to find a solid drug store choice. My favorite eyeliner is kat von d. The mayine liner lasts about two hours then starts to dissapear. It smears easily too.. I used a primer and basic shadow. It didn't even last me to lunch. I looked terrible and I wish I had just spent the extra on another brand .
Pros easily application to the eye