Rated 4.54 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love it! I'm glad I purchased this liner!
I have purchased and tried several eye liners (pencil, gel, etc) from multiple brands and I did not like any of them because they did not last more than a few hours. I have a little oily skin, so even when I put the eyelid primer, these eye liners got smudged. Also, these were not easy to apply. However, ARTLINER from LANCOME is an absolute winner!! I finally found the one that really works!! I've been using it for over a week now. * It stays on for the whole 9 hrs while I left home, went to work, and came home!! * It does not smudge. * Color stays the same as well -- it does not fade away. * It dries faster than I expected, so it's nice especially when I don't have much time in the morning before I go to work. * Also, it is easier to apply than I thought. A little tip for you -- When the color gets lighter, just put the pen back into the tube, shake a little (which makes some clicking sound), and the liquid is on again. I hesitated for a month or so to purchase this eye liner because this isn't cheap for me, but...I highly recommend this eye liner! Totally worth it :-) This was my 1st Lancome purchase.
Most Helpful Critical Review Why No Iceblack??
Hi! I'm wondering what color I can use to replace the ice black. Are used ice black for 18 years along with my three sisters and two great friends. We all LOVE Ice Black and wonder why you don't offer it anymore? Will you be offering it at all in the future? It is a perfect color for women who are over 50. It is a soft collar and it is in Hance into the eyes. And wonder why you don't offer it anymore? Will you be offering it at all in the future? It is a perfect color for women who are over 50. It is a soft collar and it is in Hance into the eyes. Please let me know if you'll be offering this excellent color again in the future. I loved this product from I loved this product from a long cold. Lanc?me. :-)
Reviewed by 905 customers Dried out
Maureen1414 from MA
I was able to use it a few times before I could no longer get any more. I love a dark purple liner & it's hard to find them in liquid form, so I was super disappointed.
Best eyeliner ever!!
VickiWise from Morrisville, Mo.
For 20 years I have loved this eyeliner... The best product!!
I would buy, and do, this product again
Sassy from Lake J, NC
Love the color but miss the other blue and the smokeblack they used to offer
Yes if i can not find a brown i like better
Donna from TX
love the liner , easy to use but i ordered the brown because i think black it to harsh since i have brown eyes , the brown is still to dark for me in this liner .
Tip is too thick and messy. Couldn't get a good wing.
Bree from Idaho
Messy tip. Will be taking this back.
I will Definitely buy again
Amie from Spartanburg SC
I love the Smooth thin line.
K the runner from Marana, AZ
Have been using liquid eyeliners for years ~40+); a lot are difficult to get a smooth line or easily smudge. This does not. Recommend
very difficult to use
long time user from Virginia Beach VA
I do not like this eyeliner at all. Very difficult to apply. The tip isn't firm enough to draw a straight line. I wish I could send it back.
The texture changed with liner. It's Poor
101 from San jose
I've used this liner for over 25 years and it has a new texture that is long lasting but hard to remove. Even make removal doesn't work. My eyes got irritated for the new product. I don't like the liner anymore.
ICE BLACK ARTLINER PLEASE BRING BACK!!!
ICE BLACK LOVER from VA
I LOVED ICE BLACK & had used it for many years as it is the most beautiful & flattering shade for me. And I always got compliments wearing ICE BLACK. I've tried other colors but NOTHING compares to ICE BLACK. PLEASE, PLEASE bring ICE BLACK back again. There is a huge following of us girls who are begging for Lancome to bring ICE BLACK back. PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!
Jules from Madison,WI
This was my to go to eyeliner. Absolutely love it. Problem is the last 2 times I've bought it the tip would bend in half and does not straighten out so it's impossible to use. I'm now struggling to find a new liner.
Angie from Menifee ca
I wanted to leave a review to hopefully save another person from wasting their money on this product. This liner is one of the most expensive and the worst I've tried. I normally spend $25 on Kaja liner that is not sold in Ulta. I decided to try this instead of driving to a different store and regret it! The liquid is watery, needing multiple layers to achieve deep black pigment. The applicator tip is too flimsy to make a precise line. The first time I tried it my eyes watered and the liner smeared on my eyelid. When I tried the next day, the liner needed reapplication after only a couple hours. I normally do not have a need to reapply liner throughout the day. Waste of money for a product that is not worth it half of what I spent.
The Best ever!
deb from Toledo, Ohio
This is the best, blackest stay-put eyeliner ever. no others compare.
Amazing For First Time Eyeliner Users
MakeupNoobie from Pittsburgh, PA
I have never been one to wear much makeup, but felt like I wanted to try a simple winged eyeliner. I've tried it in the past and was completely unsuccessful. Truthfully, I ended up looking like a creepy vampire from an old scary movie. When I went to Ulta the sales associate steered me towards this liner and I decided to give it a shot. It is AMAZING, especially if you do not have experience perfecting the perfect winged liner. It is long-lasting, smooth, easy to apply and all around excellent. I highly recommend for those with or without makeup experience.
Best liquid ever used
Smo from San Antonio tx
I have oily lids and this didn't come off! It also doesn't wash off too easily either!
Not a fan
Donna Dee from Staten Island, NY
I really wanted to like this because I decided to try liquid liner but couldn't find any with shimmery blues or greens, which are the colors I purchased. It definitely lasted, no smudging on my lids. But the color looks too much like vinyl on my lids and was thick like a latex strip. Both are going back.
Jinx from Michigan
I love this liner, but it doesn't have that much liquid in it. Also the tip could be sharper, but they color is amazing! It's so black! And even when you get to the bottom of the liner the color doesn't fade because of lower concentration. overall I LOVE THIS LINER! But not so much for beginners, keep that in mind.
Best Eyeliner Out There!
ARocky from Gilbert, AZ
Thank you Lancome for making a quality eyeliner that doesn't smudge, fade, and lasts ALL day! Please never change this formula or applicator method. This eyeliner is the best and I've tried several name brands. I have oily skin and have difficulty finding a liner that doesn't smudge, run, or fade. For the quality, this liner is worth EVERY penny! For years I had used Estee Lauder Double Wear Zero-Smudge Liquid Eyeliner, until last year when they changed their formula (that now smudges) and switched to a pen style applicator. I would recommend Lancome over every eyeliner out there.
lop from texas
the tip was sharper. Unfortunately because of this I am on the hunt for another liquid liner.
Luvmsb from Jackson, MI
Lasts all day but small for the price.
Easy to use
MAC1 from St. Joseph, MO
I have been using the Artliner for years. I find it goes on much better than an eyeliner pencil and it looks better.
Bluffton from Bluffton, SC
I have been using this product for years. Cannot live without it.
The best eyeliner ever!!!
Dianne from Poughkeepsie,NY
I have been buying this for years. It's the best..
I like this even better than the Grandiose Liner
JT from IL
The Lancome Grandiose Liner was sold to me by an enthusiastic store associate as very easy to use because of the articulated applicator but I find the Artliner even easier to apply! The brush handle is nice and slim for my small fingers.
Not great for long lasting
Mkool from Monterey
This product was a nice color. Half way through day though, it came off on my upper eyelid