Rated 3.9 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Can't stop buying this Mascara
It comes out perfectly and always make my lashes look AMAZING! I like a dramatic look, so I apply a couple of coats (2 or 3) and people ask me if they're fake! But what's cool about it is you can also play it down and do a super natural look with one coat and it elongates your lashes by a lot. Love the brush of this mascara too!
It is pretty hard to remove if you do more than one coat, but definitely worth it!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not for sensitive skin!
Yes, it works as a waterproof mascara, it didn't smudge and it wasn't until the very end of the day that it would flake (which is easily tidied up). Sadly, the quality of this mascara is completely diminished by the end of the day when I'm fighting with my eyelids to get the stuff off!
Because it's so hard to take off I actually ended up with dry skin on my bottom eyelid and it has made my under eye skin almost droopy, especially where I tried the mascara a few times just to see if a different remover would work (none did, I'm 18 and have had to start using under eye cream because of this product!)
Alas, I am left with what looks like tissue paper on my under eyes and a wasted almost £10 tube of mascara which caused more hassle than it was worth!
If you're going to buy this, please test it on your arm first and leave it for a while, then see how hard it is to remove and how your skin takes to that.
Reviewed by 269 customers my favorite mascara
sunny1111 from Ashburn, VA
I curl my lashes and then put this mascara on and it stays up for a long time!! I tried using other mascaras but I always end up back to this one so I would definitely recommend!
All time FAVORITE mascara!
Allie from MD
I have been using this mascara for the past 10 years now. I've tried so many other brands because I always expected the more expensive mascaras to be game changing, but they weren't. I always come back to this brand! It separates each lash and I never look clumpy, my lashes never lose their curl as they do with other mascaras, and it never transfers to the skin around my eyes like others do.
My only tip would be that you HAVE TO use waterproof makeup remover. The only one I have found that works to remove this mascara is L'Oreal Clean Artiste waterproof eye makeup remover in the green bottle or Dermalogica Precleanse.
Not actually water proof
Jess from Missouri
Mascara is very pretty, but it's not as waterproof as it claims to be. It also flakes pretty badly when used it n the bottom lashes.
Like it but..
D from Lemon grove ca
Love this product but prefer the water proof
I've tried them all and this is still the best!!
Kathryn from Columbia, SC
I am a makeup fiend. I'm constantly getting samples of mascaras through the makeup bags I subscribe to every month. However, this mascara is the only bargain brand I have ever, and I mean EVER, used that measures up to the best prestige products I've used. I love Monsieur Big and Bad Gal Bang for prestige mascaras. But I'm balling on a budget most days and a full tube of this is cheaper than a travel size of either of those, and it is the same, if not better quality. I constantly recommend this mascara to friends, I feel like it's severely underrated. Not only does it volumize, but it holds my eyelashes' curl and makes them look longer. It doesn't flake (in my experience) and comes off easily with eye makeup remover. I really cannot say enough about this mascara. GET IT.
Maggie from Texas
I can't say enough good things about this mascara. Try it!!!! This is my ride or die!
Love this mascara!
Nicole from NJ
This mascara volumizes, separates, and holds a curl to my straight lashes. It lasts all day and does not clump or smudge! It is difficult to remove, but that's like all waterproof mascaras I've tried, just use a good makeup remover, like a cleansing oil/balm. I definitely would recommend for those with straight lashes who are looking for their lashes to stand out and hold a curl all day!
I will definitely buy this again
Aleshia from Oklahoma City, OK
I love a good waterproof mascara. I previously tried the regular version and loved it, so when I saw this waterproof version I had to try it. It goes on smoothly and my lashes look amazing.
Cindy from San Antonio, TX
Loved it! & it is truly waterproof.
Pam from Midland,Tx
Lifts and separates
I've always loved this stuff
Sam jo from Georgia
I've used this stuff for years and it's always been my favorite, still love it! Only mascara I use.
I have bought this mascara over and over
Cari from California
Most mascaras make my eyelashes fall after I've curled them. I have long straight eyelashes and this mascara works amazing.
Hard to get off and irritating to my eyes
JELmom from USA
I really loved the Loreal Voluminous Waterproof mascara, and saw this at the store and decided to try something new. I really dislike this. Like really. It is very irritating to my eyes and kinda burns and flakes really bad. Also compared to Voluminous, my lashes look spidery and they feel hard like they will snap off. This is also sooooo hard to get off. I will stick to Voluminous. Soft full lashes with no irritation.
Not that great
T from OH
I was disappointed with this product. It is not worth the money. It did not add length and it did not add fullness. The only good thing is that it is waterproof
My go to!!!
Flo from Montclair, CA
I have straight lashes and need a waterproof mascara that will hold them up once they are curled. This one coats them evenly and does not clump. It's a little difficult to remove but it's worth it!
I have purchased for a couple of years!!!
Friend for life from Spring Hill FL
I apply 1 coat in the morning early and it lasts all day.. I appreciate the fact that it does not smudge below my eye.. It is easy to remove in the evening.. I love that it is waterproof.. I will buy again and again..Much better than any exspensive brands I have tried..Friend for life
Love my lashes!
BekkahN from Waukesha, WI
I have long, straight eyelashes. I curl them before applying this mascara. This mascara holds the curl and seperates. It doesn't clump or flake.
Perfect for short, weak lashes!!!!
Margo from USA
I have very small eyelashes. If I use regular mascara (not waterproof) my eyelashes fall down in 2 seconds even thought I curled them with an eyelash curler. I've been using this product for YEARS and it has never disappointed me. If you have short, weak eyelashes, I would definitely recommend this because it keeps your eyelashes up ALL day. It smudges every so slightly but only if I'm sweating heavily. It's never smudged on a night out. It is difficult to remove, you need to get a makeup remover specific for waterproof makeup
Maria from Pa
Love it for everyday.
Best of the Best
KarlaG from Illinois
First thing - I suck at applying mascara. Yep...totally suck at it. I have very hooded eyelids, so it's a difficult process. However, this mascara is soooo easy to work with that I almost (ALMOST) feel like I know what I am doing. No clumping, lengthens, separates and is a nice black color. It also holds curl in my stick-straight lashes. I have tried many different mascaras, both high end (Dior and the like) as well as drug store, and this is by far the best. Mine didn't smudge or flake. So happy I found this!
Mommamac from Denver
Love this mascara
Lacey from Maine
While I prefer to purchase natural/organic products there simply is not an option for a decent mascara (for my particular lashes). I have found that this is one of very few mascaras that keeps my lashes (that require a heated curler to curl) curled and has good, but not overwhelming coverage. The brush is great for easy application and the formula feels light on the lashes. It does not weigh down my lashes the way most mascara does and does not smudge or flake at all. If you want a heavier look, layering works great.
This is my go to
Amy from Western PA
I have been using this for what seems like forever. Every time I try the newest and greatest, and most expensive, I always come back to this product. I am never without. I always have a spare on hand. The others never seem to do what this does for me. It's easy to apply, does not clump, comes off relatively easy even with micellar water (the ones that state for waterproof makeup) and a cotton pad. It doesn't really lengthen a lot but it does give volume without clumping or stickiness.
Not happy with this product ... dry product
Donna from Harrisburg
Don't like it
Stephanie from Tennessee
Terrible. I bought this because I read somewhere it doesn't smudge at all. Thinking it's a tube mascara, I HATE IT. Smudged and transferred to my eyelids easily. TERRIBLE TERRIBLE TERRIBLE