Rated 4.05 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review YAS QUEEN. Just wish it was water proof
Goes on amazing and easy for a thin cat eye or a bold cat eye but runs easily. Wish it was water proof!!!
Most Helpful Critical Review Loved it at first...
I was using this eyeliner every day for a winged look and loving it. But over the last few weeks it seems to produce too much product and that causes it to spread out over my eyelid after applying. I wipe the tip off in a napkin first too, which is a big waste of product. So disappointed, it applies so nicely when it works, but literally ruins my entire eye look which can be a real pain to fix.
Reviewed by 402 customers Blackest Black < 3
MiaLia from Florida
Glides on smoother than my Stila liquid liner, and shows up very pigmented and clean, even on darker complexions. Lasts most of the day!
Wanted to love
Bon from Rockford, il
I wanted to like this eyeliner so bad. I bought this as a stand in for my usual go to eyeliner. I liked it at first but the more times I used it the more I realized how bad it feathers into the tiny lines of my eye. It ends up taking me more time cleaning the mess up than actually putting it on.
Easy to use
Dz from Stl
One of the easiest pens i've used. Super black. Easy to touch up and lasts
Good but not worth it
Liv from Florida
I loved this eyeliner right when I got it- it lasts a long time, goes on so smooth, and the brush is super precise BUT the brush gets super messed up and frayed after continuously putting the cap over it. The springs inside also come loose making it hard to put the cap on. Could be a perfect eyeliner pen but it falls apart so fast. I've had 2 of them now and they both did this
Jil from Las Vegas, NV
I was honestly shocked at how truly black this eyeliner is. It is deep, dark, and long lasting. I really like the felt pen tip, it's not too hard but not too flexible. Easy to work with and long lasting. Highly recommend!
Spills everywhere after a few weeks...
lera from dc
This eyeliner is a nightmare to use. Initially, this wasn't the case, it was fine and dandy. However, after having it for a few weeks it starts leaking and spilling out and decorating your eyelids with these not so lovely ink splotches which then effectively ruin your makeup...
Maryann from MI
Love this eyeliner! It applies super smoothly and dries quick. Also, love the gold cheetah print design!
Last All Day!!
Tasha from Manchester CT
I love this eyeliner is last all day long nonsmudes does not run its stays matte all day and Easy to do wings
Matte for days!!!
Fabi from Houston,Tx
A true black matte finish!!!! This was easy to use, i can line/wing out both of my eyes without the need to "cap the eyeliner" back. This is a true matte finish and wore well all day! Im glad i tried it out, i juggle between smash box, it cosmetics, nyx epic liner and urban decay(all felt tip) but i think this is it!!!!
Diana from Michigan
I bought this after I stopped buying Kat von d liner. It feels watered down which made it hard for me to apply without smudging it. Once one it did last but the application would take so long.
Ultabeauty from Paso Robles Ulta
I've always bought Mac black gel-liquid eyeliner for years. Those were my first and was always my go to couldn't use any other products because it was my "fav." But for some reason i wanted to try it . Also, Ive been out of eyeliner and since the pandemic started been to nervous about buying things but I came across this on sale and tried it! Oh my god it's the best of all time the name sticks to it. Easy to apply and when it says no smudges they mean it. I'm in love with this eyeliner it now my new fav.
Bria from Keego harbor
I never write reviews but I love love love this liner. I normally get eye liner on my lid through out today but not with this stuff. I don't even use eye primer. Way better then urban decay which I had been using for awhile
Really nice even for a novice like me
June from Ohio
I am not the most talented when it comes to makeup so never thought I was worthy of these 'hip' brands lol. But I am glad I decided to try this. It's very easy to use and pretty forgiving.
I had been using drugstore stuff and always stuck with Lash Stiletto (can't remember the brand....) for like the last ten years or so. What I liked about that one is how easy it was to wet a q tip and correct errors.
I wanted something a little higher quality so I started using NYX matte liquid liner. It looked really good and the application was pretty easy, but the formula dried way too fast on my lids, and I didn't have 2 seconds to correct anything. And for someone like me that was an issue. I would end up over correcting and making my lines too thick.
But this Tarte Maneater formula is like the perfect mesh of those two, in my opinion.
So even for the makeup newbie or if you just suck at makeup like me, this is an easy to use, mildly forgiving formula that looks amazing! The pen is easy to handle and creates great lines, you can go thin or thicker with ease. I only used this once and no issues with bubbling or spilling formula, but I have made a conscious effort to store it mostly upright.
My favorite liquid eyeliner
Kat from New Jersey
I'm obsessed with this eyeliner. It applies like a dream and it takes a long time for the pen to dry out. I love that it's a brush tip as well.
A good eyeliner
BiancaG from A,TX
It's a really good eyeliner! It doesn't take much to be a good eyeliner but it's probably one of the best I've used.
Bestgirlever from Virginia beach va
Easily my favorite liquid eyeliner. I dress in costumes a bit and it is great for drawing on your face. Then you can go straight to doing your eyes. When it's on sale I stock up, but still have no problem paying full price. I think it would be cool to see them do a couple different colors. but 100% content with my black for now. It lasts perfectly against 8+ hours of bartending ♡
Smooth Application and All Day Wear
Madelyn from Chandler, Arizona
Eyeliner is my go-to product. I have tried quite a few eyeliners and liquid eyeliners, but in terms of precision and length of wear, this is by far the best. The tip is strong, yet glides across the lid for smooth, precise application. Having hooded eyelids, by the end of the day my eyeliner is usually a smear on the top of my lid, but this is not the case whatsoever with Maneater. Its pigment and depth stays put, even during my 10 hour work days.
olivia from wisconsin
i've had this eyeliner for like, three years, and it's treated me well!! it does drip if stored incorrectly though, and the spring came out of it but it's still worked just fine. it's very opaque and long lasting!
Great, but will drip!
Jas from New Jersey
I learned the hard way, that this should be stored upright! If you hold this liner upside down too long, extra product will spill and bubble out of the tip. If you continue to hold it upside down, it'll drip! It makes SUCH a mess! HOWEVER, if you hold it correctly, this liner glides very well, and lasts all day! It's very simple, but does a great job!
Dalal from Rockford
Very good love
Favorite Eye Liner
Gigi from Corvallis
This is the best eyeliner I have found. Stats put all day, easy to apply and dried fast! It's my go-to for sure!
It's a brush BE CAREFUL
Redheadedhippie from Jolon, CA
I was shocked the first time I used this eyeliner. I've only used liquid and felt tip before this and was floored by how easy and soft it is! Almost messed up my eyeliner cause I was thinking it needed the pressure on it like a felt tip.. WRONG light strokes only
mags from Nashville
I've been using liquid eyeliner more than usual with the mask requirements these days. I would normally use IT cosmetics eyeliner, but had one of these. I think this eyeliner is wonderful. it applies nicely and keeps its color throughout the day, but isn't a pain in the butt to remove.
Broke on third use
Abigail from Naples Florida
I was doing my makeup before work in my car and when I took the cap off...it broke and the spring popped out. Not sure if it was a faulty one? Would have loved to use it more.
My Go-To Eyeliner!
Lex from IN, USA
I got a travel sized version before. Initially I wasn't used to this kind of eyeliner pen (started with pencil but then we upgraded to liquid), but I don't think I can ever go to another eyeliner. I love the lines it creates with my eyeliner, and it lasts all day! No running, no transfer. It stays so well that I have to use more than just a makeup remover wipe to get it off! A must-buy.