Rated 4.42 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Absolutely terrific.
Let me start by saying I basically have translucent, blonde brows. Think Tilda Swinton blonde. I'm also that pale. I get them tinted from time to time, but not as often as I should. So, most of the time I have to wear some type of brow product in order to see them at all. I was using the Benefit Gimme Brow and was fairly satisfied with it. It's not been available for purchase recently so I had to try something different. I'm glad I did. Not only is Make Me Brow so much cheaper than Gimme Brow, it's better. It has better pigmentation and gives me more volume. This doesn't run or smudge and stays in place all day, yet it isn't difficult to remove or clean on skin if some strays from the brow during application. For the price, I doubt there is a better brow product on the market. I will happily purchase this again and again.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not for those with sparse eyebrows
I have dark but very sparse eyebrows and have loved the benefit gimme brow and was hoping this would be a cheaper alternative. Sadly while it has a small brush the bristles are too spaced out and it couldn't 'grab' onto my sparse brows and make much of a difference. If you have thicker brows and just want a little fill in it would probably work great. But for me it was a no go and was returned a few days later.
Reviewed by 1577 customers Unexpectedly Good!
Maisy from New York, NY
I didn't have high expectations but figured for the low price it was worth a shot. I actually love it! And you really can't beat the price. I have blonde eyebrows and use a pencil to help define some areas then top it with the essence brow gel and really like the combo! Will definitely buy again!
favorite eyebrow filler
Em from NJ
it does not give you that super bold brow look, i always get compliments that my eyebrows look microbladed on because this gel just lightly fills in the gaps in your brows for a very natural look! i like to go over with a clear gel to really lock the shape in place!
Peyton from Virginia Beach
Really like this product but wish it came in a bigger container. This is a great product for anyone who wants a quick way to fill in their brows that are already full.
So difficult to color match
Lauren N from Los Angeles
First off, the description of the shades were so confusing to me. I bought multiple and done matched my eyes (I have light brown hair). The benefit gimme brow is perfect in my opinion but so expensive so I was hoping this would be a dupe. I am a 3 in the gimme brow if that helps anyone.
Great for the price
Brooke from WV
I keep repurchasing this bc of the price and color range. If I lose it it's no issue to replace. Just wish the spoolie was a little smaller. Sometimes I get product on my skin above my brows that I have to clean up.
Great for sparse brows
Heather from Tulsa,OK
Does a good job of making my brows look fuller but still more natural. Can get a little too thick if you're not careful though.
Great deal, weird smell
Claire from Seattle
I have pretty thick eyebrows and really needed just a minimal fill in and a lot of help shaping. This Gel Mascara is such a good deal but ... the smell is horrible! I can deal with it because I'm not too sensitive but if you have a low tolerance I would avoid this product. It's not bad enough that other people notice but it's directly on your face so it will affect you more.
Works, but needs help
Moka from Santa Fe, NM
I really love Essence products so I decided to try the brow gel when my old one tan out. The color is great it's very chocolatey for sure, but I struggled getting it to stiffen to keep my brows all in place. It was great for filling in sparse areas but didn't really tack up to keep them in place. Though I will buy again because the color is amazing and great for filling in.
blazngret from Mississippi
This is better than Benefit's Gimme Brow for a fraction of the price
maybe i don't have enough eyebrow
e from wisconsin
made my eyebrows look terrible, but i do have thin blonde brows
always a good purchase
nev from FL
I recently dyed my hair so I had to get a different color, I have naturally nice brows I just like to accentuate them a little ! I love love love this gel mascara especially for the price.
thia from usa
I love this stuff. my only complaint is that there's glitter in the formula
Perfect and affordable
Courtni Branch from Martinez, CA
This brow mascara works wonders! I already have pretty full brows, so I just use this to fill in the sparse areas. Good color match and formula that applies easily.
Bunny from Ohio
This is my go to brow gel. It makes my brows look so fluffy and defined, so if you like that soap brow look but need something more pigmented definitely give this a shot. It's one of Essence's best products!
Court82 from Evansville, IN
I really love this product. It looks natural on my brows & holds them in place all day. I love the little tube. The wand is small enough to be precise with the application. Its a small bottle, but it lasts a long while. The price is fantastic as well.
Great value product!
Poopysmom from Meridian ID
About half the price of competitors!
I would buy this product again
Mel from Midwest city, OK
Great product love it
Great brow mascara
Carly from Utah
This is really easy and quick to use. And it helps fill in my brows naturally. Especially for the price 👏👏
I have bought this prodcut 3 times now... LOVE IT!!
Raine from Oceanside , Ca.
Use on eyebrows only... works perfect
It's alright if you already have shaped, thicker brows
Ashcat from Fort wayne
The product is pretty good, it actually keeps brows in place and the pigment is nice. I don't really like the spoolie as if you touch your skin, it causes globs. It was kind of hard to use it towards the tail of my brows since there wasn't a lot of hair.
I would buy it again
Wawa from Long Beach Ca
I use two different colors to shape my brows👍😇
Needs a darker shade
RPM from Texas
This is the darkest color they offer, yet still not dark enough for those of us who have black or blue black hair.
Great and affordable
Sammy Sosa from Salt Lake, Utah
It's great, easy to use and affordable.
Not for me
Sam from Pennsylvania
I wasn't a huge fan of this gel but I also prefer pomades. The chocolate color was too warm for my brow color and I found it to pull my brow hairs together almost like mascara would with lashes. Good product for many but not all
Decent eyebrow gel
ledzepgirl78 from NY
This is a nice eyebrow gel, the color is perfect, lasts all day, doesn't smear, but I think the formula needs to a little adjusting or maybe its the brush itself because it initially puts a little too much product on. It's an easy fix though and not a deal breaker!