Rated 4.05 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing colours!
Purchased 6 colors 3 weeks ago. I was so excited to try some new colored eyeliner but was sorely disappointed. Before application, I noticed that the colors on the actual bottle don't match the box at all, so that there me off. When I applied it, it went on nicely but I had to go over it a couple more times since the pink, yellow, and lilac ones were almost transparent. The other colors were nice to put on. The one thing I hated was when it dries. First off, it doesn't dry as the same colour it totally looks different. Second, the texture was horrible, it dries like paint, chips like paint, and looked like paint (look at swatches pic w/o flash to see the paint like texture). Lastly, the brush is too thick in my opinion, it made it hard to do details on my liner.
Now, I'm not a professional mua, so take my review with a grain of salt.
Most Helpful Critical Review dry and flaky
I bought this eyeliner in the color 'vivid fire' a couples of weeks ago and when I used it today (for the first time) it immediately felt dry and by the time i had applied mascara and falsies it had flaked like paint. :(
Reviewed by 1200 customers good
May from San Jose
It's a good eyeliner. I personally don't like the brush applicator because I can't really get precise lines. It's thicker than a felt tip. It is a smooth application though, and doesn't smudge. Additionally, when dried, the color just looks... dry... and not as vibrant. I guess it just depends on one's preference.
Last long beautiful color
Honey love from Fayetteville North Carolina
Love this I bought all the colors it's amazing yes
LilLoy from Ulta
Love love love! Color is super pigmented, I got the yellow one and use it all the time! However, just like their white liner, it cracks easily so you have to go over it a couple times.
Very Nice Color
The Hijabi from Van Nuys, CA
I like the color pay off, the color is very bright. I don't know if anyone else experienced this, but this burned my eyelid when I first applied it a few times.
Fun and Easy
NMC40 from California
The Vivid Escape (Lime green) is the perfect chartreuse green color that I was searching in a liquid liner. This was my first time trying this formula but I had to get used to letting the liquid dry on my eyes and felt my eyes scrunch a bit. There was no crumbling or color flaking off at all and it stayed put. I liked how easy the tip let me place the color in the inner corner without a mess. This color with a bit of iridescent eyeshadow looks killer!
Denise from Iowa City
Love this, super easy to apply and very bright
Jaz from NM
Does not look nothing like the color on the box. It's more of a darker greenish. I was really looking forward to wearing it this summer
Bright green tube but dull color
Kay from Columbus, Ohio
I was looking for bright, fun, liquid eyeliners for summer. I had high hopes for this green color going off the box. But the actual liner color is like army green. Really dull and bland. I am not sure about the staying power yet but will report back.
What an eyeliner should be!
Dimples from Saint Louis
Love this eyeliner...I will be buying every color
I love the vivid brights!!!!
Chavella from Buffalo Ny
I love NYX liquid liners I think they have the best applicator and the vivid colors are amazing so fun spices up my simple make up looks!!!
Love the thin applicator
lisa from maryland
Creates a thin line
colors not as shown, quality is extremely low
megs from illinois
one star- *DO NOT BUY THESE* colors do not look like the bottles or pics, they are horribly drying and crack immediately after they dry down, and then crumble away. these wouldn't last 2 minutes out on a day to day basis. they also dry down so dark even though the formula is oddly milky. I had to do 2 to 3 coats to make them not streaky, but that made my eyelids tighter when they dried. just a horrible product, no quality control whatsoever.
the bright colors i was looking for!
Ingrid from Northampton, MA
i bought the white and the red eyeliners after searching high and low for liquid eyeliners bright enough. the colors go on opaque and stay opaque! another review mentioned some reactions on sensitive skin. sometimes there is a little bit of discomfort after putting it on, but it's honestly not bad, especially compared to some other eyeliners i've tried out.
brooke from ulta beauty
worst eyeliner. Cracks and just doesn't stay at all.
Color is off
Christy from Texas
The color of the tube looks really vivid and bright but the actual color of the liquid is more of an olive drab green. Completely different color than advertised.
kay from tallahassee
not very bright
don't recommend if your skin is sensitive
dona from panama city beach,FL
I was so exited to use the red eyeliner, after getting my delivery I tried on the blue on one eye and it started kinda born it was unpleasant feeling, then I tried red one on the second eye it didn't burn . I took of them tonight and next morning woke up with one red eye , this one was the side where I applied red eyeliner. Monufacturars seems to use molar paint ¡.
😷 from Los Angeles
It smells horrible. It's a smell between pool water and dirty gym lockers. Idk but I couldn't apply it without gagging. I got the green and It is a nice color but I would not buy again because of the smell. No way.
Doesn't get any better than this
Andria Flores from Hutchinson Kansas
This is the most highly pigmented amazing eyeliner ever I will continue to buy this over and over again this is a must have does not crack flake goes on nice and smooth looks fabulous I need to buy like five more of these in every color that's how amazing this stuff is
I buy this in blue
Arooba from VA
I love to wear blue liner mascara
Annalise from Goleta
I usually love NYX products but this eyeliner cracks SOOOOO much! It's not that true to color and it smells like old paint you would use in kindergarten...I was so disappointed. Please save your money from this products.
Liz from Washington
Cracks SO BAD!! I bought in white, pink, and yellow. Immediately cracks and crumbles and the pink dries darker than applied. I've tried so hard to make it work and the closets I've come is to mixing a little with water and then applying over lash glue but even then there's still a chance it'll crack. Definitely not worth it. Shouldn't have to bend over back and forth to make it work ;(((
I would buy this item again.
Jas from New York
vibrant color and nice glide
Like the color very much
Ms. Rae from Carmel ny
Love the color .. bold. Bright . Easy to apply
Good, but not great
Neko from Kansas city
The color is pretty but darker than i thought..the applicator is very good too..my only issue is there does seem to be that much and it has a very strange smell.