Rated 3.36 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Like training wheels
I love this product... It just does it for me. It allows for better stability and even application than any other eyeliner. It's lasted me months even though I use it everyday. I wish it was a little more opaque but other than that, it's amazing
Most Helpful Critical Review Dries out too fast
I bought this liner and I am very disappointed. First line goes on great but then it's too dry to do a second line, no matter how many times I shake it. It literally has to sit overnight in order for the liquid to fall to the tip. And I store it horizontally. I would not recommend. I've been waiting 20 minutes to fill this in and can't get liquid in the tip.
Reviewed by 140 customers Would not but again
Ap from Mesa, Az
I bought this to try and save money as I usually use the Kay Von D tattoo eyeliner. Not with it. It looks pretty on, but smudges way to easy, even 8 hours later, so it never dries. I'll continue to pay the extra money.
My Favorite Eyeliner!
Finicky Girl from Columbus, OH
Felt tip design makes it easy to apply very precisely. Product is a gel that glides easily & dries quickly. Only available in black. Need more colors!!
Smudged all over lid
Minx from Dallas
I am a loyal Loreal customer but do not like this product. Many other lines sell a product like this that is way better. Mine smudged all over my upper lid, I had to take all my eye make up off while I was out.. it was embarrassing. It is non water proof but the other products from other lines aren't either but they don't smudge. This is not worth it.
Amber40 from Ohio
You have to press really hard to get anything to come out of the tip which makes it go on way to heavy. Also it smudged all over my face.
Alee from Bakersfield California
I bought this expecting to have a decentiner, and was very excited when I opened it, but no matter what I do, I cannot get it to show any more than a very pale gray. I will not be buying this again
Not smudge proof
MT47 from Cookeville, Tn
I bought this because wanted a good smudge proof eyeliner. Not even an hour after application, it faded and smudge all around my eye. Thank goodness I was just all home.
MikeSmith from New York, NY
A wonderful product that works as it is intended to do.
It does stay on
C Christine from Texas
I'm ok with this eyeliner but I would have loved it to have stayed on darker the black is not dark enough for me.
HenrySmith from New York, NY
A wonderful product that works as it is intended to do.
No tapered tip!!
Toni123456 from Cincinnati, Ohio
I bought this because it looked like it would give a great winged look on the package. A nicely pointed tapered tip to draw flawless lines. NOPE! Upon opening it, it had no pointed tip, but a blunt, fat tip that totally ruined my look. Application was everywhere, no precision anywhere. I hated it. And would like my money back to go purchase a new liner that I can actually use.
Gata from Rock hill
Love the wear it wears
Smudges and doesn't apply well
Snow29 from Provo,UT
I bought this yesterday and am extremely disappointed. For an expensive drugstore product, it does nothing that it claims on the packaging. I had to go over my line repeatedly to get any saturated color (even though I purchased Black Noir), it smudged within hours despite using a primer, eyeshadow, and setting spray, and it already seems like it's running out of ink - I used it once! Save your money and go buy a reliable product from Sephora. Stilla or Fenty may be twice the price but they don't smudge, last for months, and provide intense color.
Not the best
HM from Marietta, Ga
This eyeliner is terrible. It smudges and it dries quickly which makes it harder to apply. The applicator is just hard to manipulate. I rather use the L'Oreal infallible super thin! It works like a charm.
tiffersFL from Gainesville, FL
I have purchased this eyeliner a couple of times. I love it. The only thing that really bothers me is how it leaks every once and a while.
katwoman4545 from Tivoli, NY
This is a small compact product with excellent features.
Alexyates1345 from Rye, NY
This is a great product I really love. I think it works great.
RoseBlonde18 from Modesto, CA
This is my favorite eyeliner of all time and is the only eyeliner I mainly use now! The liner goes on smooth, looks great and last all day!
I love this
Ash from Washington
I've been using the same eyeliner for about maybe two years now. Idk why people say it's not long wearing because it is. You really can't beat the price and it's very black and bold, which I love. The only thing you have to be careful of is it will be a bit tricky at first to get a perfect winged liner with this because it kind of snags onto the outer corners of your eye and doesn't glide perfectly across, but you eventually see how to get around that and can make perfect winged eyeliners every time! I never want to switch liners.
aprilgift23 from Peekskill, NY
This is a great product & I would love to buy it again.
Kg from Edmond, OK
I usually love Loreal eye products. But this was more of a gray then a black and ran like crazy under my eyes.
Smears very easily
Kallie1801 from Minneapolis MN
Where as the brush shape was very easy to work with, i was consistently re-applying and wiping off smudged liner.
I like this liner
Em from New York
I am 60-years-old. I like a winged liner, and I really like the ease of this felt tip liner. This liner is half the cost of an IT liner, and has the same exact staying power (although the IT brand felt tip does glide better). This one lasts longer, and is half the cost!
Easy to use and looks great
Blooeyes from Chicago, IL
Wish they had more colors
Easy To Use, +Value
Beeknowsbad from ELK GROVE, CA
This eyeliner lasts me months! It is simple, easy to manuever, prevents me from making terrible mistakes and stabilized my hand with it's thick tip. Expect bold lines that are bold, the only thing that could be better is if it we're more lonng wearing. Doesn't go all day without needing touch up.
Great drugstore brand Liquid Liner!
TutorialFan from MN
This is a great liquid liner for the cost. Love the pen tip; it's not too thin and not too thick. You can switch the width of your line by angling the pen differently. I went to repurchase this and they were sold out in the store. Ended up buying their thinner liquid pen and like that one as well. Will definitely buy this one again when available. Great for everyday work makeup routine.