Size 0.05 oz|
Store & Pickup Availability
Rated 3.29 out of 5 stars
I wear thick glasses which make my eyes look small. Between heavy mascara and this liner, they make my eyes open up. The only negative is that it's messy. I have to keep it in a plastic bag, so it won't get on my other makeup. Of course it could be me, I have Parkinsons. That won't keep me from buying it.
I had high hopes for this product after reading reviews online and on blogs. Here's the thing, I have a ton of maybelline products, a plethora of eye makeup from both high end and drugstore. The claims on this say that it is safe on the waterline, will last all day, and is waterproof. It is (on me) none of those things. The kajal glides on like butter and color pigment is amazing but the minute it goes on my waterline, my eyes itch, turn red and burn. When I first applied it to the waterline I thought it was my allergies or that I may have poked myself somehow. Yet after multiple attempts to try this on my waterline, I can safely say it irritates my eyes when doing so. I resorted to using it on my lash line just so I do not have to deal with ^^^. Within the hour the color has faded and has smudged.
Lei from USA
I actually own this in brown and it is my FAVORITE ride or die product. For those saying you can't sharpen it, now that the point has dulled, I just use a small angled brush to put it on, similar to if it was a potted eyeliner pigment. I LOVE that it smudges and wipes up so easy since I can do (& fix!) a wing real quick and go.
Kajal/Kohl is supposed to be smeary and smokey, so if that is your problem you're probably misuing the product. It can be used for a precise wing (again, use a brush and cleanup outside edges) but its not the precise purpose.
The only downfall is that it can wear off by the end of the day, but sometimes if I get a good sealing spray it'll hang on. For long days or events bring it & a brush for touch ups!
TrashPanda from STL
I love it for all the reasons people seem to hate it- it smudges amazingly, it's big and chunky- it's a goth girl's dream. I wear dark, heavy eyeliner everyday, and this does exactly what I need. I've purchased 3x and I plan on continuing
Dee from Florida
i love this product. I have used IT, make up forever, NYX, and more. But maybelline this is it. It stays on, i love the true black it gives. it goes on so smooth. does not make my eyes water, nor does it irritate my eyes. that is important. I will be purchasing this again. this will be my staple for eyeliner
wanda06211 from clemson, sc
This is perfect for those of us of a certain age with no desire for "cat eyes."
DLK from Maryland
It's the only kohl product I'm aware of. My eyes don't seem to tolerate anything else. I just wish this could be sharpened easily, doesn't fit standard sharpeners.
Saloni from Austin
Hard to use, smudges a lot. I used it under eyes and within a few hours I had raccoon eyes.
blueeyedbeauty from North Carolina
I was so excited to try this product... However, it is not as reliable as my liquid eyeliner. I used LORAC Behind the Scenes Eye Primer before applying, and the line was jagged and inconsistent. Very unhappy and will be returning soon.
Bambam from Houston
It's difficult to apply. It skips over the eye lid so you need to apply it thicker to make it look smooth. Then you have to give black lives across your eyes. It also fades very quickly. It was almost completely gone after two hours. I need to return or exchange it for a different one but I've been busy with work. Literally on my only break today writing this review
Monica from Atlanta, GA
This eyeliner is garbage! It glides on great but will smear the minute you apply it! If you're looking for a waterproof eyeliner, I definitely don't recommend this product!
H from Indiana
This eyeliner smudges when you put in the waterline. Also, if you end up using it a lot, the tip ends up getting bigger which makes it difficult to use. There's no way to sharpen it or anything. I definitely won't be buying this product again.
Mick from michigan
My eyes keep turning pink/bloodshot
Lisa from Goodyear,AZ
This product works best with my allergies.
PS from Cincinnati
I use this product as an under eye liner and it's extremely easy to use. It goes on smoothly but wears out.!
Pam from Dothan Al
Easy to put on
meeeeee from Scottsdale
like then product...hoping it lasts a long time.
Terri from Amesbury, MA
Product goes on easily.
Sandi from Oca Raton
Ivo from Tennessee
I absolutely love this mascara and it is most definitely my holy grail eye liner!
jichelle03 from Lake Park GA
When the liner is new its amazing. There needs to be a way to sharpen or reshape the product.
Emme from Taos, NM
This eyeliner rocks!!
AJ from Federal Way, WA
Easy to control, but a bit difficult to achieve a defined, sharp cat eye.
Mike from Fargo, ND
I use this product on the upper eyelid waterline. It makes me look like I have that wide awake look, and makes me look like I have eyelashes with no mascara. It has not really noticed that I am wearing a product, the transformation is quite amazing. Its not irritating and it lasts my whole work shift. I have had extensive chemo and radiation so I have learned small tricks that correct my flaws.
She's Goldusted from Bryan, TX
This is the best liner for me. Easy to apply and allows me to get a effortless wing. On days where I want a little drama, It smudges well giving a good smoky eye without a lot of additional work. Most days this is the only eye product I use besides mascara.
S. London from Illinois
I for sure thought this was a good product until I catch pink eye. It took me a while to realize that this eyeliner caused it. I bought a new one a few days ago to give it a second try and I caught it again. I am sure I'm probably just allergic to something in it, but I will definitely not buy this product again.
Lorelei from Brentwood, CA
Single professional Mom...works for all the looks