Rated 4.44 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Cover Girl liquid eyeliner on (Perfect) Point!
I received this Perfect Point Plus liquid eyeliner in the shade Charcoal 205. I don't normally wear grey or charcoal colored eyeliner in general, regardless of the formula (liquid, gel, cream, powder, etc). However, I decided to indulge myself and give it a try. First, can I say that this eyeliner is so richly pigmented that the charcoal looks more like a soft black! As a black eyeliner gal (or I do 2 colors at once...black + whatever shade works with my eye look), that made my heart jump for joy. This eyeliner went on easier than most felt tipped liquid eyeliners tend to (*I am a huge fan of brush tipped eyeliners) and wore well all day without wearing away or flaking. Removal was easy, and there was zero irritation to my sensitive, contact lens wearer eyes. Results: I would definitely recommend this liquid eyeliner to anyone who likes felt tipped eyeliner applicators that dip into the little eyeliner well (versus the 1 piece pen style). I do use this style of liquid eyeliner about 50% of the time so I will definitely try additional shades in this line.
Most Helpful Critical Review not the worst but not the best. issues with tip.
I was SO excited to try this eyeliner because I'm a little bit of an eyeliner snob and eyeliner hoarder. They don't call me the queen of "wings" for nothing. Anyway, upon first look, the tip looked great. Super thin and what seemed like, precise, and very pigmented. At least it was on my hand when I tried it out. When using it on my actual eye, I found that the tip dried a little TOO rapidly which caused the very end of the tip of the applicator to begin bending and it is now a bit misshapen. I don't take a long time to put on my eyeliner at all, certainly not as long as the average person, so I believe that for others, their tips would dry out and become misshapen quite quickly, which essentially renders the eyeliner unusable. So it's kind of a toss up on the "rapid drying" being a plus and a minus. On the plus side, you don't have to worry about your liner going everywhere the moment you open your eyes because it's not dry yet, however on the minus side, you do have to continuously dip it back in to avoid it drying out instantly. A really good positive aspect of this eyeliner is that it IS very pigmented. The truest of black liners, which I really appreciate. However, again, because of how rapidly it dries, you will have to continue applying it in order to get a good solid and not patchy wing. So all in all, there are some pluses, there are some minuses, but for my personal needs, the minuses definitely outweigh the pluses. I believe that if the tip was made of individual hair fibers (like the KVD tattoo liner) that this liner would work much better. However, I believe this is a felt tip and it dries out entirely too quickly. All in all, if you like to take your time with applying your liner, I probably wouldn't recommend this product. HOWEVER, the very tip of the brush is quite thin (before it begins getting misshapen) so it's great for precision work.
Reviewed by 481 customers comes off instantly even after it dries
heather8 from pennsylvania
bought this as a first time user hoping it would be better than pencil liner well i was wrong it is worse goes on beautiful but last maybe a half hour one tiny wipe and it's gone i thought i didn't leave it dry and try it again was t he same way complete waste of money
Love this color
ash37 from undisclosed
I received this from Influenster to try & I loved it. I've never worn liquid eye liner before but this was amazing. The color looked shimmery & went on easily.
Liquid liner newbie!
all2thumbs from undisclosed
I rarely use liquid liners because I'm usually in a rush and can't wait for it to dry. However, this product is easy to use and relatively forgiving for one who rarely uses liquid liners: great to apply and creates sleek lines!
Love, love, love
nin1420 from undisclosed
Ok I absolutely love this eyeliner. The tip is very sharp and pointy so you can line very precisely. I did mess up trying to draw a cat eye but pretty sure I can learn how to do it with this eyeliner. I will definitely purchase this eyeliner when I run out.
Solid Basic matte brownish-black eyeliner
bourgeoisbarbie from undisclosed
Felt tip applicator, not water proof. Did not crack or flake. I wish it was a true brown instead of just another shade of black. I enjoyed it and I would recommend it. A well-performing budget-friendly basic liquid eyeliner.
cherylann18 from undisclosed
Im not a huge fan of liquid eye liner mostly because I do not have the steady hand that is required for application. But this has great pigmentation so it allows it to go on fast and you don't have to keep going over the lines and risk messing up what you've already done. It dries just fast enough that you are not left waiting forever, but still have enough time to make minor adjustments with a q-tip or similar tool. I like the applicator because it's not a brush. It a pointy little rubbery very bendable tip that allows you to bare down without poking your eye out. I was impressed. Still looks great hours later and no smudging or smearing.
rayeclover from undisclosed
I love this rich brown color and the felt like tip. it glides on smoothly and doesn't run everywhere or bleed out from the place you applied. I love a good liquid liner especially when it doesnt dry out quickly while applying. This is a dip liquid and I could remove from base and apply one eye completely before needing to dip it again. That speaks volumes to me when I dont have to continuously keep reaching for more product. The color was stunning amd not over bearing for my slightly pale skintone. I wore all day with no issues or need to reapply. Absolutely love!!!!!
honorem from undisclosed
I have been struggling to find a liquid liner that worked for me. This was exactly what I was looking for. I loved the formula and it was so easy to use. I have always preferred liner like this but I could never find one. The only thing keeping me from giving it a 5 is that it did crack after a few hours so it is something I had to touch up when I noticed it. Overall it works great and I'm trying to moisturize my eyelids more to see if that can solve my cracking problem because I do like this liner.
first time user
courtneytb4ee from undisclosed
for the first time ever using liquid eyeliner, it was easy to use, and easy to correct a mistake. color is perfect. it also dried quickly and didnt smudge when i blinked.
Covergirl Perfect Point Liner
mandib12 from undisclosed
Perfect Point Plus Liquid Liner Goes on smooth and last all day. No flaking or cracking. Wand is skinny enough to make thin perfect lines. It's definitely long lasting.
It's just ok
mandyb2312 from undisclosed
This eyeliner is good but I don't like the precision or the color. I thought I would like it cause I like charcoal colors but on my eyes it's not so good in my opinion cause I like the color really dark and this eyeliner is not that dark. It almost looks watered down a bit. It's good but not for me! Thanks covergirl!
ragekat from undisclosed
This was a breeze to apply, it was easy to fix a good up, and it was great all day long! I couldn't improve this product, it is an A+ eyeliner.
mellisabed60 from undisclosed
This is my favorite type of eye liner! I found it very easy to apply. It lasted all day and was easy to remove.
thecookiemonster35 from undisclosed
I received this compliments of Influenster to try but opinions are all my own.
I don't typically use liquid eye liner because I'm not the most coordinated. This however goes on clean and smooth-the line isn't too thick so a mess doesn't occur.
I work at a hospital so I don't wear a lot of makeup (hello mask life!) so if I do wear this it's on the weekends. It wears well and doesn't fade. I'd buy it!
abbynorrmal from undisclosed
The eyeliner itself is amazing, i unfortunately don't use brown eyeliner on myself, but I did use it a few days just to see if I could do it. It's not as bad as i thought, and it kinda makes my eyes pop a little better. I would definitely recommend, it is my go to!
Pretty and Easy to Use
d2thalo from undisclosed
I was lucky enough to get in on the Cover Girl Easy Breezy Eye VoxBox campaign and test this simply adoreable eyeliner! Having dark brown eyes means that I get to switch up my look a lot and this "chocolate" liquid liner did just that! My eyes looked great but not too bold for work with liquid. I usually save my liquid looks for night or special occasions but with this, ANYTIME is the right time! I took one star off because it cracks when you blink your eye or you curl your lashes after it dries or it comes off a little too easy with my watering itchy allergy eyes.
christinexcore from undisclosed
In the past, liquid liners never really worked well for me. I love the cat eye effect, but couldn't quite master it. The Perfect Point Plus liquid liner dries so quickly! No fear of messing up my look or having to redo my eyes. It also doesn't tug or drag when applying. I hate having to drag my eyelids to the side to get a solid line. No more flaking and no fade or fall-out and of course no nasty hidden ingredients.
amys8 from undisclosed
easy to remove if applied wrong, does seem to bleed a little upon application possibly a little too runny. would unfortunately not recommend. #EasyBreezyEyes #complimentary @COVERGIRL @Influenster
Nice liquid liner!
mimil4e5c from undisclosed
I really like this product. I got a charcoal gray color. I find myself using this almost every day! I can't see any improvements that need to be done. I like this because it applied neat and clean, lasted a very long time, and removed easily with micellar water or cleanser. I will definitely be getting a full size of this eyeliner.
Not my thing
lindseytbentley from undisclosed
Nothing necessarily negative to say, I just don't like liquid liner. Tried it a few times and it just didn't work for me.
The color was great and would buy in a pencil.
hannahl120 from undisclosed
This is such a good pigmented liner that stays all day but comes off easily with makeup remover
taylordf054 from undisclosed
I always struggle with liquid eyeliner but this product makes it easy to apply. Wonderful product and lasts all day!
jenniferh6dad from undisclosed
I'm not a big fan of liquid eyeliner but after receiving this product for testing I am a changed woman. I like it a lot.
dawnt28 from undisclosed
I really liked the Cover Girl perfect point plus eye liner in Grey. I done a mini winged eye looked and it really left a nice clean, no tucking on the eyelid, and it Didnt smear or run. I used it before I went to work and by the time I got home, it look like I just put it on. Its very long lasting.
turtlegang from undisclosed
This eyeliner is really good i love that it's long lasting and dries quickly I ran out of my other liner so I'm so glad I got this one! I also love that the tip is thin!