Product Reviews Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars
777 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Suprisingly good I usually don't like revlon i'm more of a bare minerals, urban decay, and pop beauty person but i was indeed desprate for new eyeliner and i did not have much more eyeliner to spare. I scurried to ulta wondering around for something cheap yet good. Then finally my eyes met with the plastic covering. I snatched it from the rack from which it was hanging, payed for it then thanked the cashier. I spent my drive home in fear for i was doubtful it would not work. ALAST i got home walked into the bathroom and started to apply the make up. WONDERFUL i said. Tears of joy running down my cheeks meeting each other at the end of my chin.(Long story short, BUY IT you won't be disappointed)
Most Helpful Critical Review SO disappointed! I have been using this eyeliner for 15 years, over the past year I think Revlon changed the formula because this liner is horrible now! It used to sharpen so easily and go on with no problem but now I can't even sharpen it without it breaking and if it's not sharpened I can't apply a nice thin line. I really want to cry because I really loved this liner but I will no longer be purchasing it. Now I have to fine a different brand and hope it is as great as this one WAS! Revlon, you have failed!
Reviewed by 777 customers Only one I'll use 5
ShuShu from Florence KY
I love this product and the color is perfect for green eyes
I would not buy this again 1
Nana from Lubbock Texas
I didn't like this eyeliner I don't know if it was dry or I'm not using it right so I won't recommend it
Not bad but not the best 4
Nn from Elk Grove
I wear eyeliner almost every day and has just tried this one. It is great for the waterline but is really creamy and difficult to use on the top lid. I prefer a eyeliner pencil.
Doesn't smudge and stays long 5
V from Pleasant Hill
Easy to apply and the liner stays long. It doesn't smudge or anything 10/10
not impressed... 1
Nadia from NC
extremely hard to use, the color came out unevenly. the smudger tool does not work the way you would want it too, and neither does the "sharpener" on the end. the texture was way too soft and it crumbles every time i try to use it or apply even a tiny bit of pressure. definetly would not recommend
I will not buy this again 1
Jacqueline from State
I have always loved Revlon Colorstay eyeliner. Been using it for years. I don't know if this eyeliner came from a bad batch or what. It was so gooey like gum that I couldn't even use it. I decided to freeze it for 24 hours just to see if that would fix the problem, and it was still gooey and breaking off. Too bad my hubby threw my receipt away, and now I'm out that money. I'm so disappointed that I have to look for another brand of eyeliner, because this was my absolute favorite.
Good liner at a great price 5
LizM from New York
Easily Glides in and Stays On
Doesn't Apply Smoothly 1
Athena from New Jersey
I bought the black violet color. It was super difficult to put on- dry and not very pigmented. Once it is on, it looks nice but my eyes were sore from how much I had to press to get any color payoff. Would not buy again.
Not as good as I remember 3
SC Mom from South Carolina
I used to love the Colorstay liner that was made in the early 2000s and 2010s, but they discontinued my favorite color and I moved on to a more expensive brand with a similar color. When I ran out of eyeliner, I thought I would give this another shot. Maybe I got an old one, but the pencil was dry and super waxy and the liner wore off by the end of my work day. In my memory, this was a much better product, I think it used to go on with a more creamy texture, didn't really pull your skin, and lasted all day. I returned this version.
I would give this product zero stars if I could!! 1
Me from IL
The lead is soft and breaks off when I'm tryi g to use it.
Complete opposite of colorstay 1
Hasana from NJ
I would not buy this product again. It's supposed to be long lasting but was just the complete opposite
Not smudge or waterproof 1
AJ from KCMO
I was very disappointed in this product. The actual product is much too soft for it's packaging, so with any sort of pressure it breaks off, making the sharpener tool totally useless. It also just smears everywhere throughout the day. Even after and hour I have flakes and smears from above the eyelid that have come down to under my eyes.
Terrible 1
DeltaRie from Indiana
Bought four colors, opened the black/violet, unable to get a line drawn AT ALL. The amount of pulling and dragging on the eyelid to get this pencil to leave the faintest of lines is ridiculous. I am stunned. The unopened pencils will be returned and I'm upset I got stuck with the one I opened. Defective product.
I love this eye pencil. And I would buy it again. 5
Makeup lover from I love home, USA
I love it that it glides on so easily. The color is great and it stays on all day.
I would buy again 5
J F from Charlotte,NC
I have been wearing this liner for years, so yes I love it. I have tried other brands(expensive ones too), but this is the best waterproof liner in my opinion.
Liner that STAYS!! 5
Ms. S from Rockledge FL
It last and it stays on!!! Love it! Still very small point where it applies! I hate when they liners wear and spin them out and it's a huge line where you're applying it.
i love llove love colorstay pencil eyeliner 5
car from illinois
I like shopping. at ulta they have large selection
Very bad 1
Amlu from Los angeles
Dry and opposite to creamy
So dry it barely goes on. 1
JS from KY, USA
I like the color but the eyeliner is so dry I can barely apply it. Not usable.
Dried up eyeliner 1
Nancy from Corpus Christi, Texas
Could not use product, very dried out, no color saturation. I was very disappointed with a almost $10.00 cost that I was unable to use it.
Would not buy this product again 1
Ange ann from Ny ny
The black pencil was not dark enough for my use
Would but again. 5
Shari from Anderson SC
The ease of use is one of the best, stays on does not smears
Terrible product 1
Shari from Scottsdale
I'm returning this as soon as I get the chance. The eyeliner tip broke on first use. Then again... normally don't buy Revlon - won't buy the eyeliner again
this item is terrible. does not work at all. 1
mary from ca
did not like this product at all. lost the receipt so i cant return
Lasts but not the smoothest 4
SartheH from Charlotte, NC
I cannot get a solid line, it's like if you draw with a crayon in one stroke, but repeat strokes don't seem to improve it. I will say it is a true colorstay product, and lasts all day.
