Product Reviews Rated 3.97 out of 5 stars
407 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Been using this for 20+ years I've used this eyeliner since college. Lest you think I'm just stuck in the 90's wearing frosty blue shadow, I'm Not! I continuously try new makeup and I have everything in my makeup shelves from Chanel to MAC to NYX. I've tried other liquid and creme and gel liners but this is by far my fave. It really only comes in black and brown (to not buy the carbon black one that's super black it has some smelly chemical in it) but the regular black and brown are great. Stays on all day. You can sleep in It, wake up and it's still on. It's not hard to remove though. A bit of sweet almond oil on a cotton ball does the job. Anywat, if you're not used to wearing liquid eyeliner it will take awhile to get the hang of, but you can do a thin, or thick line and be as understated or dramatic as you'd like to be. After about 3-4 months it starts to peel easily and not last all day, so I replace it quarterly. It's my fave, hands down.
Most Helpful Critical Review Please Bring Back the Brown Liquid Eyeliner Have solely used this eyeliner for many, many years, as I love the brush application, the way it would last all day and then wash off easily. As other reviewers have noted, the formula does appear to be different; it does flake now, which is uncomfortable for contact lens wearers (and needs constant touch-up). In addition, I've also experienced problems with the rubber stop coming off. But most distressing to me is the fact that this eyeliner is no longer available in brown. Black is too intense a color for blondes with blue eyes.I am forever shopping around trying to find an equivalent liquid eyeliner with brush tip in brown color, but it's getting more and more difficult to even find brush tips anymore (and I detest the felt tip liners, which seem to be the only kind available in brown). Plus, I need a hypoallergenic eyeliner, as most brands cause my eyes to itch and burn (yet your brand never did). So, as you can see my chances for finding what I need are slimmer than ever.
PS- Why don't you have an option for "gray" hair on your questionnaire below?
Reviewed by 407 customers no more color selection 4
bp82 from florida
love this eyeliner. now it is only sold in black. I loved the brown and gray shades, since i have white hair. Have to look for a new product
My Fave for 10 Years 5
Doll from Phoenix, AZ
I've been using this eyeliner for over ten years! I love that it has a brush tip instead of a felt tip. The brush glides easily and doesn't snag the skin, you can make lines as thin or thick as you want, and the liner doesn't crack or break off. This liner brought me through my emo phase and now my adult one. I still use it to make winged liner looks, or to outline my eye for dramatic looks. You can use it to make thin or thick lines, and even designs.This will always be my go to. I may have replaced other makeup with prestige brands, but I'll keep this eyeliner for as long as they make it.
I wouldn't buy it again. 3
Didn't last long from California
Didn't last long, started coming off after a while.
use to love this liner 3
cc from san diego
i used this liner in my teens and early twenties. the applicator is the best ive ever used and glides on smooth and the color is rich and pretty. i gave 3 stars because it is not water resistant. i had to buy a more expensive waterproof liner because i am a crybaby.
LOREAL QUALITY CONTROL APPARENTLY IN THE TOILET!! 1
Booch from Osage Beach, MO
Like another 1-star reviewer, I have been using this product for over 10 years and was pretty ticked off when they discontinued the brown shade, but I lived with it because it's so hard to find decent liquid eyeliner. But I just bought a brand-new one that was not only missing the plastic insert that helps keep the brush clean and thin, but the actual brush was bent at a 45-degree angle. No worries, I thought -- I'll use the brush from my depleted one. But because the plastic insert was missing, I got liquid eyeliner EVERYWHERE ... on my counter, on my hand, and all over my eyes and face because there was so much product that wasn't wiped off by the plastic insert that was missing, that it didn't dry on my eyes, just smeared everywhere. PURE GARBAGE, and I will never buy it again. And this is the 2ND TIME this has happened recently on this same product, missing the insert. L'Oreal is supposed to be a quality product -- HA! It used to be, but no more.
Black not my favorite but the Brown/Brun was. 3
Lushus from Nevada
I have been searching for this in brown/brun for the last year and a half with no luck. i used this product for over 10 years then it just disappeared in brown. I love the fact that it's a brush and not felt tip. Black is to harsh. Please, please please! bring back the Brown. It was perfect for us gals that like a not so dark line that is not drawn on with a hard pen.
It Smeared! 2
Koko from Washington, DC
The color was rich and the application was smooth. My biggest complaint is that the liner is NOT smudge proof. It took a long time to dry and smeared when I accidentally swiped it.
Love L?Or?al Eyeliner: 5
V Keyser from Ferguson, Mo
I love L?Or?al eyeliner. But I don?t like the black liner. I use to be able to buy the black-brown eyeliner. I can?t find it anywhere. What gives.
Love L'Oréal Eyeliner: 5
V Keyser from Ferguson, Mo
I love L'Oréal eyeliner. But I don't like the black liner. I use to be able to buy the black-brown eyeliner. I can't find it anywhere. What gives.
What happened? Quality control asleep 1
Fool me once from undisclosed
Intensitique extreme wear liquid eyeliner—there is no applicator inside the tube—somehow it got past the quality control and has made me bananas looking for it
What happened? Quality control asleep 1
Fool me once from undisclosed
Intensitique extreme wear liquid eyeliner?there is no applicator inside the tube?somehow it got past the quality control and has made me bananas looking for it
Frustrated 1
Tonnia from Ohio
I have used this eyeliner for years and I have used the dark brown. I cannot find it anywhere! The black is entirely too dark and flakes off terribly. L'Oréal has been my brand forever and unfortunately you are forcing me to go elsewhere. Lost a loyal customer.
Frustrated 1
Tonnia from Ohio
I have used this eyeliner for years and I have used the dark brown. I cannot find it anywhere! The black is entirely too dark and flakes off terribly. L?Or?al has been my brand forever and unfortunately you are forcing me to go elsewhere. Lost a loyal customer.
Loving this! 5
Thatonelady from Indiana
It was super smooth, application was flawless and it dries quick!
Yes it's so easy to use 5
Mari from Dallas Tx
Goes on smoothly, long lasting
I have used this eye liner for years and love it! 5
Deb from Coeur d Alene
The best!
Used to be the best 1
kleinap from Massachusetts
I've been using this eyeliner for over 30 years and loved it. My friends would ask what eyeliner doesn't run even after getting sweaty? Within the last year or so, at the slightest bit of moisture near my eyes, the eyeliner would flake off my eyelids and buyers of eyeliner would wind up in my eyes (and I apply the product above the upper lashes and below the lower lashes). At first I thought it was from having old product, but I just threw away my entire stash and bought a new bottle and am having the same issue.
I have been using this since last 10 years. I love it. 5
Saba from Colorado
I simply love this brand and the products.
730 liquid brown eyeliner 5
Califdosa from santa barbara, ca
I was reading over all the comments, seems to me that they are missing the market they built. please reconsider brining back the brush tip eyeliner in brown. I'm having to pay black market prices for your product. thank you for taking this to your department head.
***also...everyone should leave a comment, so they can see we are large in numbers***
What happened to this product!!! 2
Natalieks9 from Grand Rapids, MI
I've been using this for nearly 20 years and have never had a problem until recently. The eyeliner has started flaking off after only a few hours. I keep buying new bottles and have the same result. It also gushes out when you screw on the top causing eyeliner all over the sides. Only Good thing left is the brush applicator, very disappointing
PLEASE BRING BROWN BACK!!! 5
DBROWN from CHICAGO
Like everyone else, I have used the brown lineur liquid eyeliner for as long as I can remember. I am so disappointed that you have discontinued it! Not everyone can or wants to wear black liner!!! I have tried several other brands and nothing compares to the wearability and how it glides on... I even tried your suggestions, but they just don't look or wear the same.
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE BRING BROWN BACK!!!!
It seems to have changed 3
My my from Mesa, az
Used to buy thia all the time. Noticed the packaging and bottle was different, but it seems like the entire product has changed. Please bring back the old one. It was so much better!
Please bring back Brown!!!! 5
Erica I from Pine Bush, NY
I have been using this liquid eyeliner for years and love it. I am disappointed that you discontinued the brown shade. This is the only brush eyeliner available that glides on my eyes perfectly. I use the brown all the time and the black only with certain color palettes. Please consider bringing the brown back. in looking at other reviewer, they feel the same way and want the brown brought back.
Easy to use but errors readily fixable 5
Elisa the conservative makeup user from Dallas, TX
Love it!
Where's the BROWN? 3
805Melissa from undisclosed
I have used this type of liner for a long time and love the brown color since I have blue eyes. I cannot find it other than in black, which is extremely harsh for blue eyes and fair skin. Are you planning on making it in brown again?
