Product Reviews Rated 4.23 out of 5 stars
1569 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review BEST LIP LINER EVER! I always get asked what lip liner I use and I highly recommend this one. I've been using it for years. Spice seems to go with all my neutrals and mauves. Excellent liner and amazing price.
Most Helpful Critical Review Don't bother The crayon tip on the pencil breaks of *way* too easy. Would call it a waste of $$$$.
Reviewed by 1569 customers BLEEDS 3
leah from searcy arkansas
idk if it was this or the lipstick but it bleeds like a mf. i'm sure it was this because i've never had this problem with my lipstick.
not my favorite 3
Dawn from Hendersonville, NC
I lie the color of the lip pencil, It is a little too soft and waxy for me, I prefer an actual pencil, but it is ok.
Not the color pictured on the pencil! 1
JAXMOM from Virginia Beach, VA
The color on the packaging in no way matches the color in the pencil. It is like a light, frosty, Garden Club pink1
Nice 4
Ambie from Texas
Pretty good but mine came with the top broken off which is odd since it's sealed. But really good actually. Honestly it feels like it could be sold at $15 each so really worth it I think.
Hard pass 1
Bugaboo from The field
Went on okay, felt okay, then there was the flavor ruined everything. Absolutely awful.
Great for Lips and Unique compliments lipstick ❤️ 5
L❤️ from NV
Every Day my Lip Liner 👏🏻
This is the perfect lip liner 5
Suzy from Towson
I've been using this lip liner for a while. It's the best I've ever tried. It's a great value for the price .It comes in a nice range of colors.
No 1
Laura from Midland Tx
I wouldn't recommend this product
Super easy to apply👌🏻 5
Jd from Ohio
It glides on perfectly to my lips. It's very easy to apply and happens to perfectly match my favorite lipstick! 10/10 recommend!😍
great 5
m from houston
did as expected and stayed on
LOVE THIS LIP LINER! 5
The Bon from Morgantown, PA
VERY NICE LIP LINER THAT LASTS ALL DAY!
Color was not expected 3
Batman.1387 from Oklahoma
The color goes on lighter than I thought it would. Good product but I needed it to be darker.
Loved it 4
Jordyn from Saint Paul Minnesota
It was creamy and pigmented, glided on easy. The color looked a little funny on me. Other than that it was great
I cannot begin to express how much I love this product! 5
luna from Los Angeles, CA
This product is amazing! I don't like products that are too light or too dark so this was the perfect compromise. I bought 3 other colors but this one was definitely my favorite. It's a very good alternative for other expensive lip liners that do the exact same thing. The only thing I'd change is that it would stay on longer and not come off so easily.
Love it 5
Darlene from Waukesha, WI
Use this on all the time. It pretty close to the color I always buy was Loreal Colour Riche "Toffee To Be".
So now I know I can go to either brand in case if I can't one in the store.
I love this color Mocha (mauve) 5
Darlene from Waukesha, WI
I have made on this color before and came back to order this. Love this that it is creamy and smooth.
Cocoa is not deep brown 4
Darlene from Waukesha, WI
The color (Cocoa) is not really deep brown. The application is creamy and smooth. I will use it from time to time.
Much lighter than the packaging looks 3
Busy swimmom from Missouri
I use this to line my lips with a long-lasting lip color and the lip liner was faded so fast compared to the lipstick and the lipstick didn't bond to it so it looked really odd. Also the color was a lot lighter than what the packaging suggests it's like three shades lighter. So if you want a true Berry color you have to find something darker. Understandably with covid you can't try things on but it would be nice if they at least had a piece of paper or something like that with what it really looks like instead of going by the packaging.
I wish this came in a pencil that I can sharpen myself 3
N. from California
Great color however, I was so disappointed when I found out that this is only available in the automatic sharpening. It was better when it came in a pencil form that I could sharpen. Please make this available in a pencil again.
Love this product 5
Rhonda from Sparks Nv
I use this liner and then use the Ulta matte lipstick over it.
Perfect shade 5
Sherlyn from Oxford
I actually sold avon to get their lip liner. (Spice) this is almost identical. What I love about this shade is that it can go with nudes, pinks or reds. Its the perfect tint.
great application, fades easily 3
anonymous from CA
this goes on great and I love that it's a twist up liner so no sharpening I just wish it lasted on better. wipes off pretty easily.
love 4
HVeasy from Arkansas
I use this with pretty much all of my colored lip products (gloss, lipstick, etc). it helps with bleeding when I dont feel I need a super defined lip and a more natural look.
This is my third purchase 5
jktejas from North Bergen, NJ
It is exactly the shade and texture I want.
Love this product so far! 5
Lish from Ohio
Great subtle color and coverage.
