Product Reviews Rated 3.16 out of 5 stars
500 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review simply the best The liner pen side of this is my absolute favorite I have ever tried! I have been using the same one for about 3 months now and it still has not run out but I bought a back up just in case. It works so well for cat eye liner as well as tight lining my upper lid and lasts all day long. The kohl liner side however I do not use because it makes my eyes burn as I apply. I have tried nyx's skinny liner pen and fat liner pen but they for some reason never lasted as long as the two timer... Because of the price, quality and number of uses I have gotten out of this I will not use anything else.
Most Helpful Critical Review Didn't work well I bought this product 2 days ago and today is my first time using it, I love NYX so I was expecting a pretty good product. However I was able to get the majority of my right eye finished before the felt tip ran out of eyeliner. I tried shaking it and closing it but nothing came out. I was resorted to use the kohl eyeliner (I didn't have anything else on me) which I know isn't typical for full winged eyeliner, but anyways it kept breaking when I barely put pressure on it and barely put any product on till I pressed hard and dragged it on my eyelid. Also by the end of this I only had have of the stick left.
Reviewed by 500 customers I wouldn't buy this again 2
? from CO
I use the pencil under eye and works great use liquid for top and it stops working after one eye application. Not happy
Didn't like it 1
MelG from Hamden, CT
Did not like the this eyeliner. The pencil portion tip broke right away and the gel liner part was dry.
Expected better 2
Topazgoblin from Grand Junction, Colorado
I bought this eyeliner around mid July, I thought it would be a good eyeliner. Nope, wears off after wearing it for three hours, I need to wet the felt tip before applying just in order to get an opaque application of liner on my eyes. The crayon side glides on smoothly but will wear off and turn into raccoon eyes after a few hours of wearing. Never buying again.
Horrible 1
Natalie from Ohio
Used it once, wasn't very good. Used it again and the liquid side was dried out, and the pencil side broke and it wasn't even twisted up very far. Will not be buying again.
YES 4
MEME from Georgia
NOTHING SPECIFIC TO COMMENT - I LIKE THE PRODUCT
I will never buy this product again. 1
Mel from Middlebury IN
Horrible product. It goes on like it's the very last bit of eyeliner in the product, even when it's brand new.
No 1
Amy from Paris, Tn
Terrible! Dries out before I can even get a line across my eyelid!
The felt tip side is bad 1
M from San Diego, CA
The crayon side is fine but the felt tip side was so bad. It would barely come out and when it did work, it wasn't smooth at all and did that weird thing where it cuts off.
Love it! 5
Sabeka from Avenel, New Jersey
Eyeliner was always the most difficult part of makeup for me because I have a bit of a Shakey hand. But it's effortless with this liner.
I wish I checked the reviews before I bought it 1
Victoria from Palm Coast, Fl
I wish I read the reviews online! The felt tip cap came off too easily so everytime I opened my makeup bag I found the cap off and the tip dry. I was so upset and out of eyeliner till I bought a cheaper Elf brand one which was way less disappointing. NYX should be ashamed to make this garbage.
worst eyeliner 1
KateB from Sydney, Australia
Not worth any money let alone the price, bought it and swatched it on my hand, felt tip was dried out, the colour was far from a true black and came up more as a grey. In order to get any kind of pigment you have to press down hard, an act that is not safe for an eye related product. Overall dissapointing, regret buying it
Dried up after the first use. 1
Wowo from Gainesville, Fl
The black was bit as deep as I expected and did not last part one use. I returned it.
Terrible! 1
Summer from Concord
Worked ok on my hand but was so hard it was almost impossible to get a wing. Also pretty dry.
Worst Liner Ever 1
Samia Rahman from Bangladesh
I love NYX Cosmetics products but The eyeliner is the worst liner ever I've tried in my life. The felt tip dries out after 1stroke also not black at all. Had much expectation on this product.
I wouldn't purchase this again 1
Nikki from Owensboro,Ky
It was almost as if it was dried out or wouldn't come off. It was very faint and you had to push pretty hard to use it.
Waste of money 1
Lovely Reyes from Moriches
I am extremely disappointed at this item. The felt tip doesn't work. Just don't waste your money out of it. Now i just use the pencil section to make my money worthwhile somehow.
It's okay 2
Mannie from Fresno
Liquid liner is not smooth lining so it makes it difficult to get that precise cat eye. And it's not so black, I would say grey black.
Felt tip end sucks 2
Mary from Glendora, ca
The crayon end is really good and applies easily, but the felt tip end is pretty bad. I had to put a lot of pressure for it to work, and didn't even work well.
Sad 1
Ang from Texas
I purchased this and was super excited but when took it out of the box it was completely dried out. Returned it for Morphe.
Don't buy 2
Stephghff from Michigan
The felt tip dried out after the first use and barely showed up on my lid and the kohl liner's tip broke off the first time I used it. It also did not go on my water line at all and was flaking off the rest of my lid. I tried to go over it with the felt end and it just rubbed it off making a huge mess. Very disappointed.
I will not buy again 1
Crafty from Charlotte, NC
Smeared everywhere after 2 hours of wear even with a primer.
Dry felt tip 2
Tine from Fort wayne in
Love the pencil side but was having issues with the felt tip drying out. I was a little bummed I haven't really had this problem with my eyeliners before
It's ok 3
Novahorrify from Fontana CA
I feel like I should've stuck to Nyx's Epic Ink Liner considering it's a dollar cheaper and seems like it runs smoother than this felt tip. Also this kohl liner is NOT waterline friendly and not because it smudges. It won't stick to my waterline at all! Not only that but after trying no other product would stuck to my waterline until I went over it with a wipe. Maybe the kohl liner would be better as a base for the felt liner? That's the only thing I can think of
Just ok 3
Islandgirl62 from VA
Used daily, was disappointed in the quality of this product.
DONT BE FOOLED 1
Rebecca from WA
Yet another in a long line of products claiming to do two things well and absolutely failing at doing either. The tip of the pencil liner immediately broke off. When I tried to use the liquid liner on top of the pencil, it lifted it off, and flaked onto my cheeks. The smudged black remains stayed on my lid and lower lashline for two full days, so it had staying power at least. I looked like an absolute mess, and felt like I had been robbed. Nyx has some great liquid liners and pencil eye liners, this is not one of them.
