Product Reviews Rated 3.91 out of 5 stars
413 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review This is a wonderful... This is a wonderful and natural looking product for people with acne and acne scars. I have very oily skin, and this doesn't break down and wear off like all of the liquid concealers that I've used in the past. I find that it applies best with a tiny smudge brush that I used to use for eye makeup. Directly applying with the tip of the crayon can leave harsh edges and a cakey finish. The smallest amount makes a huge difference!
Most Helpful Critical Review One Star for the New Formula This used to be an awesome concealer until they changed the formula. Despite the folks at L'Oreal insisting that the formula has not changed - it has. The pictures attached clearly shows that. The original had a smaller tip, and although shinier than the new fatter tip, it was a matte finish. The new formula is so greasy it doesn't cover and it doesn't last. I drew a line in ink on my hand and held it to the light. You can see how the newer formula is shiny and doesn't cover the line, while the old crayon did. Very disappointed L'Oreal!
Reviewed by 413 customers Love this product - but why it is pointed? 3
Kimbo58 from Washington DC
I love this product and have used it for several years. However, the fact that it is has a pointed tip escapes me. (I mean, it's called a "crayon," but really?) It seems the product is a bit creamier in texture now, which is nice, but the first time I swipe it under my eyes, the tip breaks off! This has happened with EVERY TUBE I've used in the past couple of years. I have to squish the tip back down on the base, but it still comes off every time I use it. SO FRUSTRATING! Why don't you make the tip more rounded and less pointed? There is no way to twist the new product further down into the tube. I am not sure I can buy this product any more, and I do love it. Nothing else works as well on my very dark undereye circles. I would like a replacement product, please. Maybe the amount in the base - after the tip breaks off - will make up for what I lost in that tip. Please contact me to get my mailing information so you can send me a new tube. Thank you.
Had to do multiple layers 3
Ren from Usa
Idk if it's just me because I have extremely dark under eyes but this barely covered anything. Did match to my skin alright but I wouldn't buy it again.
Works as well as luxury brands 5
janfed7 from Elmhurst, Illinois
I use this to cover blemishes, acne scars - and it's just perfect. I've tried EVERY concealer and this one works without causing irritation or further breakouts Some I've used just make the breakouts worse. The consistency is just right...it's soft, but not liquid (obviously), I carry 2 colors with me at all times (fair and 4-5).
It's a shame 1
Disappointed in TX from San Antonio, TX
I purchased this product; it is great, does not irritate my eyes, but you cannot find a sharpener for it. So you only get a few uses and that's it! WASTE OF $$$$$$$
Nice 4
Ari from Arizona
Reeeeally really nice blend. Definitely dries down but not to fast to work. Pigmented
Formula has changes 1
Clm72 from undisclosed
I have used and loved the crayon for years to cover a raised dark birth mark. Sadly the formula has been changed and it is too sheer and thin to do the job. I was very disappointed that my go to product was modified. The search continues for a replacement.
There's better 2
danay from Florida
Was disappointed in this product. It blends well, but in the process, it didn't cover, as though there wasn't enough pigment in it, like watered down paint would be. I returned it for another brand.
Changed the formula 1
dayz from Mcallen
I have been buying this concealer for years and was disappointed to see they have changed the formula. It is much more sheer and oily than it was before and I no longer use it. I wish they would revert to their older formula, it was so much better
Great 5
UdyJones from New York, NY
Wonderful and creamy. Applies smoothly and blends well
Fair still isn't fair enough 3
redheadedmandy from Herndon, VA
Unfortunately, this concealer shade did not work for me; it was noticeably warmer and a tad darker than my skin. The formula is decent, I think, but it's hard to say because I couldn't wear it out in public.
I'm a very fair-skinned redhead with neutral-cool undertones. The old L'Oreal Infallible stick concealer (in the red tube) was my ride or die concealer from the moment I started wearing makeup to the day it was discontinued. (I don't think I'll ever forgive L'Oreal for getting rid of it.)
I have a strong preference for stick concealers, because liquid formulas don't work well on my skin and potted creams are inconvenient. Unfortunately, I've yet to find another stick concealer that works on my extremely pale skin.
Daily go to 5
Dewy dreamer from San Mateo, CA
I love this concealer! I purchased it impulsively at my local drugstore and instantly fell in love. I love a natural/dewy finish and this gives it perfectly without being too much. I also have borderline dry skin and this concealer is one of the only ones that doesn't crease/dry down too powdery and keeps my undereyes well hydrated but not greasy. It does tend to settle into creases a bit under the eyes, but I have this problem with every single concealer I use due to my eye shape. I also like the medium coverage it offers as I'm more into the natural look. I wouldn't recommend this for covering up super prominent blemishes, as it doesn't really have enough coverage for that, but it's great if you have a few spots of pigmentation/acne scarring you want to cover/conceal while still keeping your skin looking like skin (ticking all boxes for me!). Great product overall, my new holy grail.
Love this 5
Jazz from Nj
Def easy to use
Dry and not very bendable 2
Gigi19 from Homestead, FL
I bought this as an emergency concealer. It's so dry and bad that I still have it and it's intact.
It's like butta! 4
purttiegurl from Brawley, CA
This goes on like butta! So smooth and easy to blend. I just wish I got a darker color, but love it!
Great results 5
Cool60 from Canton, Georgia
I used the Crayon Concealer and was wonderful on my dark circles under my eyes. I have been looking for a concealer and I found the right one. I love this concealer and the color is totally a match for my skin tone with my dark underage circles. Thank you L'Oreal. I wish I could get a case of these if they were not too expensive.
The best shades! 5
Sevengrace from Plainfield, IL
This concealer works so well at hiding imperfections and stays put for hours. I use with the matching powder and it's a flawless-looking result!
I would buy this product again 5
Carrie from New Bern, NC
I use it under my eyes as concealer
great conceal no crease 5
Jamiecarey24 from Collinsville, OK
My daughters and I all have used and liked this one, works great on most skin types
great conceal no crease 5
Jamiecarey24 from Collinsville, OK
My daughters and I all have used and liked this one, works great on most skin types
Good product 4
Ada from San Antonio
It's a great eyelid primer and its also good to clean up the eyebrows. I like this but not for under the eye, it doesn't work good for covering dark circles
Super easy to travel with! 4
GirlinSeattle from seattle, WA
I love the product, but I need more coverage. For ease, it's a great product and it's creamy and blendable. I did a yellow corrector underneath it and it helped. Great concept!
Fantastic! 5
Smile's from Columbus, Indiana
This concealer is definitely great for a touch up or traveling purposes!
I would buy this again 5
Taty from Tampa Florida
Loved this product, use it for my eye brows for that perfect sharp arch !
Crayon Concealer 4
Hey Nurse! from Hampton Roads, VA
I love this crayon concealer. It's perfect for travel and every day use, and I love how nicely it blends with liquid or powder foundation. In the past, I've found that the L'oreal True Match coordinates with my skin tone the best.
Excellent coverage! 5
MrsMom7211 from Cortlandt Manor, NY
My age is catching up to me and at 36 years old I definitely need an excellent concealer. The super blendable crayon is perfect!
