Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product
I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it
I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 13650 customers Waterproof, but Smudges BADA
KayyBee from Texas
The mascara was just okay. I didn't get any kind of volume from it even after three coats. And it smudges like CRAZY. That's with one coat or three. Go ahead and skip this one.
KGraham from Aurora
When I took the wand out it had so much mascara on it. The shape of the tube at the top doesn't help. You can't wipe any excess off, and there was plenty of it. I wasn't even able to put any on because I could tell it would be a mess. I'm disappointed.
Believe the hype!
Mia 🍵💋 from Media
Great I use this before falsies and it works great!
bre from morganton,nc
perfect waterproof mascra
don't recommend to anyone.
BB from Pennsylvania
The picture might make it look bigger but it is the length of my index finger. The shape of the brush makes it hard to reach all the lashes and if you move it in one wrong direction it will look like there are black spiderwebs all over your lashes. don't buy it it's not worth your money.
G from Texas
Used to be my favorite mascara, but now it's just too clumpy.
Raccoon eyes here I come!
OlySal from Olympic Peninsula
This may be "waterproof" but it is not smudge proof. By the end of the day I have black circles under my eyes and black marks on my eyelids! The brush does a poor job of separating my lashes as noted in other reviews!
I would not buy this product again.
Roberta from Seymour Indiana
Didn't like it
This mascara is not worth the money.
Michelle from Winchester, Ky
It is a struggle using this mascara. Not worth the hassle. It's super clumpy and the brush hairs stick to the stick ughh.
By far my favorite mascara ever!!! Love, love
Pammy from Baytown
Stays on all day like water proof, but then comes off easily at bedtime.
Travel Size is the way to go!!
Emily from United States
I don't like the full size of this mascara because of how thick it is, but the travel size is PERFECT! My favorite mascara because it isn't clumpy and it's very lengthening. Again ONLY the travel size of this mascara
Not what it used to be
Laura from Colorado
This used to be my go to mascara for beautiful, long, lush lashes. The formula must have changed because now, its clumpy, flaky, and does nothing for me except darken and define my lashes.
The volume is great but, that's all you get, definition of short, chunky, unnatural looking lashes.
Doesn't Stay Put For Waterproof
Erica from Houston, Texas
I wasn't sure if it was my eyeliner or mascara that made me look like a racoon by lunchtime. Playing process of elimination, I discovered it was this mascara. It's supposedly waterproof but it transfers everywhere. And what stays on my lashed just clumps up.
Pam from SD
It clumped on my eye lashes
JEANZ from Sandy, Utah
This product was too expensive and didn't live up to the HYPE. Ended up giving it to my daughter to use with her fake eyelashes.
KH from Indiana
I really like this! I did not buy waterproof, and I don't see where this one says it's waterproof. So I was confused by other reviews. But I bought the travel size to try it out before I dove in for the full size, it's pricy. But I really like this and will eventually buy the full size.
Best mascara hands down
Kristie from OH
I love this mascara, no clumping, lengthens my lashes and does not smear or smudge. Does not dry my eyes out either. But does dry up after 9-12 months use (it should've been thrown away way before that).
This mascara was a real disappointment.
Lauren from Jax., Fl
I am always trying out mascara. Someone told me this was a good product., so I was happy to give it a try. Nope. It is thick, clumpy, doesn't seem to dry and it transfers very easily. The brush is too thick, so it makes it next to impossible to get the lashes in the corner and edge of your eye. Also, it is very difficult to remove even with mascara remover. When this was my only tube, I actually passed on wearing it. I would rather go without than to use this brand. I headed back to Ulta for Lancome which is the best mascara I've found. Even the Ulta rep. voiced the same complaints about better than sex.
Gina from GA
After reading many reviews and also trialing the non-waterproof formula, I purchased, mainly with rewards $'s, the waterproof formula. Do not waste your money. It flakes and smudges. Not sure how why the other positive reviews. Very disappointing.
AL from Louisiana
So disappointed with this product. I purchased this thinking that waterproof meant that it wouldn't transfer to my under eyes/eyelids, but it's all over my eyes by the time lunch rolls around and at the end of the day I look like a raccoon. The wand is bulky and makes it difficult to reach all my lashes without getting it all over my face. Frustrating to say the least, I would not buy this product again.
I have used it with a primer and it helps a little bit, but still transfers throughout the day.
Would not come off!!!
Ashley from Michigan
Love this brand of mascara. The BEST. However, the waterproof I will never buy again. I could not get it off!! Used every makeup remover. Have just ordered the regular and can't wait :)
Ginger Accountant from Portland, Oregon
I have tried tons of mascara as they roll out new formula, engineer better applicators etc. This one is a huge disappointment. I could tell I was going to hate it as soon as I opened the tube. The applicator brush is enormous which means zero precision for corners. Formula is ultra thick and dry, so so dry. There is no more length than any other drug store brand - and if by volume they mean hideous spider leg clumpy bumpy lashes ... ick
I am thankful for Ulta's return policy.
My holy grail mascara
Olivia from Columbus, Oh
I love this product. The travel size is perfect for using up before the product expires/needs to get tossed. This mascara lengthens my already long thick lashes and gives them a thick look. I've never had problems looking spidery with this and fall out throughout the day is minimal. This is my holy grail mascara.
Not buying this product again
Shona from Philadelphia
This product was SO dry and flakey. Heavily disappointed.
This wasn't as amazing as I hoped
Ally from Brentwood Ca
Every time I used it at work it would run under my eyes. So much for waterproof.